Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Love or Hate 'American Sniper,' We're Brought Together By Its Bad Fake Baby Love or Hate 'American Sniper,' We're Brought Together By Its Bad Fake Baby 'Girls' Outrage Tracker: Season 4, Episode 2, 'Triggering' 'Girls' Outrage Tracker: Season 4, Episode 2, 'Triggering' 'Better Call Saul': 'Breaking Bad' Prequel Accepts the Charges 'Better Call Saul': 'Breaking Bad' Prequel Accepts the Charges 'Girls' Outrage Tracker: Season 4, Episode 1, 'Iowa' 'Girls' Outrage Tracker: Season 4, Episode 1, 'Iowa' Why the Unanimous Praise for 'Boyhood' Is Bad for Film Criticism — and for 'Boyhood' Why the Unanimous Praise for 'Boyhood' Is Bad for Film Criticism — and for 'Boyhood' At Last, the Four-Hour Cut of 'The Hobbit' You've Been Waiting For At Last, the Four-Hour Cut of 'The Hobbit' You've Been Waiting For The A.V. Club's 25 Best Sitcom Episodes of the Past 25 Years: 'Seinfeld,' 'The Simpsons' and More The A.V. Club's 25 Best Sitcom Episodes of the Past 25 Years: 'Seinfeld,' 'The Simpsons' and More Sleeper of the Week: 'Appropriate Behavior' Sleeper of the Week: 'Appropriate Behavior' First Reviews of Johnny Depp's 'Mortdecai': Scraping Bottom With a Waxed Moustache First Reviews of Johnny Depp's 'Mortdecai': Scraping Bottom With a Waxed Moustache The Oscar Nominations Were Dramatically Lacking in Diversity, But It's Not (Just) the Academy's Fault The Oscar Nominations Were Dramatically Lacking in Diversity, But It's Not (Just) the Academy's Fault Not at Sundance? Watch 14 Festival Films Via Sundance's #ArtistServices Not at Sundance? Watch 14 Festival Films Via Sundance's #ArtistServices Daily Reads: Stop Pitting 'Broad City' Against 'Girls,' How Political Pundits Warp 'American Sniper,' and more Daily Reads: Stop Pitting 'Broad City' Against 'Girls,' How Political Pundits Warp 'American Sniper,' and more 'Strange Magic' Reviews: Yup, That's Late Period George Lucas, All Right 'Strange Magic' Reviews: Yup, That's Late Period George Lucas, All Right Daily Reads: Stop Calling Tom Hanks an Everyman, 'Blackhat' as Michael Mann's Lonely Film and More Daily Reads: Stop Calling Tom Hanks an Everyman, 'Blackhat' as Michael Mann's Lonely Film and More Criticwire Classic of the Week: Jim Jarmusch's 'Dead Man' Criticwire Classic of the Week: Jim Jarmusch's 'Dead Man' 'Disney Deaths' and 'Big Hero 6': How Children's Stories Process Loss 'Disney Deaths' and 'Big Hero 6': How Children's Stories Process Loss 'The Nightly Show With Larry Wilmore': A Ways to Go, But Its Aim Is True 'The Nightly Show With Larry Wilmore': A Ways to Go, But Its Aim Is True The Scrambled Sexuality of 'Frozen's "Let It Go" The Scrambled Sexuality of 'Frozen's "Let It Go" 'Justified' Season 6 Reviews: After a Stumble, It's Back in the Saddle 'Justified' Season 6 Reviews: After a Stumble, It's Back in the Saddle Cahiers du Cinema's Top 10 Movies of 2014: 'Goodbye to Language,' 'Under the Skin,' 'Love Is Strange' Cahiers du Cinema's Top 10 Movies of 2014: 'Goodbye to Language,' 'Under the Skin,' 'Love Is Strange'

From the Wire: Times Editor Quotes Times Critics On Subject of Times Review

Criticwire By Matt Singer | Criticwire November 28, 2012 at 6:38PM

Some movies are "practically critic-proof," says the Times' Manohla Dargis.
1
Guy Fieri

Over the weekend, the New York Times officially addressed the reaction to Times food critic Pete Wells' brutal review of Guy Fieri's new Times Square restaurant, in a piece by public editor Margaret Sullivan. I tried reaching out to Wells to see if he'd do an interview with me the day after his review was published -- can you believe he didn't get back to me?!? -- so I was interested to see his comments in the piece, along with some quotes from Times film critic Manohla Dargis about her feelings on the subject of very negative reviews. Wells insists he didn't go to Guy's American Kitchen looking to pan the place ("I would have liked to write the ‘man-bites-dog’ review," he said) and added that negative reviews like his should be done "sparingly." Those comments were echoed by Dargis:

"'Most movies are middling,' she said. 'They’re fine, but they’re not transporting you.' Ms. Dargis is acutely aware of how a bad review can hurt -- not only feelings, but also commercial success. This is especially true for critics at The Times; a great deal rides on the judgment of the paper of record. Some blockbuster movies, though, are 'practically critic-proof,' she said. When the subject is vulnerable, one solution may be to not review at all. But sometimes that’s not practical. The Times can pass on reviewing, for example, an independent filmmaker’s fledgling effort or an art exhibit in a small gallery, but it is committed to reviewing major concerts, films and theater productions, whatever their quality."

That could get us into a whole discussion about whether certain movies really are "critic-proof," but that's a topic probably best saved another time. I'm still interested what readers think about this subject: was the original review going too far? Should negative reviews be used sparingly? Should critics feel responsible about how their reviews impact movies' box office receipts? Let me know what you think below.

Read more of "Reviews With 'All Guns Blazing.'"

This article is related to: From the Wire


E-Mail Updates