Must-Watch: Poignant 'Sugar' Explores Struggles Faced By Dominican Ball Player w/ Subtlety & Realism

Reviews
by Vanessa Martinez
June 18, 2012 3:32 PM
11 Comments
  • |

Here’s a film I should’ve watched three years ago upon its limited theatrical release; although it was indeed limited to only NY and LA. Sony Film Classics' 2009’s Indie Sugar is not your average sports flick; it avoids the usual for the love of the game and the glorious champion cliché’s so common among this genre.

Unsurprisingly, Sugar was deemed one of the 10 best films of 2009 by AFI, and currently ranks a 94% Rotten Tomatoes score.

The film’s success lies in its subtlety and realism and its nuanced performances, especially by the titular character Miguel Santos AKA “Azucar” (Sugar), played by newcomer Algenis Perez Soto. It almost comes across as a documentary. Filmmakers Anna Boden and Ryan Fleck, who wrote and directed the film, interviewed many Dominican immigrants playing baseball in minor league towns.  They also visited the Dominican Republic, where they discovered Perez Soto, who didn’t achieve his dream of playing professionally in the U.S.

It's a relevant subject. Unbeknownst to many, according to statistics, 20% of U.S. professional baseball players are from the Dominican Republic. We see the Hispanic last names, and, many figure these young players are lucky and thrilled to leave their impoverished countries for a chance for the big leagues. But it's not as simple as it seems. Yes, they have ambition, and these men love the game.

However, playing ball in their native countries along with their friends, among those within their culture, who speak their language, close to their loved ones, and being considered their town's celebrity is a very different ballgame than playing professionally in the U.S. -among strangers, facing bigotry, feeling displaced, isolated, and to top it all of, feeling the pressure to succeed against a language and culture barrier.

Sugar is the journey of Miguel, nicknamed Sugar for his sweet fast pitch; but to the viewer, Miguel, overall, is an affable "sweet" character. He loves his family, loves the game, loves his girlfriend, and he's endeared to many in his hometown. Miguel's family, who lost Sugar's father years ago, place all their hopes on him to make them proud by making it in the big leagues. Miguel has already started to build his family - mother, grandmother, and sister - a bigger house with a bonus from the baseball academy in the Dominican Republic. In this academy, aspiring U.S. players learn some English, at least the game's lingo. 

Miguel is chosen for spring training by Kansas City Knights (fictional team), and assigned to their Single A affiliate the Swing in Iowa. He is welcomed by the Higgins family, practicing Christians, who house players from the team every year. The Higgins mean well; Sugar abides to their rules, but he's lonely, and he's young.  

Anne, the Higgins' daughter, makes an effort to befriend Sugar and engage him socially in her Christian circle of friends. He's attracted to her, and develops a short lived attachment. She's especially attentive, but their social outings are awkward, and besides an obvious physical attraction, Sugar is really an outcast. Their two worlds are simply too different, and when Sugar acts upon his crush on her, she rejects his advances.

This only adds to Sugar's frustration and confusion. To make matters worse, on a night out at a club, he begins dancing with some Caucasian young women, and is caught in a physical confrontation by a Caucasian player.

Up until that point, it's interesting to note that Sugar seemed rather oblivious to bigotry and matters of race, compared to how such matters weigh heavily in the minds of many Blacks and Whites in America. Therefore, he can't readily connect with the other players aside from Jorge, another player from his hometown, and Brad Johnson (Andre Holland), an African American, whom Sugar begins a genuine camaraderie with.

Sugar and Brad's friendship comes with ease; it seems as Brad has familiarized himself with other Spanish speaking players in the league. He's patient and amused by Sugar's naiveté and ignorance about American Baseball trivia; most likely, their sense of kinship comes from being Black and minorities in the league. As a result, Brad, aside from veteran Jorge, is Sugar's real connecting bridge into American culture.

But after his closest friend Jorge is cut from the team, Sugar's confidence starts to crack under the pressure. He now feels more vulnerable than ever about failing, and feels more insecure about the new world around him. And it's heart-trending to watch him succumb to the pressure and lose control in the field. Soon after, Sugar flees to Bronx, NY, in search for his friend and a familiar turf. He finds refuge at the home of a workshop owner who befriends him, and whom Sugar offers woodwork help in exchange for housing and a place to build his mother a table.

In a latter scene of the film, the shop owner, who is not a fan of baseball, tells Sugar his favorite player is Black Puerto Rican Vic Power because of Power's remarks to a waitress after being told at a restaurant counter in 1951, "We don't serve colored people." Power's answer? "That's OK! I don't eat colored people. I just want some rice and beans."

