"The revenge conceit doesn't really move me much, nor does freedom achieved simply through the benevolence of white people. Leaving that aside, what scares me most is the portrayal of black women in this testoronic revenge fantasy. I really loath the 'Union soldiers raped and killed my wife, now I'm out for revenge' motif. It is a lie on several levels, ranging from history to humanism. But reversing that history only makes it slightly more true, while leaving some of the biggest lies in place."
Coates says it's also "really dangerous to get caught up" in a narrative about a black man taking revenge on the white men who had enslaved him ("It is wrong because such a focus says that the only thing important about war are those who carry the guns."). Coates has done his research and knows what he's talking about. I'm sure that what he is saying is true.
What I'm not so sure about is whether Tarantino should be held accountable for his "inaccurate" portrayal of this period, since, if "Inglourious Basterds" is any indication, he's not only unconcerned with historical accuracy, he's downright oblivious of it. Some chafed at the idea that "Basterds" rewrote the end of World War II to glorify its Jewish heroes, but most seemed okay with Tarantino telling his story the way he wanted, with the understanding that it was a piece of fiction, not history. It'll be interesting to see whether he gets the same latitude here.
"My thoughts, as offered here" Coates concludes, "are not entirely fair to Tarantino." True; especially since they're based on a two and a half minute trailer, not the actual movie. Coates' concerns could be 100% valid, but they could also be off the mark. Another thing "Inglourious Basterds" taught us: expect the unexpected from a Tarantino movie. The trailer for "Basterds" made it look like QT's version of "The Dirty Dozen" -- but the reality was far more complicated. The same might end up being true of "Django." At this point, this essay is more like a trailer itself, for the potential controversies coming soon to a theater near you.