Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Weekend B.O. Sept. 12-14 (Will 'No Good Deed's' Success Help Make Taraji P. Henson an A-lister?) Weekend B.O. Sept. 12-14 (Will 'No Good Deed's' Success Help Make Taraji P. Henson an A-lister?) Interview: John Sayles Tells S&A About 'Go For Sisters,' the Future of Indie Film, and 5 Historical Projects That Should Come to the Small Screen Interview: John Sayles Tells S&A About 'Go For Sisters,' the Future of Indie Film, and 5 Historical Projects That Should Come to the Small Screen Doc 'Take Me To The River' Celebrates Inter-racial Influence of Memphis Music (Opens Today) Doc 'Take Me To The River' Celebrates Inter-racial Influence of Memphis Music (Opens Today) Reginald Hudlin Is Getting Behind the Camera Again for an Untitled Comedy Project Reginald Hudlin Is Getting Behind the Camera Again for an Untitled Comedy Project Meet Your New-Look 'Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.' Entire Cast Assembles in All-New Season 2 Image Meet Your New-Look 'Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.' Entire Cast Assembles in All-New Season 2 Image Issa Rae + ColorCreative.TV to Premiere 3 New Television Pilots at Urbanworld Film Festival Issa Rae + ColorCreative.TV to Premiere 3 New Television Pilots at Urbanworld Film Festival Delicious Extended Trailer for 'American Horror Story: Freak Show' Debuts. Watch It Here. Delicious Extended Trailer for 'American Horror Story: Freak Show' Debuts. Watch It Here. Netflix Takes 'Wyatt Cenac: Brooklyn' Stand Up Comedy Special to Premiere October 21 Netflix Takes 'Wyatt Cenac: Brooklyn' Stand Up Comedy Special to Premiere October 21 Chiwetel Ejiofor Will Be Joined By Julia Roberts & Gwyneth Paltrow in Remake of Argentinian Thriller 'The Secret in Their Eyes' Chiwetel Ejiofor Will Be Joined By Julia Roberts & Gwyneth Paltrow in Remake of Argentinian Thriller 'The Secret in Their Eyes' Check Out the First Teaser-Trailer for 'Drumline: A New Beat' (Sequel to the 2002 Film) Check Out the First Teaser-Trailer for 'Drumline: A New Beat' (Sequel to the 2002 Film) 'Lucy' and the Absence of the Black Race in Origin of Humanity Theories 'Lucy' and the Absence of the Black Race in Origin of Humanity Theories Third 'Best Man' Movie Gets a Title, an Official 2016 Release Date & A Most Unexpected Wedding Third 'Best Man' Movie Gets a Title, an Official 2016 Release Date & A Most Unexpected Wedding Alexandra Shipp Will Replace Zendaya in Lifetime's Aaliyah Biopic + Wendy Williams Joins As Exec Producer Alexandra Shipp Will Replace Zendaya in Lifetime's Aaliyah Biopic + Wendy Williams Joins As Exec Producer South African Action-Romance 'Hard to Get' will Open 35th Durban International Film Festival (Poster) South African Action-Romance 'Hard to Get' will Open 35th Durban International Film Festival (Poster) 4 Black Women will Transform a "White Sister" Weekly on New Lifetime Series 'Girlfriend Intervention' 4 Black Women will Transform a "White Sister" Weekly on New Lifetime Series 'Girlfriend Intervention' Whoopi Goldberg & Daughter Alex Martin Enter Reality TV Series Ring Whoopi Goldberg & Daughter Alex Martin Enter Reality TV Series Ring VH1 Cancels 'Single Ladies' - Season 3 Will Be Its Last VH1 Cancels 'Single Ladies' - Season 3 Will Be Its Last 5 Netflix Streaming Titles You May Not Know Are Available & May Want To Check Out (9/6/13) 5 Netflix Streaming Titles You May Not Know Are Available & May Want To Check Out (9/6/13) Jay-Z Responds To Harry Belafonte's Challenge: 'My Presence Is Charity' (My Thoughts) Jay-Z Responds To Harry Belafonte's Challenge: 'My Presence Is Charity' (My Thoughts) 5 Netflix Streaming Titles You May Not Know Are Available & May Want To Check Out (7/26/13) 5 Netflix Streaming Titles You May Not Know Are Available & May Want To Check Out (7/26/13)

Are There Any Topics That Are Completely Off Limits In Comedy? Discuss...

Indiewire By Tambay A. Obenson | Shadow and Act August 20, 2013 at 5:08PM

In light of the recent brouhaha over the ill-conceived Harriet Tubman comedy skit on Russell Simmons' YouTube channel, some commentary and a question for you all - the question being: are there any topics that are completely off-limits when it comes to comedy?
14
Hmm

In light of the recent brouhaha over the ill-conceived Harriet Tubman comedy skit on Russell Simmons' YouTube channel, some commentary and a question for you all - the question being: are there any topics that are completely off-limits when it comes to comedy?

It’s an ongoing debate that comes up in the public sphere at least once a year it seems, usually when a comedian jokes about something or someone others deem seemingly exempt from being fodder for any comic's routine. Which is essentially what happened this time around, with Russell Simmons, who had to issue a public apology in reaction to swift and decisive criticism he found himself on the receiving end of.

It's practically a guaranteed annual (at least) occurrence: comedian says something controversial; people get outraged; comedian issues apology (sometimes); and then the debates begin, op-eds are written for and against, making the usual arguments about placing limits on comedy, versus that right that we call *free speech* - in this country (USA) anyway. There are countries where telling a risque joke can put the *offender* in very serious, potentially life-threatening trouble.

Although, here in the USA, while we supposedly have the right to speak freely, a constitutional right to free speech, some would argue that we are still very much constrained by certain laws as well as public opinion on what we can and cannot say publicly. Essentially - freedom of speech, but just watch what you say. 

Does this mean that comics should stay clear of what would widely be deemed offensive humor? Well, if they’re not prepared to handle any blowback, then yes. I believe that if you're going to go there, as the saying goes, be able to stay there, and stand your ground, and support your words. No apologies. Apologizing suggests that you obviously didn't think hard, long and critically enough about your joke before you made it public.

As you may have noticed, the more fearless comics amongst us tend to be intelligent, wise, thoughtful and articulate people who understand how powerful comedy and language can be in illuminating what ails societies, and helping to bring about an understanding that may not have been present previously. They know how to use comedy and language to get underneath the surface of things and make bold, subversive points, and not just blindly, thoughtlessly as a tool to shock.

Telling a joke about something or someone without some comprehensible underlying point to it all, isn’t comedy. That is, unless you're a comedian who's satisfied with what would amount to insults for the heck of it. And if you are, it's obviously your choice. But don’t be surprised nor feign shock and misunderstanding, nor run and hide, when others challenge and criticize you for it. You're free to speak, but not free from criticism.

So all that said, back to my original question: are there any subjects that you feel should be completely off-limits when it comes to comedy, no matter how smart and intelligently the joke is delivered? Or do you feel that nothing is exempt, and it is indeed all in the comic's delivery?

Discuss in the comments section below.

I recall Dave Chappelle's man-rape joke which sharply divided audiences a few years ago - some thought it was hilarious; others were deeply offended. And there was Louis C.K.'s appearance on The Daily Show discussing the limits of funny. Both clips embedded below.

This article is related to: Things That Make You Go Hmm...

Shadow & ActNewsletter