Live Review: Goldfrapp @ Radio City Music Hall (Plus a Curious Incident After the Show)
**NOTE: All Photos by Amanda Nanawa. If you wish to link or post photos to your blog, kindly send an email to Digital Music W... Thanks.**
The last time I saw Goldfrapp perform, she was chatty and cursing like a sailor. Friday night at Radio City Music Hall -- which is the largest venue the band has ever performed in the city -- I wondered what kind of surprises the live show would have. There was already talk about no dancers on the 2nd US tour, which meant no pole dancing. So the likelihood that a full choir would make an appearance on this large stage was practically zero on the chance scale. It seems that Mute just poured out their budget on the proper UK tour and skimped on other stand-alone tours outside the UK. The sad trickle down effect from EMI. So what was different about this tour? Let me just outline and then I'll write up some snazzy paragraphs.
What was different:
- No wicker squares used as backdrop
- Theremin broke
- One song encore
- Less chatty Alison
- Only sang one song from Felt Mountain (yeah, really)
- No dancers
- Performed "Clowns" live!!!!!!!!
The stage setup had the stag head topped pole with streamers and bunting all around. There were a couple of stuffed owls and the background scrim was this silk screen with diamond-shaped patterns. Gone were those tasty looking wicker squares.
The band opened with "Utopia" from Felt Mountain and it was stirring. Radio City has amazing acoustics - one of the reasons why seeing Goldfrapp performing in this venue is well worth the catch. Needless to say, one of the biggest drawbacks at Radio City is the lack of stadium seating. There were various people standing up during "Utopia" (a slow dance shuffler that can elicit people to sit rather than stand). Problem is, in a seated venue people just want to sit during a slow number. But these two guys - drunk beyond belief - were whooping and dancing their martini-soaked asses off. And worst, they were sitting in the Orchestra Pit section so everyone behind them were affected by their obstructed view. Very bad. Not a good way to appreciate the song or Alison's operatic voice.
The setlist featured a menagerie of tunes from Supernature and Seventh Tree but it seems most of the tunes from Seventh Tree were played. After "Utopia" was "Cologne Cerrone Houdini" and it was sensual. You can hear each instrument making a contribution to the live set - Ruth Wall on harps, Davide Rossi on electronic violin & keyboards, Angie Pollock on keyboards, Alex Lee on guitars, Charlie Jones on bass and Ged Lynch on drums/percussion. They sounded like an orchestra of a 100 but it was just them. That's amazing.
"Satin Chic" made it on the setlist but Alison didn't do the ragdoll robot dance. "Number One" got people really into it. Biggest improvement of all the songs on the setlist was the extended live "Little Bird". When last performed at the Beacon Theatre earlier in the year, the song kinda fell short existentially. But at Radio City, the song was alive. The psychedelic imagery that accompanied it was brighter for some reason too.
"You Never Know" also improved since the Beacon show. It was powerful and spellbinding. That was the Alison Goldfrapp I expected to hear. Those vocal acrobatics returned and thats what always made this song a great live song.
During "Happiness" everyone danced and bounced up and down like in the music video (that was an homage to an MGM movie -- which Peter Wolf also paid tribute to in his "Come As You Are" video). That was fun. And what's a show without "Ooh La La"? This is the electro-stomp version, not the Hillbilly version they experimented with at the Beacon. "Caravan Girl" made it back on the setlist. But the one I've been curious to hear and see was "Clowns" performed live and it was worth the wait. It was gorgeous listening to this cheeky quiet song in the flesh.
The song "Train" came on and everyone got really crazy and started hip grinding with people (some others were....er...doing things I don't want to even recall). The last time she performed "Train" in NYC was at the infamous Roseland show -- the same show where Alison broke down in tears while singing "Black Cherry" -- and at that show, the Theremin was missing. During the Radio City show, the Theremin was on stage but when Alison went to turn on the volume, its pitch was so high that it never got under control. Alison, frustrated at the Theremin's non-cooperative spirit, threw the Theremin to the floor like an angry child that couldn't get its toy to work. Amazingly, it didn't shatter to pieces but to Alison it was no good and worth throwing in the bin. So during this angry session, the song was still in its instrumental phase and once again Alison had to improvise. And again she danced it off... angrily. With no dancers to dance the tune with, she started to do some crazy hybrid shadowboxing dance moves. She was pumping her fists high in the air as if to punch the living daylights out of the Theremin god that failed her. When the song ended, she was livid. She started pacing toward the monitor technician but didn't approach him. She was just beside herself.
