Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Indiewire logo

Top Ten Politically Effective Films: #2

ReelPolitik By Anthony Kaufman | ReelPolitik August 23, 2011 at 11:35AM

Top Ten Politically Effective Films: #2
1

Once you start toying with a list of politically powerful movies, it's hard to restrict yourself to just a handful.

And while starting off with "Do the Right Thing" last week seemed like a natural first entry, I've been struggling to decide between several possibilities for a number two. (Foreign, doc, anti-war?) And while these are not in any particular order, there is obviously some sort of hierarchy established, whether I intend it or not.

So let me emphasize that my order is random, and that my second pick, Michael Moore's "Roger and Me" -- released in the same year as "Do the Right Thing" -- comes without any specific reason, except that it's one of the most profoundly resonant and sustained arguments about the plight of the working class in America than anything made since.

The film's precursor "Harlan County U.S.A." comes close, and I was considering devoting an entire entry to Barbara Kopple's coal mining nonfiction epic, but I believe Moore's montage is more effective, more enduring and, well, more compelling.

Moore's juxtapositions are priceless; as stark and dynamic as the work of Sergei Eisenstein. In "Roger and Me," Moore makes an art out of such dialectics, cutting back and forth between upper-crusty white aristocrats lounging at a luxurious picnic with a news story about rats overcoming the town's human population; harrowing housing evictions with a children's choir singing at a GM Christmas party; the urban blight of rows and rows of bombed-out-looking houses with the Beach Boys' "Wouldn't It Be Nice?" on the soundtrack. I can't think of another contemporary filmmaker who has mastered ironic counterpoint as much as Moore: When I teach film classes about editing and the power of juxtaposition, I show the killing/baptism climax of "The Godfather" and the Beach Boys scene from "Roger and Me."

I don't think Moore has made a better film since "Roger and Me." While there are sequences in "Bowling for Columbine" (a murderous montage), "Fahrenheit 9/11" (the credit sequence in which the architects of America's perpetual war are seen getting ready for interviews through live feeds) and "Sicko" (the heartbreaking testimony of insurance victims) that aspire to the level of arch-irony and disturbing social comment that exists in "Roger and Me," there is a kind of knowingness and self-consciousness that keeps Moore's later films from a more genuine outrage.

While Moore's manipulations of chronology and certain factual minutiae can be criticized, I don't think they are egregious enough to undermine his overall project. As film essayist, I'd say he is allowed some wiggle room, after all. As New York Times critic Vincent Canby wrote in his review of "Roger and Me": "Playing fair is for college football. In social criticism, anything goes."

Writing about "Fahrenheit 9/11" in 2004 in a post I titled "Truth is Fiction", I argued: "Moore is just another manipulative storyteller in a crowded field of manipulative storytellers, which includes everyone from ABC News to CNN to that 'objective' purveyor of 'fair and balanced' reporting, Fox TV. In his book 'Spike, Mike Slackers and Dykes', John Pierson counters the Moore-bashing with a quote from filmmaker Jean-Luc Godard: “You can start with either fiction or documentary. But whichever you start with, you will inevitably recall the other.”

This article is related to: Political Docs

Follow us

E-Mail Updates



Recent Comments

By Bob Connors: The thing to remember is the video has some actual data but it's conclusions are far fetched and inaccurate. This is a Progressive propaghand…

Who is "Politizane" and What's Next for the Income Inequality Viral Video

Mar 21th, 2015 8:47am

By Ostlee: This makes very sad reading - i feel for the people of Maldives. Everyone should boycott the island as a holiday destination until Nasheed…

Documentary Filmmakers and Activists Call for Release of "Island President" Nasheed

Mar 13th, 2015 5:35pm

By Ahmed Shahid: Release the first democratically elected president. The only president of Maldives who has reached the people of Maldives, heard them and…

Documentary Filmmakers and Activists Call for Release of "Island President" Nasheed

Mar 12th, 2015 9:37am

By Hanne Neve: Please take care of your country and the climate by freeing your real selektet president.

Documentary Filmmakers and Activists Call for Release of "Island President" Nasheed

Mar 11th, 2015 9:09am

By Iqbal: Please release President Nasheed

Documentary Filmmakers and Activists Call for Release of "Island President" Nasheed

Mar 10th, 2015 10:27pm

By Martha Robertson: I strongly urge the immediate release of Nasheed!

Documentary Filmmakers and Activists Call for Release of "Island President" Nasheed

Mar 10th, 2015 9:37pm

By Ned Rollins: Bad business, going to bite you.

Documentary Filmmakers and Activists Call for Release of "Island President" Nasheed

Mar 10th, 2015 3:47pm

By John Painter: The guy isnt a terrorist.

Documentary Filmmakers and Activists Call for Release of "Island President" Nasheed

Mar 10th, 2015 12:00pm

By Sofia Vera: I support Presdient Nasheed and add my name to this letter of support for his release.

Documentary Filmmakers and Activists Call for Release of "Island President" Nasheed

Mar 10th, 2015 11:14am

By Margarett R Mulkey: A civilized society is required of the current government of the Maldives. The world is watching injustice and crimes, and many realized thes…

Documentary Filmmakers and Activists Call for Release of "Island President" Nasheed

Mar 10th, 2015 10:53am