A Capra Classic Made Whole

Reviews
by Leonard Maltin
April 2, 2012 1:00 AM
6 Comments
  • |

A year before It Happened One Night famously swept the Oscars, Frank Capra and screenwriter Robert Riskin made Lady for a Day, which earned four Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture—but because it was withheld from TV and 16mm distribution for years, it never attained the widespread awareness and residual affection that other Capra classics have always enjoyed. A new, beautifully restored DVD and Blu-ray from Inception Media—with a sequence that was missing from an earlier dvd release—may help to remedy that injustice.

Oddly enough, it was Capra himself who pulled Lady for a Day from circulation, so that it wouldn’t be compared to his 1961 remake, Pocketful of Miracles. (The same thing happened to Capra’s Broadway Bill, the film that followed It Happened One Night: it wound up buried and neglected in Paramount’s library when he remade it for that studio as Riding High.) Because no studio owned the picture, it wasn’t cared for, and the original negative disappeared.

Timing is everything: the belief that It’s a Wonderful Life was in the public domain enabled so many people to broadcast it and sell videos that it became a permanent part of the public consciousness in the 1970s and 80s. I remember channel-surfing one Christmas eve and finding it playing on four different cable channels! If only that had been true for Lady for a Day.

Original Film Element Main Title Card - 'Lady For A Day'
In 1977, a negative and new prints of the film were struck from Capra’s personal 35mm print; finally, the movie was made available for retrospectives, and eventually released on DVD with an introduction and commentary track by Frank Capra, Jr. I will never forget the first time I got to see the film, at the fondly-remembered Regency Theatre on Broadway in Manhattan. My wife and I left the show walking on air: this is the kind of movie that genuinely lifts your spirits. That was the kind of magic that Capra and Riskin created at the height of their powers in the 1930s.

'Lady For A Day' Main Title Card - Restored Element
There are hints of that magic in Platinum Blonde (1931) and American Madness (1932), but it fully blossoms for the first time in Lady for a Day (1933), which is based on the Damon Runyon story “Madame La Gimp.” May Robson (who earned an Oscar nomination) plays Apple Annie, a frumpy woman who sells flowers on the street. Slick gambler Dave the Dude (Warren William) considers her a good-luck charm, which is why, when Annie needs help, he’s willing to pitch in, albeit reluctantly. She has told her daughter, that she is a member of New York society, and now the girl is coming to New York with her high-born fiancée. Annie is bereft…but Dave’s girlfriend Missouri Martin (Glenda Farrell) persuades him and his cronies that it’s worthwhile to help Annie pull off a near-miraculous masquerade. In time, every crook, bum, and political figure in town gets yanked into the proceedings.

This Depression-era fable still resonates because Capra and Riskin allow us to indulge in a wish-fulfillment fairy tale. They ask us to believe that anybody, from a beggar to a governor, has some good in him, and will do the right thing when given the opportunity.

The original DVD release of Lady for a Day was a good, sharp transfer of Frank Capra’s 35mm print, with all of its inherent wear and tear intact. For the new release, video wizards at ADS (Advanced Digital Services) have gone through it frame by frame, repairing tears and flaws, removing dirt and scratches, and best of all, adjusting the contrast so that Joseph Walker’s luminous photography looks the way it originally did, with true blacks and whites, and every shade of gray in-between. Walker was a master and it’s a shame to see any of his films looking less than perfect.

This transfer also includes a 4½ minute scene at about the 55-minute mark that, for some reason, doesn’t exist in the earlier copy. It’s a continuation of a conversation between Barrie Norton, Apple Annie’s future son-in-law, and his father, played by Walter Connolly, followed by a longer version of a scene with Warren William and Guy Kibbee as they discuss who should be invited to Annie’s party.

You might also like:
Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

6 Comments

  • Mary | September 14, 2012 8:52 PMReply

    I got this restored version - wow, is it stunning. It's amazing how spellbinding the material is when it looks so beautiful. Great review, Mr. Maltin, and great version of this movie!

  • Barney Again | April 3, 2012 3:52 PMReply

    Leo, reviewing these kinds of movies will not keep you on the cutting, competitive edge. I needed a review of the straight-to-dvd movie "Cropsey" and it's not here! All I get is this gushy review about some obsolete tripe made in the stone age that nobody cares about (except senior citizens). You made a big mistake separating from Ebert 15 years ago, friend-o.

  • Brian | April 5, 2012 5:59 PM

    "Barney Again," I don't think Leonard really cares if he's on the "cutting, competitive edge" or not. He reviews the films he's passionate about. I'm really sorry you can't appreciate a movie made by a master craftsman like Frank Capra, so you might as well leave it to the true cinema aficionados who actually have real brains, unlike you. You really need to step away....far, far away....from the bong.

  • Jim Reinecke | April 4, 2012 1:43 PM

    "Barney Again?" Or would that be "Barney Rubble Still"? And you call this film, by one of the great filmmakers of all time, "obsolete tripe made in the stone age" when your attitude and taste (or readily apparent lack of) certainly indicates a mentality that would have aroused the interest of Dr. Louis Leakey. "Cropsey", eh? Sure that you didn't misspell this title by substituting an "o" for an "a"? There is a reason that this mindless drivel goes direct to video and if I have to spell it out for you then you're probably even more of a lobotomized sea monkey than you initially seemed. I'm sure that if you look hard enough, and in the right place (like the wall of a stoner bar's men's room), you'll find your much needed study of "Crapsey". (Hey, Leonard, do you think that a first-rate historian and wordsmith like Scott Eyman contributed to that one? It is to laugh!)

  • Alonso Duralde | April 2, 2012 3:46 PMReply

    Looking forward to seeing it! Oddly enough, Jackie Chan did a remake of the film — and it's one of his best directorial efforts — called "Mr. Canton and Lady Rose," but also known as "Black Dragon" and "Miracles." If you've never seen it, it's worth a look.

  • Karen | April 2, 2012 10:23 AMReply

    This is a wonderful movie. I saw it at the Regency Theater also ! The only improvement (if you want to call it that) to the remake "Pocketful of Miracles" was preferring Peter Falk over Ned Sparks in the role of Dave the Dude's right-hand man. Although Sparks is terrific, in my opinion he can't hold a candle to Falk's hilarious performance (which was nominated for an Oscar). In any case, this DVD sounds like a winner, just for the commentary and extras involved !

Email Updates

Latest Tweets

Follow us

Most "Liked"

  • Movie Heaven, Courtesy Of TCM
  • From the Beginning - An Orphan Black ...
  • Fading Gigolo
  • Transcendence


leonardmaltin