Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
How Did Nicole Kidman's 'Grace of Monaco' Go From Cannes Opener to Lifetime Movie? The Movie's Writer Tweets All How Did Nicole Kidman's 'Grace of Monaco' Go From Cannes Opener to Lifetime Movie? The Movie's Writer Tweets All A.O. Scott on Why the New York Times Changed Its Review Policy A.O. Scott on Why the New York Times Changed Its Review Policy The Best Films of the 2015 Cannes Film Festival According to Criticwire The Best Films of the 2015 Cannes Film Festival According to Criticwire The Top-Rated Movies of 2015 So Far: Literary Stories and New Genre Favorites The Top-Rated Movies of 2015 So Far: Literary Stories and New Genre Favorites 'Aloha,' With Bradley Cooper and Emma Stone: Cameron Crowe's Worst Movie, or Just One of His Worst? 'Aloha,' With Bradley Cooper and Emma Stone: Cameron Crowe's Worst Movie, or Just One of His Worst? First Cannes Reviews: Hou Hsiao-Hsien's "The Assassin" First Cannes Reviews: Hou Hsiao-Hsien's "The Assassin" First Cannes Reviews: Gaspar Noé's 'Love,' A 3D Art-Porn Mashup First Cannes Reviews: Gaspar Noé's 'Love,' A 3D Art-Porn Mashup First Reviews: Netflix Series 'Sense8' Goes 'Full Wachowski' First Reviews: Netflix Series 'Sense8' Goes 'Full Wachowski' Daily Reads: Why Critics Don't Have to Review 'Game of Thrones,' The Clash of Action in 'Avengers' and 'Mad Max,' and More Daily Reads: Why Critics Don't Have to Review 'Game of Thrones,' The Clash of Action in 'Avengers' and 'Mad Max,' and More The New York Times Is No Longer Reviewing Every Movie That Opens in New York The New York Times Is No Longer Reviewing Every Movie That Opens in New York Meditations on a Mad Man Meditations on a Mad Man Every Shot From David Letterman's 'Late Show' Farewell Montage Every Shot From David Letterman's 'Late Show' Farewell Montage 'San Andreas' Turns 9/11's Tragedy Into Pure Corn 'San Andreas' Turns 9/11's Tragedy Into Pure Corn The Mary Sue Freezes Out 'Game of Thrones' to Protest Yet Another Rape Scene The Mary Sue Freezes Out 'Game of Thrones' to Protest Yet Another Rape Scene Daily Reads: The Secret History of Ultimate Marvel, Why Your Favorite TV Show Was Cancelled, and More Daily Reads: The Secret History of Ultimate Marvel, Why Your Favorite TV Show Was Cancelled, and More What Critics Are Saying About David Letterman's Final 'Late Show' Episode What Critics Are Saying About David Letterman's Final 'Late Show' Episode Daily Reads: Why No One Remembers "Avatar," the Best Blu-rays and DVDs of 2014, and more Daily Reads: Why No One Remembers "Avatar," the Best Blu-rays and DVDs of 2014, and more First Cannes Reviews: Todd Haynes' "Carol" First Cannes Reviews: Todd Haynes' "Carol" The Children's Book from 'The Babadook' Will Terrify You in the Real World The Children's Book from 'The Babadook' Will Terrify You in the Real World Daily Reads: 'San Andreas' and the Art of Destroying L.A., Why Ferris Bueller is the Real Villain of his Day Off, and More Daily Reads: 'San Andreas' and the Art of Destroying L.A., Why Ferris Bueller is the Real Villain of his Day Off, and More

Sex, Disability and Videotapes: 'Gabrielle' and 'The Special Need'

Criticwire By James Berclaz-Lewis | Criticwire August 20, 2013 at 5:12PM

Two new movies explore the intersection of disability and sexual desire.
1
'The Special Need'
'The Special Need'

Either by coincidence or inspired programming, this year's Locarno Film Festival offered the opportunity to watch two films that tackled the rather slippery subject of disabled people and their sexual desire, and how it is perceived by those who do not share their condition. It is only in relatively recent times that the issue has started to be studied with any serious consideration by specialized psychologists and educators, let alone be seriously depicted on the screen. It is worth noting that the very notion that it should warrant scientific research does suggest that the sexual desires of the disabled are inherently understood as different. At Locarno, Gabrielle and The Special Need respectively provide a fictional and documentary angle on the subject, offering two different takes whose approaches sometimes overlap, and sometimes veer in completely opposite directions. 

