Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Saving Mr. Banks

Reviews
by Leonard Maltin
December 13, 2013 12:03 AM
3 Comments
  • |
Photo by François Duhamel - © Disney Enterprises, Inc.

You can see all kinds of movies this holiday season, from a gargantuan fantasy tale to a gripping war drama, but I daresay there’s only one that offers charm, delight, and a finale that will bring tears to your eyes. That’s Saving Mr. Banks. That such a lovely, heartfelt film could be made at a time when irony and darkness dominate mainstream moviemaking is a minor miracle. Yet with delicacy and taste, Saving Mr. Banks spins a fascinating story about the people whose rocky collaboration resulted in a beloved movie, Mary Poppins. Having grown up watching Walt Disney on television, I doubted that anyone could imitate him to my satisfaction, but I was wrong: Tom Hanks embodies the look and spirit of the public Walt and provides some telling hints about the private man as well. (Note the actor’s stance during meetings and his formidable smoker’s cough.) P.L. Travers was a more private individual, yet surviving tape recordings of her story sessions at the Disney studio confirm that Emma Thompson has captured this eccentric author to a T. (Don’t leave without listening to the evidence, played during the closing credits.)

The movie tells two parallel stories: Walt Disney’s wooing of the contrary Pamela Travers during a tense two-week visit to his studio in California, and, through flashback, the events of Travers’ childhood in Australia—especially her relationship with a loving but irresponsible father (played by Colin Farrell)—that formed her personality and inspired her to create her Poppins stories.

Photo by François Duhamel - © Disney Enterprises, Inc.

In both milieus, director John Lee Hancock has used restraint, a rare commodity in modern Hollywood movies. The childhood scenes are played with the seriousness that befits young Pamela’s lifelong attachment to them. The sequences that take place in a rehearsal room at the Disney studio (involving writer-producer Don DaGradi and songwriters Richard and Robert Sherman) may strike some viewers as rose-colored, yet will seem completely credible to anyone who’s read up on the workings of the Disney company at that time. Richard Sherman served as a valuable consultant to both the actors and filmmakers, including screenwriter Kelly Marcel, who shares screen credit with Sue Smith, the author of an unproduced Travers biopic.

Does that mean that Saving Mr. Banks tells the whole, unvarnished truth? I doubt it. I don’t know if P.L. Travers actually had a driver as earnest and winning as the one played by Paul Giamatti during her stay in Los Angeles. I can’t vouch for every detail of Poppins’ inspiration from Travers’ childhood. But I’ve learned not to get my history (recent or distant) from movies. What Saving Mr. Banks does offer is a heartwarming piece of entertainment, highlighted by a handful of superior performances. Walt Disney himself couldn’t have asked for more.

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

3 Comments

  • Tom Murphy | December 27, 2013 9:36 PMReply

    For me, the best film out this year. Ms. Thompson should receive an Oscar nomination.

  • Allen Blank | December 26, 2013 8:31 PMReply

    I loved it from the beginning to the end. The only negative point at all for me and it's really nitpicking is the scene where P.L. Travers enters her hotel room and sees all the plush dolls that are left for her. There are a couple of Winnie The Pooh dolls. "Winnie The Pooh and the Honey Tree" came out in two years after Mary Poppins. but that is the only fault I find in this wonderful film

  • Jeffrey | December 23, 2013 12:03 PMReply

    This film is a tremendous achievement for both Emma Thompson and Tom Hanks. It is also a charming portrayal of an important piece of moviemaking history, as Mr. Maltin correctly points out.

Email Updates

Latest Tweets

Follow us

Most "Liked"

  • From Robin Williams To Film Noir…
  • Too Much Johnson-Joseph CottenOrson Welles Discovery Now Online


leonardmaltin