Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

film review: Barney's Version

by Leonard Maltin
January 14, 2011 12:26 AM
5 Comments
  • |

Paul Giamatti is one of those actors whose presence in a movie generally validates it, and Barney’s Version is no exception. He manages to make a central character with few—if any—admirable traits not only bearable but downright compelling. And if this Barney strays from the way Mordecai Richler painted him in his first-person novel, he still justifies his existence in this entertaining film.

No one who is familiar with Richler’s writings—or the wonderful 1974 film The Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz, which starred Richard Dreyfuss—should be shocked to learn that the protagonist of this tall tale is a Canadian Jew. Barney Panofsky makes a living producing a pedestrian TV series, but his appetite for life away from work is enormous. In his early years he experiences La Vie Bohème in Rome, where he meets and marries his first wife (Rachelle Lefevre). Later on, back home in Montreal, he marries again, but not for—

—love; Minnie Driver plays the unfortunate second Mrs. Panofsky. Then Barney is smitten with the beautiful Miriam (Rosamund Pike), and determines to make her Wife Number Three—no matter what it takes.

Along the way we meet some of Barney’s friends and at least one of his enemies. The biggest treat is getting to know his father, a retired Montreal cop who is socially embarrassing but a mensch at heart. He is portrayed, with great gusto, by Dustin Hoffman, the second reason this movie is worth seeing. Hoffman seems to be having a great time playing this uninhibited character, and the feeling is infectious.

I wish Barney’s Version had a little more meat on its bones, as I suspect its source novel does. One can’t help but feel that some of its subplots and supporting characters have more to them than they do here, where they are dealt with in casual or hurried fashion. Yet the film remains enjoyable because the actors bring so much to Michael Konyves’s screenplay. Fortunately, director Richard J. Lewis, who has worked mostly in television, seems to understand that this endeavor is all about character and story, not stylistics.

Finally, there is a series of in-jokes for diehard film buffs: cameo appearances by some of Canada’s most notable directors, all of whom have worked for producer Robert Lantos in years past. David Cronenberg and Atom Egoyan turn up as directors of Barney’s silly TV show. Ted Kotcheff (who made Duddy Kravitz) is a train conductor, and Denys Arcand is a suave maître d’ at a restaurant. A nice touch.

  • |

More: Film Reviews

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

5 Comments

  • Fertnerd | January 23, 2011 7:52 AMReply

    Just saw the movie. Absolutely stunning portrayals by all actors, not just Giammati & Hoffman. Screenplay must have been a story in itself because it does the impossible: convert the big first person narration book into streamlined cinema providing depth where it needs to be and giving the actors enough guidance to really ply their trade. Probably my most enjoyable movie going experience in years, especially given the high price of tickets these days. Graci! Bravo!

  • Shal21 | January 15, 2011 10:41 AMReply

    Hello Leonard ! Thanks for the review. Will surely watch this movie.

    @ Santos- I agree Giammati did made some bad choice in selecting his movies, but he is a great actor, his versatileness amazes me. Lady in the water was bad bad choice of him.

  • H.L. Atkinson | January 15, 2011 8:52 AMReply

    Though I didn't always warm to Mordecai Richler's fiction, I always enjoyed his real life appearances on Canadian television. He also wrote a column for a now defunct magazine and in one revealed that he was the uncredited writer of the final screenplay for "Room At The Top", the successful 1959 Laurence Harvey-Simone Signoret film. Richler does have a screenplay credit on the less successful 1965 sequel with Harvey, Jean Simmons and Honor Blackman.It was directed by Ted Kotcheff, who I see has a cameo in "Barney's Version." I guess i'll have to see the film, including the part where our jerk of a hero spots a new love at one of his weddings. To quote the book: "My heart ached at the sight of her. I knew right then, I'd married the wrong one."

  • Leslie | January 15, 2011 5:33 AMReply

    I hated the book and was not overly impressed with the movie as a whole. I was, however, impressed with Paul Giammati's performance.

  • Santos | January 14, 2011 10:35 AMReply

    I'm not sure what you mean by the validation comment. Giammati has been in his share of bad movies (Lady in the Water comes to mind, although I didn't outright hate it like others did). However, he himself is always great regardless of the quality of the movie itself.

Email Updates

Latest Tweets

Follow us

Most "Liked"

  • Curtain-David Suchet-PoirotWhy David Suchet Came So Close To Missing ...
  • The Major and the Minor-485Throwback Thursday: Ginger Rogers, Billy ...
  • Charlie Chaplin at Comic-ConCharlie Chaplin At Comic-Con
  • Guardians of the Galaxy-Saldana-PrattGuardians Of The Galaxy
  • Calvary-Brendan Gleeson-promoCalvary
  • Get On Up-Chadwick BosemanGet On Up


leonardmaltin