In Gabrielle, a passionate mentally handicapped girl in her early twenties yearns for normalcy in both her day-to-day life and the relationship she desires with her fellow choir member Martin. One of the film's most pertinent aspects lies in how it strives to reveal the prejudice of the "infantilized" representation people like the title-character have to suffer, a widespread illusion that persistently keeps disabled people from successfully transitioning into adult life. The culprit here is Martin's mother who, after walking in on the two lovebirds in their underwear, forbids her son to see Gabrielle and even participate in choir practice. Through its depiction of Gabrielle's struggle to overcome that most common of obstacles, the films begs the question who, between Gabrielle and Martin's overprotective mother, truly suffers from the bigger handicap?

The film, however, does have issues of its own. Louise Archambault's feature often oversimplifies nuanced problems to fit the genre's dramatic requirements. Its proclamation that we are all exactly the same and should be treated in the exact same way is a noble concept, but it also contrasts with the reality of the issue. Current scholarly work reveals that people with Downs Syndrome, to offer one example, often consider sex to be "unhealthy" or "dangerous", though it is still up to debate whether those sentiments are the result of the taboo still in place in many of their households. At no point in the narrative does Gabrielle betray anything but unwavering, uncompromising, certainty about getting what she wants which, while perfectly justifiable for dramatic purposes, ultimately clarifies the character as an idealistic construct; one that bears little resemblance to the maladroit realities of both first love and first sexual experiences. 

'Gabrielle'
'Gabrielle'

Thankfully, revealing that clumsiness inherent to inexperience is one of the most compelling elements of Carlo Zoratti's docudrama The Special Need: a tightly-wound coming-of-age/road-trip twist on the American Pie myth in which the director and his friend Alex go on a journey through central Europe to effectively get their mentally-disabled friend Enea laid. As implied by the second part of the "docu-drama" label, the Italian director is sometimes guilty of orchestrating emotional beats for the sake of entertainment value more than any truth-seeking motivation, though that shouldn't take away from the laudable honesty with he captures the touching realizations Enea is forced to face throughout the trip. Zoratti uses the opening third in Udine to show Enea's natural impulse to try and engage with women and the often humiliating encounters that follow without ever denting his drive, revealing how that missing physical connection has turned into an outright obsession. 

The trio then travel to Austria, where prostitution is legal, in order to coordinate an encounter between a prostitute and Enea. When finally given the opportunity to "close the deal," Enea's usually extroverted brashness makes way for a timid uncertainty that betrays the genuine sense of inadequacy that he otherwise hides so well. This is the first of several truly touching moments that serve to depict Enea's gradual steps toward accepting the notion that he might never be able to enjoy things exactly the way other people do. Though Enea is the first to claim that he has "learned a lot" from his trip, Zoratti's film quietly suggests that the lesson might be better directed to the audience. As we learn to know this most colorful of characters, it becomes harder and harder to find any justification for keeping Enea from fulfilling his most primal of urges. By capturing these moments when his funny childishness dissipates to reveal his earnest longing for basic human contact, The Special Need dispels taboos and facile answers to uncover the truth behind this man's overwhelming urges: the absence of love, that most essential of sentiments. 

Gabrielle and Enea are both surrounded by love, but cultural prejudice would have it that they not participate in the sharing of it. One can only hope that Gabrielle and The Special Need can now pave the way, though on undeniably different terms, for that very prejudice to be slain or at least for the oft-ignored issue to reach the wider attention it deserves.

Click here for more on James Berclaz-Lewis and this year's Critics Academy.

This article is related to: Locarno International Film Festival, Critics Academy


E-Mail Updates



Check out Indiewire on LockerDome on LockerDome