Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
David Denby Stepping Down as New Yorker Film Critic David Denby Stepping Down as New Yorker Film Critic 'Under the Skin' Edges 'Boyhood' in the Guardian's Top 10 Movies of 2014 'Under the Skin' Edges 'Boyhood' in the Guardian's Top 10 Movies of 2014 Film Comment's Best Movies of 2014: 'Boyhood' Plus 'Birdman,' Plus a Cotillard Twofer Film Comment's Best Movies of 2014: 'Boyhood' Plus 'Birdman,' Plus a Cotillard Twofer The Liberating Joy of Quitting a TV Show The Liberating Joy of Quitting a TV Show A.O. Scott Names 'Boyhood' the Best of 2014, Also Loves 'Ida,' 'Selma' A.O. Scott Names 'Boyhood' the Best of 2014, Also Loves 'Ida,' 'Selma' Wide Margins and Surprises in Indiewire's Film Critics Poll Wide Margins and Surprises in Indiewire's Film Critics Poll The New Yorker's Richard Brody Named Chevalier, Offers Top 10 List The New Yorker's Richard Brody Named Chevalier, Offers Top 10 List What Happened to 'Dying of the Light?' Just What's Happening to Independent Filmmakers What Happened to 'Dying of the Light?' Just What's Happening to Independent Filmmakers Manohla Dargis' Top 10 Times 2: 2014 Had Many Great Movies, and Not Nearly Enough Diverse Ones Manohla Dargis' Top 10 Times 2: 2014 Had Many Great Movies, and Not Nearly Enough Diverse Ones HuffPo's Maureen Ryan Names 'Orange Is the New Black,' 'Jane the Virgin' to Her Top 10 TV Shows of 2014 HuffPo's Maureen Ryan Names 'Orange Is the New Black,' 'Jane the Virgin' to Her Top 10 TV Shows of 2014 Barbed Wire: Ten Plagues Upon 'Exodus: Gods and Kings' Barbed Wire: Ten Plagues Upon 'Exodus: Gods and Kings' Daily Reads: The Disappearance of Mid-Budget Movies, the Most Exciting Working Cinematographers and More Daily Reads: The Disappearance of Mid-Budget Movies, the Most Exciting Working Cinematographers and More Every Star Trek Episode Ever, Ranked: The Behind-the-Scenes Story Every Star Trek Episode Ever, Ranked: The Behind-the-Scenes Story The Dissolve Publishes Big Checklist of 2014 Films, from 'Interstellar' to 'Inherent Vice' The Dissolve Publishes Big Checklist of 2014 Films, from 'Interstellar' to 'Inherent Vice' Cahiers du Cinema's Top 10 Movies of 2014: 'Goodbye to Language,' 'Under the Skin,' 'Love Is Strange' Cahiers du Cinema's Top 10 Movies of 2014: 'Goodbye to Language,' 'Under the Skin,' 'Love Is Strange' A.V. Club's Worst of the Year List: 'Left Behind,' 'Winter's Tale,' 'Atlas Shrugged' and More A.V. Club's Worst of the Year List: 'Left Behind,' 'Winter's Tale,' 'Atlas Shrugged' and More Daily Reads: How PT Anderson Saved (and Ruined) Adam Sandler, Why 'The Hobbit' Turned Out So Badly Daily Reads: How PT Anderson Saved (and Ruined) Adam Sandler, Why 'The Hobbit' Turned Out So Badly The Scrambled Sexuality of 'Frozen's "Let It Go" The Scrambled Sexuality of 'Frozen's "Let It Go" Daily Reads: An Oral History of 'Boogie Nights,' Paul Thomas Anderson's Best Actors and More Daily Reads: An Oral History of 'Boogie Nights,' Paul Thomas Anderson's Best Actors and More Criticwire Survey: How to Make a Top 10 List Criticwire Survey: How to Make a Top 10 List

Criterion's Flash Sale: Just Say No

Criticwire By Edwin Arnaudin | Criticwire February 26, 2014 at 1:57PM

The deals are great, but take a minute before you fill up your cart.
20
Fox

Shortly after noon yesterday, my Twitter feed lit up with the kind of activity only one type of news can ignite. The Criterion Collection had announced one of its 24-hour flash sales and my fellow film journalists flocked to the site's online store and began stocking up on 50 percent off goodies.

Soon I was flooded with purchase suggestions and screenshots of carts full to varying degrees, and per usual when these events come along I couldn't help but browse myself. Doing so inevitably led to placing temptations into my own cart and entering the promo code to see precisely how good of a deal I would receive.

$20 for the Blu-ray of "Days of Heaven," my favorite Malick film to be given the Criterion treatment? Sounds pretty good. $62.50 for the "America Lost and Found: The BBS Story" box set? Hell, that's just under $9 per film... $7 if I slum it with the DVD version.

I still had some birthday money left over and there was a little extra in the checking account. Why not go ahead and click that beautiful green "Proceed to Checkout" button?

Likewise per usual at this juncture, my mind became crowded with questions, each one a pin ready to poke holes in what at first seemed like an easy decision.

How often would I really watch these movies? What about the ones I already own, many of which I've seen once, maybe twice since purchasing (and even fewer whose bonus features, often a key selling point, I've exhausted)? And what about all the movies I haven't seen that I keep putting off, often in the name of revisiting old favorites?

The more I think about it, the less cultivating a personal film library has a place in my life. Would I love to own the complete Criterion Collection? Of course. Is the cost feasible? No. Is owning the entire thing even rational? That depends on the person, but strictly from a film-watching perspective, I don't think it is.

It's a shift from where I was 10, even five years ago, but one that's a combination of packing up and moving an ever-growing number of discs almost yearly from 2002-10 (college, grad school, and a string of one-year leases); the rise in affordable streaming services; my librarian past and seeing the benefits of a communal film collection (especially since many North Carolina systems have entered into a consortium); becoming friends with more film enthusiasts, each of whom have their own personally tailored collections from which they're eager to loan; and the cases of a sizable collection of films I already own staring at me whenever I sit down to watch something.

Through these factors, I've come to the realization that I don't need to own a film to feel ownership of it. Once I've seen a film, no one can take that experience away from me. Watching something grants me entrance into a community with whom I share that common ground and if I want to refresh that knowledge, that can easily be accomplished without bringing an extra possession into my home, no matter how impressive the transfer or enticing a bonus feature.

I make an exception for each new Wes Anderson film, though even those go unwatched for a year or two with many of their supplements yet unseen. So, yes, I pre-ordered the Criterion edition of "Fantastic Mr. Fox," but did so because it was a film I'd been anticipating owning in that format since its theatrical run, not because it happened to be part of a 24-hour special offer.

As such, apart from the cost/space/time issues of physical ownership, the problem with these Criterion flash sales is that they attempt to convince film lovers that they should buy discs because they happen to be on sale that day. That's not to say certain people don't keep a wish list, save up, and wait for these semi-regular events to occur, but the majority of us impulse-purchase consumers swarm simply because the sale is upon us, a rush that blinds us (myself included) of the fact that most of the standalone Blu-rays are available on Amazon for $25 on a given day. A similar feeling transpires with Black Friday and Cyber Monday purchases, inducing a frenzy of "why not?" orders without pausing to answer that question. 

Before finalizing that purchase, consider how much instant access to a particular title is worth and how often that impulse arises. If those factors line up with the cost, go for it. Personally, I'd rather utilize the aforementioned non-purchase options or invest $8 and dedicate a month to knocking out some blind spots on Hulu Plus' Criterion Collection channel, though that's a challenge all its own.


E-Mail Updates