Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
What Quentin Tarantino Gets Wrong About TV Critics What Quentin Tarantino Gets Wrong About TV Critics The Dissolve's Keith Phipps Will Be Uproxx's Film/TV Editor The Dissolve's Keith Phipps Will Be Uproxx's Film/TV Editor Criticwire Survey: The Worst Movie and TV Accents Ever Criticwire Survey: The Worst Movie and TV Accents Ever 'Fear the Walking Dead' Starts Slow, and Interest Is Already Waning 'Fear the Walking Dead' Starts Slow, and Interest Is Already Waning Daily Reads: Why Yale's Library Is Preserving VHS, Who Wins When a Brown Actor Plays a White Character, and More Daily Reads: Why Yale's Library Is Preserving VHS, Who Wins When a Brown Actor Plays a White Character, and More How 'Mr. Robot' Hacks TV's Empathy Machine How 'Mr. Robot' Hacks TV's Empathy Machine The Top-Rated Movies of 2015 So Far: Defying Conventions The Top-Rated Movies of 2015 So Far: Defying Conventions When You Laugh at Old Movies, the Joke Is On You When You Laugh at Old Movies, the Joke Is On You Joe Hill: Review Aggregrators Like Rotten Tomatoes Provide 'Confusion, Not Clarity' Joe Hill: Review Aggregrators Like Rotten Tomatoes Provide 'Confusion, Not Clarity' British Film Critic Was a Soviet Spy British Film Critic Was a Soviet Spy 'Manic Pixie Dream Girl' Is Officially Part of the English Language Now 'Manic Pixie Dream Girl' Is Officially Part of the English Language Now Real Life Hasn't Punished Jordan Belfort. Why Should 'The Wolf of Wall Street'? Real Life Hasn't Punished Jordan Belfort. Why Should 'The Wolf of Wall Street'? Daily Reads: How 'Straight Outta Compton' Fails Its Audience, Universal's Blockbuster Year Without Superheroes, and More Daily Reads: How 'Straight Outta Compton' Fails Its Audience, Universal's Blockbuster Year Without Superheroes, and More Amy Schumer, Meryl Streep and the State of the 'Strong Female Character' Amy Schumer, Meryl Streep and the State of the 'Strong Female Character' Daily Reads: Sexism Isn't Just a 'Straight Outta Compton' Problem, How Samuel L. Jackson Lost 'Reservoir Dogs,' and More Daily Reads: Sexism Isn't Just a 'Straight Outta Compton' Problem, How Samuel L. Jackson Lost 'Reservoir Dogs,' and More Sleeper of the Week: 'The Diary of a Teenage Girl" Sleeper of the Week: 'The Diary of a Teenage Girl" Daily Reads: What Colin Trevorrow Got Right About Female Directors, the Art of Cynical Sincerity in 'BoJack Horseman' and 'Rick and Morty,' and More Daily Reads: What Colin Trevorrow Got Right About Female Directors, the Art of Cynical Sincerity in 'BoJack Horseman' and 'Rick and Morty,' and More 'The Gift': A Great Thriller (Almost) Ruined By a Terrible Ending 'The Gift': A Great Thriller (Almost) Ruined By a Terrible Ending Daily Reads: 'Mistress America' and the Art of Making a Living as an Artist, How Summer TV Surprised Us, and More Daily Reads: 'Mistress America' and the Art of Making a Living as an Artist, How Summer TV Surprised Us, and More Criticwire Classic of the Week: Roman Polanski's 'Chinatown' Criticwire Classic of the Week: Roman Polanski's 'Chinatown'

We Must Protect Criticism, Says Guy Who Anonymously Attacked His Critics Online

Criticwire By Matt Singer | Criticwire June 12, 2012 at 9:35AM

The practice of criticism is under attack. Movie stars don't like it. Directors don't like it. Editors aren't too interested in it. Critics, in other words, need a champion.
4
"The Tree of Life."
"The Tree of Life."

The practice of criticism is under attack. Movie stars don't like it. Directors don't like it. Editors aren't too interested in it. Critics, in other words, need a champion.

At (British) GQ.com, they've got one in the form of columnist Johann Hari, who has written a passionate defense of the form entitled "Is This the End of Critics?" Surveying the rather inhospitable landscape facing critics today -- firings, layoffs, disgruntled subjects, the explosion of amateur criticism on social media -- Hari explains why professional critics still matter...

"Because critics perform two essential tasks in the cultural ecosystem - and as with any ecosystem, if you knock out one part, the entire network is at risk of unravelling. Their first task is simply consumer advice... but critics have a deeper role still. When something new and startling comes along, it often baffles us, and we are tempted to drop it, pained, for easier cultural lifting. A great critic can help us to figure out what is going on, and to appreciate it in a richer way. When I saw Terrence Malick's 'The Tree Of Life,' I was sure I had seen something extraordinary, but I felt I had barely begun to understand it. It was reading the body of criticism by terrific writers, such as Dana Stevens and Peter Bradshaw that led me deeper in. As film critic Pauline Kael put it: 'We read critics for the perceptions, for what they tell us that we didn't fully grasp when we saw the work.'"

Well said. Hell yes, criticism is important (says the guy whose livelihood depends on its continued importance). It does help guide our purchases. It can enrich our understanding of complex works of art. It should be protected. It deserves to be supported. 

That support, in this case though, may come from a dubious source. The intro to Hari's piece on GQ-Magazine.co.uk  says that the writer "was last year embroiled in his own media storm after admitting to plagiarism and confessing to using a pseudonym to attack his critics online." So the guy saying criticism needs to be protected recently got into trouble for anonymous bashing his own critics?

Apparently. An article in The Telegraph by Cristina Odone details how, after a fight with Johann Hari, her Wikipedia page was defaced by a commenter who rewrote her personal history to include fabricated incidents involving anti-semitism and homophobia. That commenter, it later turned out, was actually Johann Hari. And Odone wasn't the only one of Hari's enemies attacked by his online alter ego, either.

After Hari's misdeeds came to light he apologized, took a leave of absence from his job, enrolled in a journalism training program, made amends. He seems to be in a better place professionally and I still think his message is a good one. But is he the right messenger to deliver it? I mean, this is weird, right? If criticism is under attack, this feels a little like an undercover agent sent to destroy it from within. Let's all agree to do as he says, not as he did.

Read more of "Is This the End of Critics?"

This article is related to: Johann Hari


E-Mail Updates