Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Cahiers du Cinema's Top 10 Movies of 2014: 'Goodbye to Language,' 'Under the Skin,' 'Love Is Strange' Cahiers du Cinema's Top 10 Movies of 2014: 'Goodbye to Language,' 'Under the Skin,' 'Love Is Strange' Daily Reads: The Epic Uncool of Philip Seymour Hoffman's Career, How Scarlett Johansson Subverts Her Good Looks and More Daily Reads: The Epic Uncool of Philip Seymour Hoffman's Career, How Scarlett Johansson Subverts Her Good Looks and More 'The End of the Tour' Sundance Reviews: Jason Segel Impresses as David Foster Wallace 'The End of the Tour' Sundance Reviews: Jason Segel Impresses as David Foster Wallace Why the Unanimous Praise for 'Boyhood' Is Bad for Film Criticism — and for 'Boyhood' Why the Unanimous Praise for 'Boyhood' Is Bad for Film Criticism — and for 'Boyhood' 'Girls' Outrage Tracker: Season 4, Episode 1, 'Iowa' 'Girls' Outrage Tracker: Season 4, Episode 1, 'Iowa' Now Streaming: 'The Interview' and Other Movies That Didn't Get Us Threatened Now Streaming: 'The Interview' and Other Movies That Didn't Get Us Threatened 'Strange Magic' Reviews: Yup, That's Late Period George Lucas, All Right 'Strange Magic' Reviews: Yup, That's Late Period George Lucas, All Right 'Going Clear' Sundance Reviews: A Scorching Takedown of Scientology 'Going Clear' Sundance Reviews: A Scorching Takedown of Scientology Not at Sundance? Watch 14 Festival Films Via Sundance's #ArtistServices Not at Sundance? Watch 14 Festival Films Via Sundance's #ArtistServices David Bordwell Shows How Aspect Ratios Matter David Bordwell Shows How Aspect Ratios Matter Love or Hate 'American Sniper,' We're Brought Together By Its Bad Fake Baby Love or Hate 'American Sniper,' We're Brought Together By Its Bad Fake Baby 'Girls' Outrage Tracker: Season 4, Episode 2, 'Triggering' 'Girls' Outrage Tracker: Season 4, Episode 2, 'Triggering' The Scrambled Sexuality of 'Frozen's "Let It Go" The Scrambled Sexuality of 'Frozen's "Let It Go" Meet the Indiewire | Sundance Institute Ebert Film Criticism Fellows, 2015 Meet the Indiewire | Sundance Institute Ebert Film Criticism Fellows, 2015 Daily Reads: Movie Monsters That Look Like Genitalia, Why It Feels Like There's Too Much TV and More Daily Reads: Movie Monsters That Look Like Genitalia, Why It Feels Like There's Too Much TV and More 'Disney Deaths' and 'Big Hero 6': How Children's Stories Process Loss 'Disney Deaths' and 'Big Hero 6': How Children's Stories Process Loss 'Dope' Sundance Reviews: A Smart, High-Energy Comedy 'Dope' Sundance Reviews: A Smart, High-Energy Comedy How Kids Change the Way Critics Watch Movies, Why It's Hard to Fight for Gender Equality in Hollywood and More How Kids Change the Way Critics Watch Movies, Why It's Hard to Fight for Gender Equality in Hollywood and More 'Z for Zachariah' Sundance Reviews: M for Mixed 'Z for Zachariah' Sundance Reviews: M for Mixed First Reviews of Johnny Depp's 'Mortdecai': Scraping Bottom With a Waxed Moustache First Reviews of Johnny Depp's 'Mortdecai': Scraping Bottom With a Waxed Moustache

Is 'Dead Poets Society' Ruining Our Schools?

Photo of Sam Adams By Sam Adams | Criticwire February 20, 2014 at 12:24PM

Okay, it's not. But its vision of the humanities makes them awfully hard to defend.
10
Dead Poets

Kevin Dettmar is hardly the first critic to take issue with Dead Poets Society, but he might be the first to accuse it of ruining our schools. More specifically, Dettmar writes in The Atlantic, the movie, which purports to extol the values of literature, is actually profoundly anti-intellectual, essentially falling in line with the caricature of the liberal arts as soft-headed and emotional-driven -- the kind of thing that's fine for long-haired teenagers but not much use in the adult world.

In the conversation about the fate of the humanities, these disciplines are often caricatured to the point of being unrecognizable to those of us in the component fields. The most alarming version -- one, I'm arguing, that has been propagated by Dead Poets Society -- is what I’ve taken to calling "sentimental humanities": humanities content stripped of all humanities methodology and rigor. This is a feel-good humanities -- the humanities of uplift. The film is of no help as we try to find our way out of our current standoff -- and to the degree that it unconsciously stands in for humanities pedagogy and scholarship, it does real damage

Following in the footsteps of noted literary scholar Piper Kerman, Dettmar argues that Robin Williams' beloved Mr. Keating fundamentally misreads Robert Frost's "The Road Not Taken": "His use of those closing lines, wrenched from their context, isn’t just wrong -- it's completely wrong, and Keating uses them to point a moral entirely different from that of Frost's poem." In essence, rather than understanding Frost's poem as one about self-deception and the illusion of choice, Keating, and Dead Poets Society as a whole, uses it as a self-congratulatory metaphor for nonconformism (while doing so in the most conformist way imaginable). 


It's not surprising, in a sense: the exaltation of feeling over intellect is practically a manifesto for Hollywood. So if Dead Poets Society is a terrible movie about the teaching of English literature, it might be, intentionally or not, a fairly accurate one about what happens to literary complexities when they're fed through the movie industry's meat grinder.

Update: Let the counterarguments begin! Flavorwire's Jason Bailey fires back, arguing that the Atlantic essay is merely the sour grapes of a thin-skinned intellectual:

You see, Dettmar objects to the picture’s "sentimentalized version of the humanities," wherein (gasp) "passion alone" is "empty, even dangerous." OK, that’s all well and good, but we start getting into territory far off the screen when the good professor proceeds to blast the film's -- and society's -- "preference for fans over critics, amateurs over professionals." You see, he concludes, "Scholars and teachers of the humanities" like the good professor "will insist on being welcomed to the table as professionals." In other words, this lengthy ramble is less about the quality of a motion picture and more about a professional intellectual taking a strangely forced opportunity to fiercely assert his own relevance. And I'm not quite sure why anyone else needs to read that.

It's great that Dead Poets Society drove 13-year-old Bailey to seek out the works of Whitman, et al., but that's not really an argument: Salinger will undoubtedly inspire people to read Salinger, but that doesn't make it a good documentary. And Bailey's supposed rebuttal -- "What academics are supposed to do is take that passion and turn it into close study and real analysis, rather than turn up their nose at the source" -- actually sounds a lot like what Dettmar is arguing in the first place. Dettmar's not saying that passion has no place in the class room, but that while Williams' Keating removes "dull pedagogy," he "doesn't finally give his students anything in its place besides a kind of vague enthusiasm." How this translates into Dettmar being a "bully," as Bailey calls him, I just don't see at all.

This article is related to: From the Wire


E-Mail Updates