"Strict Machine (We Are Glitter remix)" came on and the light show that accompanied this song was definitely inducing hypnosis or epilepsy. The strobe lights just kept going and my eyes just kept dilating to the point where I had to shake my head and get my focus back.
For an encore, the band came back to play one song, "Some People". It got everyone to sit down and soak in its soothing sound. And then she said, "Thanks. That's it!" Afterwards, Alison took her glass of wine, held it up to the crowd as if she was saying "cheers" and took a sip. She did this on both sides of the stage. She then asked the cowd to thank the live band that supported her.
You know what I said after she said "That's it"... I said out loud... "Awe c'mon! You gotta be kidding me!" When oh when does Alison get to overcome this feeling of ambivalence to sing "Black Cherry" live again?
Before I conclude, I must write about Martha Wainwright. She rocked! It really surprised me that she was opening for Goldfrapp but that's ok because it was a great performance. Of all the opening acts I have seen open for Goldfrapp so far, Martha was the best. Oh hell, she's on a different stratosphere than all the other openers anyway. But she truly warmed up the crowd. And her rousing duet with her mother, Canadian folk singer/songwriter Kate McGarrigle, was amazing. Martha sang in French while her mother was on keyboards and backing vocals. Its too bad her brother Rufus didn't make it, but that would've been too much!

There was some drama after the Goldfrapp show... What was it? Click below to read the rest.
I ended up going somewhere else after the show but my friend stayed behind to see if she could get her mottled Seventh Tree CD box signed by Alison Goldfrapp. Apparently, there were some fans waiting outside the stage entrance on 51st Street.
My friend said that she saw Alison was ready to exit but didn't come out to greet the fans. Instead, all the fans that waited outside for her under the intermittent rain waited there for more than 2 hrs. 2 hrs! She finally heard from one of the guys who worked there that Alison left the building. I asked her if anyone from the touring staff came out and said anything. She said no. They made it sound like she was still in there. She thinks that the touring staff must've thought it was a nice joke to see how long the fans would wait for Alison outside under the rain.
If this is true, that means Alison Goldfrapp actually left her fans outside under the rain and just sneaked out of the building without having someone from staff actually tell people that she officially left. I asked my friend if there were a lot of people. She said no. Just maybe about 15 or 20? It wasn't a lot. And it wasn't like there were paparazzi. It was just all fans. She said the experience just left a bad taste in her mouth. I said the whole thing is unconscionable. If the band's staff knew that Alison left, they should've just told the fans the truth rather than leaving them outside soaking in the rain. The decent thing they could've done was just tell the fans waiting that Alison couldn't go and greet them. My friend said she just couldn't believe that Alison was just at the door ready to leave but didn't even bother to come out and just quickly greet fans. She was sure it would've been quick since it was raining.
I don't know what really happened but my friend wouldn't lie about this. If this truly was the case - Alison knowing that fans were outside waiting - then shame on her for not having the decency to just come out and kindly tell fans that she wasn't signing or doing pictures with them. How hard was it to tell fans the truth? Now, it seems that Alison Goldfrapp seems to shun even the heartiest of fans. Truly a shame.








My StumbleUpon Page
Comments
i was outside the stage entrance for awhile after the concert & it was barely raining @ all. maybe it drizzled a lil every now & then, but we weren't soaking wet out there. i left a lil bit after my friend abby got a pic taken with charlie & davide but she stayed, determined to meet alison. from what i understood from her, alison was in the building for most of the time that they were waiting. but as hard as it is to believe, alison is very shy. she even said she was overwhelmed while on stage. after being a rabid fan for a few years now, i really doubt that she consciously snubbed the fans. i think the rain, or just the gross yuckiness outside, her shyness, & the rest of that wine bottle i'm sure she had have more to do with why she didn't greet the fans. i think abby said something about her car being on the other side of the building, so she could've went to the stage entrance door mistakenly. if they were running late (they played in toronto that weekend too), she may not have even had time to acknowledge them.
sorry for the huge post, but i just love alison to death & feel the need to defend her as much as possible. =]~
Posted by: jerm on September 20, 2008 at 12:42 AM