Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Jean-Pierre Jeunet's 'T.S. Spivet' Opens With No Warning and No Reviews Jean-Pierre Jeunet's 'T.S. Spivet' Opens With No Warning and No Reviews David Foster Wallace's Editor and Friend Savages the 'Ghoulish' 'End of the Tour' David Foster Wallace's Editor and Friend Savages the 'Ghoulish' 'End of the Tour' The Top-Rated Movies of 2015 So Far: Foreign Films and Portraits of the Artists The Top-Rated Movies of 2015 So Far: Foreign Films and Portraits of the Artists 35 Bill Cosby Accusers Speak in Staggering New York Cover Story 35 Bill Cosby Accusers Speak in Staggering New York Cover Story Daily Reads: Why Movies Need Men and Women to Just Be Friends, The Limits of Outrage, and More Daily Reads: Why Movies Need Men and Women to Just Be Friends, The Limits of Outrage, and More "Vacation" Is Just Good Enough to Be Disappointing "Vacation" Is Just Good Enough to Be Disappointing Critics Pick the 100 Greatest American Movies of All Time for the BBC Critics Pick the 100 Greatest American Movies of All Time for the BBC Sleeper of the Week: 'Listen to Me Marlon' Sleeper of the Week: 'Listen to Me Marlon' How 'Paper Towns' Calls BS on 'Me and Earl and the Dying Girl' How 'Paper Towns' Calls BS on 'Me and Earl and the Dying Girl' Daily Reads: How Hollywood Rips Off Women, Do Characters Belong to Their Fans or Their Creators, and More Daily Reads: How Hollywood Rips Off Women, Do Characters Belong to Their Fans or Their Creators, and More Daily Reads: Why No One Remembers "Avatar," the Best Blu-rays and DVDs of 2014, and more Daily Reads: Why No One Remembers "Avatar," the Best Blu-rays and DVDs of 2014, and more First Reviews: The Exciting But Bloated Hip-Hop Epic 'Straight Outta Compton' First Reviews: The Exciting But Bloated Hip-Hop Epic 'Straight Outta Compton' This Week In Home Video: Cannes Winner 'White God,' DreamWorks Animation's 'Home,' and More This Week In Home Video: Cannes Winner 'White God,' DreamWorks Animation's 'Home,' and More Little White Lies Names 50 Great Movies by Female Directors Little White Lies Names 50 Great Movies by Female Directors News Anchor Mistakes Samuel L. Jackson for Laurence Fishburne News Anchor Mistakes Samuel L. Jackson for Laurence Fishburne Why Stephen King Is Utterly Wrong About 'Room 237' Why Stephen King Is Utterly Wrong About 'Room 237' Editors Keith Phipps and Scott Tobias on the End of The Dissolve and the Future of Film Criticism Editors Keith Phipps and Scott Tobias on the End of The Dissolve and the Future of Film Criticism The 10 Best Films of 2015 So Far According to the Criticwire Network, Plus 40 More The 10 Best Films of 2015 So Far According to the Criticwire Network, Plus 40 More The Death-by-Skype Horror Movie 'Unfriended' Is an Unlikely Critical Hit The Death-by-Skype Horror Movie 'Unfriended' Is an Unlikely Critical Hit Cahiers du Cinema's Top 10 Movies of 2014: 'Goodbye to Language,' 'Under the Skin,' 'Love Is Strange' Cahiers du Cinema's Top 10 Movies of 2014: 'Goodbye to Language,' 'Under the Skin,' 'Love Is Strange'

Ken Loach Thinks We Should Fire Critics and Replace Them With "Ordinary Punters"

Photo of Sam Adams By Sam Adams | Criticwire May 30, 2014 at 1:04PM

Ken Loach has generally had a good time of it with critics. But with what may be his last movie opening in the U.K., he says the feeling isn't mutual.
14
Jimmy

By and large, Ken Loach has had a good run with movie critics: Not one of his films has an average lower than 64 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, and three -- 1969's "Kes," 1993's "Raining Stones" and 2003's "The Navigators" have a perfect 100. But with his latest movie, "Jimmy's Hall," opening in the U.K., Loach has made it clear the feeling isn't mutual. In a video interview with the Guardian, he suggested doing away with them altogether: "Sack the critics and get ordinary punters in," he said. "People experienced, who know life."

By and large, critics are people who live in darkened rooms. They don't meet the people who are running campaigns to save hospitals or save community centers or are engaging to in that political struggle in the real world.... If they did, they'd meet people who from their own experience can articulate their own ideas, can articulate a strategy for a political campaign or whatever. And they'd find people have a richness of language and a use of language that is very vivid. It's like it's a fantasy for them. 

The odd thing is that "Jimmy's Hall" got fairly good reviews across the board. Perhaps he's talking about Neil Young in the Hollywood Reporter, who called it "an odd, only fitfully engaging hybrid of 'The Quiet Man' and 'Footloose,' which neither packs much of a punch nor is particularly nimble on its feet," or the Playlist's Jessica Kiang, who said "The complexity of the political landscape in Depression-era rural Ireland... is not so much shown as told, often in awkwardly polemic speeches poorly disguised as casual conversations between acquaintances." Maybe it's Ryan Gilbey in the New Statesman, who called it "less a portrait of the Irish communist leader Jimmy Gralton than a big, dopey kiss blown at him." Or Robbie Collin, who writes in the Telegraph

This is exasperatingly thin stuff from Loach and Laverty, who have in the past built far more textured narratives, peopled by far richer characters, even while maintaining a fierce, politicised charge. This story, though, is so dramatically facile – working classes good, ruling classes bad – that it all but evaporates on contact with air. Which makes you wonder: why tell it? And why now? Loach and Laverty have both suggested that Jimmy, a threat to the status quo and a man whom the authorities want to do away with at all costs, might be viewed as a surrogate Julian Assange-figure (the director is a prominent supporter of the WikiLeaks co-founder, and helped to raise his £200,000 bail), but Jimmy’s character is so flatly and uninterestingly noble that the parallel feels half-formed, even naive.  

But in Variety, Scott Foundas praised the film's " talky but stimulating ideological tennis matches." Alan Coor at RTE called it a "lovely and lyrical folk history." At Indiewire, Eric Kohn said it "captures more than simply the early stirrings of a cultural revolution. It situates them in the tense, claustrophobic world where any secular form of expression was an automatic taboo." In the Guardian, Peter Bradshaw wrote:

The movie is at its best when it simply expounds an idealism, with its own distinctive frankness. There is a wonderful sequence in which people just sit in a circle in Jimmy's hall for a sort of practical criticism session: they discuss WB Yeats's poem "The Song of the Wandering Aengus," and talk about what it means to them. I could watch simple, thoughtful scenes like this for hours on end.

You understand why someone like, say, Seth MacFarlane might rail against critics. But Ken Loach? Despite his proletarian sympathies, his forty-plus year career offers little evidence that his movies are of much interest to "ordinary punters," who've give them far less attention than critics have. Don't be a hater, Ken Loach.


E-Mail Updates