Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Comparing Lena Dunham to Woody Allen Is Unfair — to Lena Dunham Comparing Lena Dunham to Woody Allen Is Unfair — to Lena Dunham Studio Cancels All Screenings of 'No Good Deed' to Preserve Shocking Twist That It's Probably Terrible Studio Cancels All Screenings of 'No Good Deed' to Preserve Shocking Twist That It's Probably Terrible 'While We're Young': Noah Baumbach's Xer-Millennial Comedy Ponders the Difference Between Sharing People's Lives and Stealing Them 'While We're Young': Noah Baumbach's Xer-Millennial Comedy Ponders the Difference Between Sharing People's Lives and Stealing Them Reverse Shot Relaunches as an Official Website of Museum of the Moving Image Reverse Shot Relaunches as an Official Website of Museum of the Moving Image 'The Duke of Burgundy': With Butterflies and BDSM, a Kinky Romance Woos Critics 'The Duke of Burgundy': With Butterflies and BDSM, a Kinky Romance Woos Critics FX's 'The Strain' Is a Steaming Pile of Hot, Delicious Garbage FX's 'The Strain' Is a Steaming Pile of Hot, Delicious Garbage The Criticwire Survey: The Movie Title That Describes Your Life The Criticwire Survey: The Movie Title That Describes Your Life Brian Reitzell's Jaw-Dropping 'Hannibal' Scores Set for Release Brian Reitzell's Jaw-Dropping 'Hannibal' Scores Set for Release FX's 'Married,' With Judy Greer and Nat Faxon, Could Find Just the Right Balance of Bitter and Sweet FX's 'Married,' With Judy Greer and Nat Faxon, Could Find Just the Right Balance of Bitter and Sweet Writer Who Pirated 'The Expendables 3' Saw It In Theaters, Panned It Writer Who Pirated 'The Expendables 3' Saw It In Theaters, Panned It New on Netflix: 'Good Morning, Vietnam,' 'School of Rock,' 'A Simple Plan' and More New on Netflix: 'Good Morning, Vietnam,' 'School of Rock,' 'A Simple Plan' and More Augustus Waters: 'The Fault in our Stars' Manic Pixie Dream Guy Augustus Waters: 'The Fault in our Stars' Manic Pixie Dream Guy Is Scarlett Johansson's 'Lucy' the Summer's Smartest Dumb Movie, or Its Dumbest Smart One? Is Scarlett Johansson's 'Lucy' the Summer's Smartest Dumb Movie, or Its Dumbest Smart One? With Kelly Reilly as a Bipolar Neurologist, ABC's "Black Box" Is Crazy Bad With Kelly Reilly as a Bipolar Neurologist, ABC's "Black Box" Is Crazy Bad Jon Stewart's 'Rosewater' Is a Sharp, Sincere, if Not Exactly Stirring, Debut Jon Stewart's 'Rosewater' Is a Sharp, Sincere, if Not Exactly Stirring, Debut Why Is Lena Dunham Naked So Much? And Other Questions About 'Girls' Why Is Lena Dunham Naked So Much? And Other Questions About 'Girls' Lianne Spiderbaby Plagiarism Inspires Anger, Sorrow Lianne Spiderbaby Plagiarism Inspires Anger, Sorrow Criticwire Survey: Game-Changers Criticwire Survey: Game-Changers The Wizard of Oz Vs. Army of Darkness The Wizard of Oz Vs. Army of Darkness 5 Marvel Properties That, Even After 'Guardians of the Galaxy,' Are Still Too Weird for the Big Screen 5 Marvel Properties That, Even After 'Guardians of the Galaxy,' Are Still Too Weird for the Big Screen

Angry 'Skyfall' Commenters React to Negative Reviews As If Sky Was Actually Falling

Criticwire By Matt Singer | Criticwire November 7, 2012 at 2:52PM

"It's people like you that make 'Skyfall' drop from 95% to 94%."
4
Skyfall Bardem

The general tenor of the discourse on Rotten Tomatoes has improved a little bit since the site changed their commenting system in the wake of the death threats (and assorted other misogyny and hate speech) leveled against critics who didn't care for "The Dark Knight Rises" last summer. Still, there's plenty of room for excessive outrage over there, as evidenced by the level of fevered vitriol greeting the negative reviews of "Skyfall." So far, the new Bond film has earned an impressive 92% on Rotten Tomatoes (on our own Criticwire Network, it's currently got an A- average). Impressive, but not good enough for some, and the eight negative reviews have been subject to hundreds of angry reactions -- including a couple dozen from just one guy.

In some cases, commenters behave like the sky is actually falling. In others, it gets even more surreal; like the reader who dismisses one negative "Skyfall" review because it was written by a critic who liked "The Dark Knight Rises" too much. "Hipsters" were a frequent target, for some reason -- according to some, anyone who doesn't like "Skyfall" is a hipster. And then there is that one guy, a Mr. Himanshu Pant, who spent a fair part of his Wednesday morning leaving well over twenty angry comments all over Rotten Tomatoes. His account has since been deleted -- no doubt as part of a dastardly SPECTRE plot to enable critics to discredit 007 with impunity.

As always, the comments that follow have not been edited in any way (except, in a few cases, where I removed line breaks for readability). "Skyfall" opens in theaters on Friday.

The Angriest Readers Reactions on Rotten Tomatoes to Negative "Skyfall" Reviews

"its people like you that make Skyfall drop from 95% to 94%." -- James Faidley

"Your license as a critic should be revoked. That and of those who've mistakenly hired you:)." -- Wahab Al-Dugaishim

"Shitty blabbling review Bettr luck next time, Adam." -- Geng Sapsupan

"you were payed to give a bullshit review." -- Joey Copenhaver

"Utter garbage review!!!! Kyle I suggest you should get another job, you waste of space!!!" -- Scott Barber

"You don't need to worry about this guy's opinion because it's wrong. He didn't like Inception either, therefore I don't like his taste in movies." -- Nick Fury

"I don't understand how you are a part of this website. Has to be a Hipster. 3 names makes it obvious." -- Kyle Forrester

"Can we just get rid of all the hipsters who write movie reviews? That would clean most of the garbage on this site and movie ratings would be accurate for once!" -- Nick Meise

"I just want to kick the ass of these kind of critics." -- Himanshu Pant

"What the f**k is this ?" -- Himanshu Pant

"These kind of rotten reviews are useless. They can not affect this excellent movie." -- Himanshu Pant

"This review is shit. This movie is so good." -- Himanshu Pant

"This review is shit." -- Himanshu Pant

"This review is bullshit." -- Himanshu Pant

"This review is garbage." -- Himanshu Pant

"This review is nonsense." -- Himanshu Pant

"This review is ridiculous." -- Himanshu Pant

"This review is f**king ridiculous." -- Himanshu Pant

"This review is totally useless." -- Himanshu Pant

"This is a nonsense and ridiculous review." --  Himanshu Pant

"F**king ridiculous review ." -- Himanshu Pant

"Shit review." -- Himanshu Pant

"Finally RT has declared this movie certified fresh. So these rotten reviews are f**king shit of some asshole critics." -- Himanshu Pant

This article is related to: Skyfall, James Bond, Rotten Tomatoes


E-Mail Updates