Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Confessions Of A Sundance Juror

by Leonard Maltin
January 27, 2014 9:10 PM
  • |

I got to experience this year’s Sundance Film Festival in a way few others did: as a member of the U.S. Dramatic Competition jury. It was a great experience, challenging at times but definitely worthwhile. The best part of being a juror is that a driver takes you to every screening where prime seats are reserved.

The U.S. Dramatic Competition jury: Lone Scherfig, yours truly, Dana Stevens, and Peter Saraf, with Bryan Singer out in front.
The U.S. Dramatic Competition jury: Lone Scherfig, yours truly, Dana Stevens, and Peter Saraf, with Bryan Singer out in front.

If that sounds mundane, let me explain: navigating this wintry festival as a civilian can be daunting, especially during the jam-packed opening weekend. (I remember standing and shivering one frigid night some years ago, awaiting the arrival of a shuttle bus to take me to my next showing.) Some 45,000 people descend on Park City, Utah over the course of the ten-day event, and even after the “cool kids” depart on Monday and Tuesday, screenings are often sold out and people turned away.

The other “best part” of being on this panel was spending time with my fellow jurors: critic and podcast host Dana Stevens, filmmaker Lone Scherfig (An Education, Italian for Beginners), producer and Sundance veteran Peter Saraf (Little Miss Sunshine, Safety Not Guaranteed), and prolific director-producer Bryan Singer (The Usual Suspects, X Men). We got along extremely well and were pleased to discover that we had similar taste, which isn’t always the case in situations like this. Having two critics and three articulate and astute filmmakers on the panel made for stimulating conversations all week long.

Still smiling and enthusiastic: Robert Redford at the 30th anniversary kickoff for his assembly of independent filmmakers.
Still smiling and enthusiastic: Robert Redford at the 30th anniversary kickoff for his assembly of independent filmmakers.

Because I had to teach my first class of the semester at USC on Thursday night, I missed the opening ceremonies and arrived late Friday; the other jurors were already one or two films ahead of me. That meant I had to log three feature films a day in order to catch up and take in all sixteen titles in our category. That left me little time or energy to see anything outside my required quota. (Fortunately, at the end of the road on Friday I was able to see Steve James’ beautiful documentary about Roger Ebert, Life Itself. This candid portrait of the influential and inspiring critic will be released theatrically and will wind up on CNN, which helped to finance it. I’m glad such a worthy doc will reach the wide audience it deserves.) On Saturday morning we were shuttled to the Sundance Institute for a filmmakers’ brunch where founder Robert Redford reminisced about his early days as an actor when he went through the often-humiliating audition process and learned what it was like to fail. He offered empathy and support for the efforts of this year’s participants in the gathering he initiated thirty years ago.

Day by day, we saw films at public showings—often their premieres—and had the chance to stay for q&a sessions, which are always interesting and informative. We had to discount the wild cheering that greeted many of the screenings, which were packed with the directors’ family, friends, and coworkers. This may give the creators a welcome ego boost, but it may not reflect how an ordinary audience will respond.

By Friday evening, when it was time for our official deliberation, we thought we could breeze through the process in a half-hour or so. We then decided that it would be irresponsible not to review each of the sixteen titles in contention and voice our feelings one more time. Four and a half hours later we reached our decision, intentionally spreading our awards among as many films as possible and citing them for their particular strengths.

The awards ceremony on Saturday night was electrifying at times. I hadn’t stopped to think that we were part of a newsmaking event: after all, it isn’t just individual movies that are launched at Sundance but entire careers. The recipients were jubilant, and rightly so: their hard work paid off with a prestigious prize and the promise of a bright road ahead. I can’t wait for audiences to see some of our selections, including Damien Chazelle’s Whiplash, which won both the Grand Jury Prize and the Audience Award, Craig Johnson’s The Skeleton Twins, Jeff Preiss’ Low Down, Cutter Hodierne’s Fishing Without Nets, David and Nathan Zellner’s Kumiko, the Treasure Hunter, and Justin Simien’s Dear White People. They aren’t all perfect movies, but they feature fresh new voices that deserve encouragement. We on the jury can’t wait to see what these writers and directors do next, and that sense of emerging talent is what the Sundance Film Festival is all about.


Postscript: on Saturday afternoon my daughter Jessie and I got another perspective on the festival as our friend Chapin Cutler, the longtime technical director at Sundance (as well as Telluride and other leading film events) gave us a tour behind the scenes at the festival nerve center. I daresay few people ever think about the logistics involved in such an endeavor, nor should they. But when you learn that 486 pieces of content were shipped into Park City, in a variety of film and digital formats, and every one of them was personally inspected…or that the print traffic team was responsible for 5,000 deliveries (that’s 28 films per hour, 18 hours a day, for 11 days) you start to appreciate how much work goes into such an enterprise. Every piece of projection and sound equipment has at least one backup, and just as at Telluride, many of the theaters are actually converted spaces—from a library to a synagogue—that magically become screening facilities with world-class projection and perfect sight lines. Chapin and his team at Boston Light & Sound have the benefit of experience behind them, as well as vast technical knowledge. These highly dedicated people love what they do and perform daily miracles to make sure things go right throughout the festival. 

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    


  • J. Grube Madsen | January 29, 2014 8:42 AMReply

    Hi Leonard,
    Thanks for the post, which brings its share of envy to film-lovers like myself who also want to be chauffeured around to movie premieres.
    Glad to see fellow Dane Scherfig in the jury, and since you mention her Italian for Beginners, I guess you have seen it, (but no review in here). Anyway, I just want to recommend that film, if you haven't, because it is Scherfig's best and a really wonderfully funny, romantic, real Dogme romcom.
    Looking forward to seeing some of the Sundance films myself.
    Best regards,

  • Jokersmith | January 27, 2014 10:03 PMReply

    Thanks for your fascinating behind the scenes look at the festival. I think I have a man crush on Dana Stevens. I guess that's just a regular crush then.

  • Jokersmith | January 28, 2014 1:39 PM

    Since there seems to be some confusion on Twitter, I am the man in this scenario. Hence the "regular" crush clarification which, apparently, wasn't clear or funny enough.

    Note to self: don't try to be funny unless you are Jesse Eisenberg. And you are not.
    Note to self: keep notes to self to one sentence. And too yourself. (Oops.)

Email Updates

Latest Tweets

Follow us

Most "Liked"

  • Hercule Poirot-David SuchetThe First and Final Days as Poirot: ...
  • New Laurel & Hardy Book: Love At First ...
  • Blind Husbands-Erich Von StroheimThrowback Thursday: Von Stroheim!