Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Finally! Laurel & Hardy On Dvd

Reviews
by Leonard Maltin
November 3, 2011 3:00 AM
9 Comments
  • |


It’s a cultural crime that the greatest comedy team of all time has been so forsaken on DVD…until now. Therefore, I’m happy to report that Laurel & Hardy The Essential Collection (Vivendi) fully lives up to its name. It includes all of the team’s talkie shorts—including the ones they made in foreign languages for the international market—and most of their feature films for producer Hal Roach. (A handful of these films were released several years ago, but in slipshod fashion, using syndicated TV masters with fade-outs for commercial breaks!)

Bombastic Billy Gilbert encounters Stan and Ollie midway up that endless flight of steps in The Music Box.

I know many people who were so desperate to have this material that they purchased all-region DVD players just so they could play the British boxed set of L&H comedies some years ago. That nicely-packaged collection also included colorized editions, which most fans wouldn’t bother to watch.

Now, thanks to the untiring efforts of Richard Bann, the Roach library has been treated right on this 10-disc set. The original MGM logo and art-deco main titles, which were—

—replaced decades ago, have been faithfully restored. Vivendi has used the best 35mm source material available and transferred the films in high-definition. (This in no way minimizes the need for this collection to undergo thorough modern-day preservation of the original sound and picture elements, as the UCLA Film and Television Archive is doing right now. Learn more HERE.)

I haven’t had time to watch every film in its entirety, but I’m very happy with what I’ve sampled, including the best-looking copy of the Oscar-winning short The Music Box I’ve ever seen. The packaging and menus are attractive and the liner notes by Dick Bann couldn’t be better. Dick has also recorded several commentary tracks which are jam-packed with background information no one else could provide. (Dick has devoted much of his life to researching the films of Hal Roach, and spent many years as Mr. Roach’s trusted confidant. He and I collaborated on a book, The Little Rascals: The Life and Times of Our Gang years ago.) He is joined by comedy scholar and aficionado Rich Correll—they have so much to say about Hog Wild that it requires two separate audio tracks—and Hal Roach music expert Piet Schreuders. A separate commentary for Sons of the Desert features lifelong L&H enthusiasts Chuck McCann and Tim Conway, who know a thing or two about comedy.

A tribute to Stan and Ollie features McCann and Conway on camera along with such notable fans as Dick Van Dyke, Jerry Lewis, Bob Einstein, and Penn and Teller. Dick Bann is joined by fellow experts Bob Satterfield, Jimmy Wiley II and Jimmy III for a lively tour of Laurel and Hardy locations, then and now.

But wait—there’s more. The short-subject Laughing Gravy features ten minutes of footage that was never released in the U.S. (but was adopted for the foreign-language versions). There are also complete versions of the three Hal Roach talkie shorts in which L&H made unbilled guest appearances: On the Loose with Thelma Todd and ZaSu Pitts, Wild Poses with Our Gang, and On the Wrong Trek with Charley Chase, as well as the U.S. Department of Agriculture short The Tree in a Test Tube (1942), the only time Laurel and Hardy were filmed in color. There are even rarely-seen original-issue preview trailers for Pack Up Your Troubles, A Chump at Oxford, and Saps at Sea.

I grew up watching these films every single day on local television; kids who came of age over the past thirty years haven’t seen so lucky, and neither have Laurel and Hardy, who have receded from their position of prominence in our culture. It’s high time they were reintroduced, and this DVD set will go a long way towards that goal. (Turner Classic Movies also makes good use of the Hal Roach library, but that doesn’t compare to the ubiquitous presence these movies had in the early days of television.)

To complete your library of Laurel & Hardy on DVD, you should also own the double-feature The Devil’s Brother and Bonnie Scotland, beautifully restored and released several years ago by Warner Home Video. (Dick Bann and I can be heard on their commentary tracks.)

And if you want to know the long, sad story of how the Roach library has been passed from hand to hand, and mistreated along the way, you should read Dick’s exhaustive essay on the subject at the official Laurel and Hardy website HERE

Now all we have to do is get the Laurel and Hardy silent shorts to be released with the same loving care.


Reviews
  • |

More: DVD Reviews

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

9 Comments

  • P. L. Silverman | November 28, 2013 11:11 PMReply

    Mr. Maltin, have U seen the ATOLL K(uncut) DVD?

  • Danny Proctor | December 24, 2011 6:41 PMReply

    As a lifelong fan of Stan & Ollie, my heart skipped a beat when I learned of this DVD release. Like Mr. Maltin, I also grew up watching the boys on afternoon TV. By the time I actually got to see their movies, I was 15 or 16 and had already read Mr. McCabe's book and everything my local library could provide on Mr. Laurel and Mr. Hardy. When I read that Stan, after seeing how poorly the films were butchered for commercial interruptions, offered to deaf ears to come to the TV station and actually edit them properly himself, it broke my heart. I have waited patiently for decades and finally can make this collection part of my library. The Three Stooges collection was very well done and seems to have sold strongly enough for them to complete the series. Let's hope fans will snatch this up to encourage a similar set with the Laurel & Hardy silents. My gratitude and congratulations to Richard Bann and everyone who had a hand in this release. Long live Stan & Ollie!

  • Eric Schultz | November 24, 2011 8:14 AMReply

    This is a very nice article. Indeed, Laurel and Hardy have been overlooked and neglected on television for decades, and their best films have hardly been available in the U.S. since the introduction of DVD. It is really great that these films are FINALLY available in proper form on this side of the world. I think that Mr. Maltin should consider putting together a new version of his 1973 "Laurel and Hardy Book". The original was very nice, but has been out of print for many years now.

  • dwj | November 8, 2011 10:42 PMReply

    Just received my L&H - what joy, worth every cent.

  • Randy Skretvedt | November 4, 2011 2:55 AMReply

    And Mr. Bann and I did commentaries for "Way Out West," as well...

  • James Knuttel | November 4, 2011 1:35 AMReply

    Correction to my previous comment: I meant to say THE ROGUE SONG.

  • James Knuttel | November 4, 2011 1:33 AMReply

    All but two of Laurel & Hardy's silent shorts were issued on DVD several years ago by Image Entertainment. These discs are now out-of-print.

    A minor correction to your comments, Leonard: THE TREE IN A TEST TUBE was not Laurel & Hardy's only color film. in 1930 they appeared in MGM's two-color Technicolor musical THE ROGUE SONGS. Only a few fragments (along with the entire soundtrack) survive from this film.

  • Richard W. Bann | November 3, 2011 11:52 AMReply

    That decision has not been made yet. There is always a chance, yes, but chances improve as a function of how well this set performs.

  • Colin | November 3, 2011 11:17 AMReply

    Sounds great! Any chance of a Blu-ray release?

Email Updates

Latest Tweets

Follow us

Most "Liked"

  • Melanie Lynskey-Joe SwanbergHappy Christmas
  • Magic in the Moonlight-Colin Firth-Emma StoneMagic In The Moonlight
  • Snow White Marketing Campaign-9th WeekThrowback Thursday: See Disney’s Snow ...
  • Curtain-David Suchet-PoirotWhy David Suchet Came So Close To Missing ...
  • Charlie Chaplin at Comic-ConCharlie Chaplin At Comic-Con
  • Douglas-Keaton- Clay EnosAnd So It Goes


leonardmaltin