Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

The Master—movie review

Reviews
by Leonard Maltin
September 14, 2012 1:05 AM
6 Comments
  • |

courtesy of The Weinstein Company
The Master flirts with greatness and has much to admire, including exceptional performances from Joaquin Phoenix and Philip Seymour Hoffman. Their work is reason enough to recommend the film, yet at the screening I attended the audience was strangely silent at the end. That’s because this audacious, original piece of work is less than fully satisfying.

I had heard that The Master was to be Paul Thomas Anderson’s fictionalized exposé of Scientology, but it isn’t so. He might be dramatizing the life of Aimee Semple McPherson or any other charismatic spieler who developed a following in the 20th century. While the movie does deal with the formative years of a “movement” called The Cause, Anderson’s primary focus is the complex relationship between a magnetic self-promoter named Lancaster Dodd (Hoffman) and a lost soul still suffering the emotional scars of World War Two. Freddie Quell (Phoenix) is a strange, inarticulate, oversexed loner with a talent for making moonshine who stumbles into Hoffman’s rarefied world quite by chance and stays because he has nowhere else to go. Why Hoffman takes such an interest in the animalistic young man is never explained, but these two disparate men form a bond, and there’s no question that it’s a two-way connection.

Both actors are working at the peak of their powers. Phoenix’s harsh, almost emaciated look and expressive body language manage to convey all the turmoil going on in his head. We never fully comprehend why he is such a tortured soul—“beyond saving,” in the words of Hoffman’s steely wife, well played by Amy Adams—but we marvel at his mood swings and often contradictory behavior.

Courtesy of The Weinstein Company

Hoffman’s Lancaster Dodd is a meticulous-looking charmer blessed with the gift of gab. He’s seldom caught off guard except, now and then, by the actions of his randy and violent protégé. Hoffman projects the precise mix of leadership qualities and bluster to be credible as a man who inspires people to follow (or is it “swallow”?) his teachings, which his own son avers he is making up as he goes along.

Part of the appeal of The Master is its seemingly effortless recreation of time and place, as filmed by Mihai Malaimare, Jr. in crisp 65mm. By choosing just the right locations and casting unfamiliar actors (with period-appropriate hairstyles and clothing) in the supporting roles, Anderson never has to over-sell the idea that we are in post-War America; we simply believe it. The production design by Jack Fisk and David Crank is superb, never flashy. Jonny Greenwood’s discordant score is punctuated by perfectly-chosen music of the era, like Duke Ellington’s jaunty “Dancers in Love.”

But what, ultimately, is this film about? We’re left to make up our own minds about Dodd and his controversial Cause, and we never have a chance to penetrate the enigma of Freddie. Parts of the lengthy film are deliberately strange and difficult to penetrate. There is a musical passage near the end of the film that defies belief, let alone understanding, but I suppose one shouldn’t expect explicit storytelling from the man who climaxed Magnolia with a shower of frogs.

The Master provides a challenging, alternately rewarding and frustrating experience unlike any other I’ve encountered this year. I’m sorry I couldn’t fully embrace it, but in the long run I’d rather watch Paul Thomas Anderson aim for the fences and miss than slog through sheer mediocrity.

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

6 Comments

  • David Mortimer | November 22, 2012 7:53 AMReply

    I went to see this last night, I must say that it has fantastic camera work, direction also top notch, acting was amazing, I loved the period piece settings but this is where we start to hit road bumps ,the story unfortunately leaves a lot to be desired and for me I kept asking when is this going to take off looking at my watch and my other thought was how will it end just as it started it seems .

  • Andrew | September 20, 2012 7:35 PMReply

    Always such wonderful reviews in here!

  • Visiter | September 17, 2012 10:03 AMReply

    "I’m sorry I couldn’t fully embrace it, but in the long run I’d rather watch Paul Thomas Anderson aim for the fences and miss than slog through sheer mediocrity."

    That is pretty rich, considering that you praise mediocrities all the time.

  • north face sale | September 17, 2012 9:34 AMReply

    north face jackets http://www.salethenorthfacejackets.com
    north face outlet http://www.salethenorthfacejackets.com
    north face sale http://www.salethenorthfacejackets.com
    north face women http://www.salethenorthfacejackets.com/the-north-face-women-1

  • Brett | September 14, 2012 7:26 PMReply

    Mr. Maltin's standards may seem exacting to some, but I can understand his inquiries. The film ultimately avoids answering what exactly made Freddie so troubled, although there is evidence that his deviant nature predated the war. But this is a film about power first and second, if at all, about psychology. The most important thing to know about Freddie is that he was poor and unemployed when Dodd met him, and Dodd used his desperate situation to turn him into a follower.

    There was a brief lull in the second hour, however it did not subtract from the film's achievement as much as has been suggested. This film is not for everybody. That much I will admit. But for the patient viewer, it is quite rewarding.

  • mike schlesinger | September 14, 2012 4:44 PMReply

    FWIW, I interpreted Dodd's interest in Freddie as, "If I can save this creep, I can save anybody!" I agree that it just misses, but my belief is that he left too much in the cutting room. Too often, things are discussed in a way that presumes we've seen them, or plot threads are opened and then tossed away. I suspect it could've been a lot more (for lack of a better word) satisfying, but Anderson clearly didn't want to go that route. So I'd call it 85% of a great movie.

Email Updates

Latest Tweets

Follow us

Most "Liked"

  • Life After Beth-DeHaan=PlazaLife After Beth
  • The Giver-Streep-BridgesThe Giver
  • Three Stooges-Nuts to YouThrowback Thursday: Promoting The Three ...
  • From Robin Williams To Film Noir…


leonardmaltin