Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
'No Good Deed' Reviews: And the Twist Is That It's Good! (Not Really) 'No Good Deed' Reviews: And the Twist Is That It's Good! (Not Really) Studio Cancels All Screenings of 'No Good Deed' to Preserve Shocking Twist That It's Probably Terrible Studio Cancels All Screenings of 'No Good Deed' to Preserve Shocking Twist That It's Probably Terrible The Availability Gap: What We Lose When Netflix Wins The Availability Gap: What We Lose When Netflix Wins Mysteries of Laura Review: Debra Messing on NBC Mysteries of Laura Review: Debra Messing on NBC Comparing Lena Dunham to Woody Allen Is Unfair — to Lena Dunham Comparing Lena Dunham to Woody Allen Is Unfair — to Lena Dunham Daily Reads: The Death of Adulthood, the Future of Film in 'Snowpiercer' and More Daily Reads: The Death of Adulthood, the Future of Film in 'Snowpiercer' and More 'The Disappearance of Eleanor Rigby: Them': 'Between Just Enough and a Bit Too Much' 'The Disappearance of Eleanor Rigby: Them': 'Between Just Enough and a Bit Too Much' Why the Unanimous Praise for 'Boyhood' Is Bad for Film Criticism — and for 'Boyhood' Why the Unanimous Praise for 'Boyhood' Is Bad for Film Criticism — and for 'Boyhood' 'While We're Young': Noah Baumbach's Xer-Millennial Comedy Ponders the Difference Between Sharing People's Lives and Stealing Them 'While We're Young': Noah Baumbach's Xer-Millennial Comedy Ponders the Difference Between Sharing People's Lives and Stealing Them Now Streaming: 'Silver Linings Playbook,' 'Beginners' on Netflix Now Streaming: 'Silver Linings Playbook,' 'Beginners' on Netflix 'The Cobbler' Reviews: 'Makes Me Want to Upgrade Everything I've Ever Seen Half a Star' 'The Cobbler' Reviews: 'Makes Me Want to Upgrade Everything I've Ever Seen Half a Star' 'A Walk Among the Tombstones' Reviews: A Liam Neeson Movie Worthy of Liam Neeson 'A Walk Among the Tombstones' Reviews: A Liam Neeson Movie Worthy of Liam Neeson Daily Reads: The 50 Worst Movies Ever Made, The Last Blockbuster Video Stores and More Daily Reads: The 50 Worst Movies Ever Made, The Last Blockbuster Video Stores and More Criticwire Classic of the Week: Federico Fellini's '8 1/2' Criticwire Classic of the Week: Federico Fellini's '8 1/2' 'The Duke of Burgundy': With Butterflies and BDSM, a Kinky Romance Woos Critics 'The Duke of Burgundy': With Butterflies and BDSM, a Kinky Romance Woos Critics 'The Expendables 3' Torrent and the Techno-Utopian Delusion 'The Expendables 3' Torrent and the Techno-Utopian Delusion David Lynch on 'Eraserhead,' Women in the TV Industry David Lynch on 'Eraserhead,' Women in the TV Industry Did 'Edge of Tomorrow' Just Get a New Title for Home Video? Did 'Edge of Tomorrow' Just Get a New Title for Home Video? 'The Counselor's Extended Cut Is Inspired Madness 'The Counselor's Extended Cut Is Inspired Madness Daily Reads: Why Toronto Is the Best Place for Female Filmmakers, In Praise of Fincher's Women and More Daily Reads: Why Toronto Is the Best Place for Female Filmmakers, In Praise of Fincher's Women and More

Does 'Dallas Buyers Club's Exceptional Protagonist Distort History?

Photo of Sam Adams By Sam Adams | Criticwire November 8, 2013 at 4:31PM

'Dallas Buyers Club' takes criticism for representing the AIDS crisis through a straight protagonist.
4
Jared Leto and Matthew McConaughey in "Dallas Buyers Club"
Jared Leto and Matthew McConaughey in "Dallas Buyers Club"

With Dallas Buyers Club going wide this weekend and awards buzz building for leads Matthew McConaughey and Jared Leto, the movie's perspective on the AIDS crisis is coming under scrutiny, sometimes with positive results. At Sound on Sight, John Oursler situates the film within Hollywood's long history of telling stories of "the gay plague" through straight protagonists.