A lesson in pride and facing struggles with humor and in stride in this bittersweet, touching story. Sugar a familiar story of many rejected professional baseball players in the U.S.; stories we don't hear about because they're about the so called losers; these journeys are all the more affecting due to immigrants' feeling of physical and cultural displacement. But it's a story of growing up, of courage, reflecting on what's really important and finding fulfillment on your own.

Unfortunately, Sugar is not available on Netflix as of yet. You can buy the Blu-Ray/DVD or watch instantly now on Amazon.

Watch the trailer:

Reviews
  • |

More: Reviews, DVD / Blu-Ray

You might also like:
Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

11 Comments

  • Ava | June 19, 2012 5:24 PMReply

    Hey, I mentioned this film, I think it was last week in response to the post about the Documentary about Dominican Baseball players that that Bobby Valentine is producing. I'm glad there was a separate post reminding people of this movie.
    I wonder what happened to Algenis Soto? His personality struck me as being a lot like the character he portrayed (in a strange way, he reminded me of the actor who starred as Victor Vargas). I wasn't sure whether he wanted to go on to pursue an acting career but he was so good in that movie, it almost made me want to call up my Dominican ex boyfriend and suggest that he watch the film. But then I remembered that I was indifferent to him nowadays. Oh well...Yeah, but the movie's a gem, if you haven't seen it, see it (lol).

  • Vanessa | June 19, 2012 6:58 PM

    Ava- I don't know if Algenis Soto is pursuing acting. Soto was an aspiring U.S. professional baseball player in the Dominican Republic when he was discovered for the lead. He definitely drew upon personal experiences to tell this story.

    And yes, if you haven't seen Sugar, do so now. :)

  • AccidentalVisitor | June 18, 2012 8:38 PMReply

    Saw this a few years back in the theater. Saw it the same weekend that I checked out the most recent Termintor flick with Christan Bale. It should come as no surprise that the little indie film was a lot more memorable desie costing $150 million less. Big fans of the filmmakers Fleck and Boden who also did Half Nelson. For a non-actor Soto was very impressive. Theater vet Holland was pretty good too in his small role. I was hoping hispart would propel him to more highrofile work. Silly me.

  • everyoneknowsmyname | June 18, 2012 5:28 PMReply

    A truly great one! It took a while to come out after making the festival rounds and never quite found the traction it deserved.

  • CareyCarey | June 18, 2012 4:24 PMReply

    Vanessa, THANKS FOR THE MEMORIES. GO IOWA! That could be me standing in the exact spot as Sugar, with that bridge in the background. I've played in the ballpark in which this film was shot. Yep, I've been across that bridge a thousand times. One night (many many years ago) I had to run across that bridge in about 3 minutes because I was late going home from a party. I didn't make it on time. My father was waiting for me at the kitchen table. Oh lord, it was 12:07 AM. He told me to be home by 12 oclock. GROUNDED!....NEW CHORE... SOLE DISHES, POTS AND PANS MAN FOR A MONTH :-(! To this day, my mother still lives on the other side of that bridge. And I have seen the movie Sugar.

  • Jug | June 18, 2012 6:22 PM

    LOL Aww shit man, that's what makes life interesting, Them "stories" (he says motioning to pick dat head up).

  • CareyCarey | June 18, 2012 6:19 PM

    Actually Jug, it developed my car stealing skills. *LOL* I am serious. Dumb I know, but I didn't want to be late no mo. But check this, if you look at the cuff on Sugar's right arm, there's a 5 story building waaay in the background. That's across the Mississippi River. Anyway, that building is the County Jail. Well... I have stories **dropping my head**

  • Jug | June 18, 2012 5:17 PM

    Thought that woulda developed your super powers Carey LOL SUGAR is such a good movie too!

  • Adam Scott Thompson | June 18, 2012 3:55 PMReply

    Quiet, poignant yet unpretentious. A hidden gem, a la Leonard Maltin. lol

  • MVF | June 18, 2012 3:50 PMReply

    A great film, that unfortunately slipped through the cracks. Great article!

  • MASTER BLASTER | June 18, 2012 3:39 PMReply

    sugar WAS on netflix, but apparently they've decided to move their streaming rights to amazon.

Follow Shadow and Act

Email Updates

Most "Liked"

  • Minority Independent Producers Summit ...
  • Fox Picks Up "International 'Bad Boys'-Style" ...
  • Film Based On Convicted African American ...
  • Watch The 'Half of a Yellow Sun' Title ...
  • New Original Feature-Length Doc - 'Kobe ...
  • If You Missed 'Jimmy Kimmel Live: Behind ...
  • First Poster For Latest Denzel Washington/Antoine ...
  • Interview: Marlon Wayans Talks Career, ...
  • Weekend B.O. April 18-20 (Depp Tanks) ...
  • 'My Last Day Without You' Starring Nicole ...