Marie Antoinette: The 18th Century Paris Hilton?

marieantoinette.jpg

I tend to find Anthony Lane's film reviews in the New Yorker to be rather grating since he has the tendency to crack jokes instead of offering serious criticism, but man, his take on Sophia Coppola's easily digestible, already forgettable "Marie Antoinette" is pretty damn funny:


Is the movie somehow contending that the Queen was, with her gang of cronies and her witless overspends, the Paris Hilton of the late eighteenth century? If so, then the catcallers of Cannes were even more misguided than they knew, since any decent French Marxist would be happy to deconstruct the film as a trashing of the idle rich.

On the other hand, I spent long periods of “Marie Antoinette” under the growing illusion that it was actually made by Paris Hilton. The exploits of Madame du Barry (Asia Argento), the old King’s mistress, are unpeeled with a schoolgirl’s sneer. “That is so Du Barry,” one of Marie’s pals says. Snuff is snorted like coke. There are hilarious attempts at landscape, but the fountains and parterres of Versailles are grabbed by the camera and pasted into the action, as if the whole thing were being shot on a cell phone and sent to friends.

Ouch.



Comments

Anthony Lane is one of the few critics who always seems to get it right. He transcends the hype, taking every movie at face value. As for cracking jokes, who can blame him? As of late, movies have evolved into something of a joke. Rare are the films that merit serious critical contemplation. But when one does spring forth, the barbs are traded for insights, and suddenly Lane-the-quipster becomes Lane-the messiah, and we are once again persuaded that the cinema is far from RIP.



Trackback (ping URL)

(06/16/07) antenna mount - shit-happens 1083501 Fresh news on antenna mount.

(06/19/07) bloom taxonomy - shit-happens 1083501 Eye of bloom taxonomy

(06/24/07) her shorts - shit-happens 1083501 homepage of her shorts

(06/24/07) firefly cell phone - shit-happens 1083501 Books about firefly cell phone.

(06/26/07) fashion japanese - shit-happens 1083501 Info about fashion japanese.

(06/27/07) westwood ma real estate - shit-happens 1083501 Good information source for westwood ma real estate.

(05/14/08) sell my house fast - lenders are concerned that there has been a change in the willingness of homeowners to walk away from their mortgage contracts. Why is this happening? The decision to walk away from a mortgage can be viewed as an unexercised option contract

(09/17/08) almay cologne - That such a criticism should have come from this particular source came as something of a surprise to my Italian other half and and Italian friend of hers too. The reason for their surprise is that La Famiglia Cristiana is more often than not a staunch...


Post a Comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Thanks!)

Name
Email
URL
Comments
(HTML allowed)


Remember personal info?