Hollywood’s vision of AIDS is one where educated, white, and gay men become sick and where an altruistic, or entrepreneurial, straight man can swoop in and save the day if they so desire. Crass, potentially reductive, but also clearly shown. These things can and have all been true, but they shouldn't be misconstrued as typical. And while two films don’t justify a trend, certainly not when two decades removed, there are similarities between the ways AIDS is treated in Philadelphia and how it rears its head in Dallas Buyers Club.

At Slate, J. Bryan Lowder, who edits the site's queer-focused vertical, Outward, takes exception to the charge that the movie whitewashes -- or, more accurately, straightens -- history by focusing on the (fact-based) story of a McConaughey's Ron Woodroof, a heterosexual man who  set up a subscription based organization to provide lower-cost drugs to HIV-positive patients -- including, of course, himself. The idea that "the movie oversimplifies and perhaps focuses on the wrong players in the AIDS crisis, is just bizarre," Lowder says. "Aren’t narrative films, especially about sweeping historical events, only ever effective when they focus on particular characters and time periods to create a simplistic impression of a remarkably complicated time?'" (The quote comes from an article by Salon's Daniel D'Addario.) "In the end," Lowder continues, 

[T]his is really a question of representation: When a particular historical event is thought to "belong" to a certain group, how much freedom do artists have in portraying it? Must movies or other art about AIDS always focus on gay people? Woodroof was a real person who suffered, fought, and eventually died from the disease. He was also straight. Is it then categorically "wrong" or a waste of resources to present his story while countless others remain untold? 

Stories like Dallas Buyers Club and 12 Years a Slave, which has faced similar criticism for focusing on the exceptional case of a free black man who was sold into slavery and subsequently escaped it, bear a burden of representation which may be unfair but is nonetheless real: Whether or not they proclaim themselves to be the definitive story of their respective eras, they at least run the risk of being taken as such. This is less a problem specific to the films themselves than the context in which they exist. As Oursler puts it, "[C]inema’s conspicuous discursive absence surrounding HIV/AIDS cheapens the thoughtful messages contained in Philadelphia and Dallas Buyers Club.... You can’t entirely bypass the grieving process and start with healing. Hollywood needs to provide some context if it wants to facilitate cultural atonement."

The Atlantic's Richard Lawson finds a partial solution in, of all places, The Carrie Diaries, the CW series about the young life of Sex and the City's Carrie Bradshaw. By most accounts, it's a fairly featherweight show, but it's set in New York in 1985, specifically in the fashion and publishing industries, where HIV infection reached epidemic proportions. 

As last year's galvanizing, vital documentary How to Survive a Plague so bracingly illustrated, America's big cities, especially San Francisco and New York, were angry, scary places in those days. Not for everyone, of course -- plenty of people probably didn't pay much attention to what was happening in the gay corners of the city -- but for the kind of people that Carrie Bradshaw hangs out with and aspires to be like, it seems entirely likely that the world they knew would suddenly begin to collapse right around the time of this cheery little summer.

According to Lawson, The Carries Diaries has yet to mention AIDS, but the show's executive producer told him via email that it's "definitely going to play a big part in this season." How that will play out remains to be seen, but in one sense, it's irrelevant. When it comes to under-represented histories, more is more. 12 Years a Slave is based on a extraordinary story that deserves to be told, but so do the stories of "normal" slaves, those who were born and died in bondage; if there were more of them, it wouldn't matter so much what kind of story 12 Years told. It may be unjust to hold one film accountable for representing an entire historical era, but it's also unjust that it has so little competition.

This article is related to: From the Wire, 12 Years a Slave, Matthew McConaughey


E-Mail Updates