Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Weekend B.O. Sept. 12-14 (Will 'No Good Deed's' Success Help Make Taraji P. Henson an A-lister?) Weekend B.O. Sept. 12-14 (Will 'No Good Deed's' Success Help Make Taraji P. Henson an A-lister?) Producer Charles Belk and Actress Daniele Watts Apparently "Fit the Description" (Just Another Day in the Neighborhood) Producer Charles Belk and Actress Daniele Watts Apparently "Fit the Description" (Just Another Day in the Neighborhood) TIFF 2014 Review: 'Top Five' is Chris Rock's Funniest Movie in Years - If Not Ever TIFF 2014 Review: 'Top Five' is Chris Rock's Funniest Movie in Years - If Not Ever What’s the Big Secret That Got Those ‘No Good Deed’ Screenings Canceled? What’s the Big Secret That Got Those ‘No Good Deed’ Screenings Canceled? TV: New Corrections Officer for 'Orange, Another ABC Drama for Shonda Rhimes, SNL's 1st Black 'Weekend Update' Anchor TV: New Corrections Officer for 'Orange, Another ABC Drama for Shonda Rhimes, SNL's 1st Black 'Weekend Update' Anchor Watch First Episode of ABC's New Series 'Black-ish' Now Watch First Episode of ABC's New Series 'Black-ish' Now Antoine Fuqua Confirms He'll Be Partnering w/ Denzel Washington on a 'Magnificent Seven' Remake Antoine Fuqua Confirms He'll Be Partnering w/ Denzel Washington on a 'Magnificent Seven' Remake It's a Done Deal - Paramount Pictures Will Distribute Chris Rock's 'Top Five' Worldwide It's a Done Deal - Paramount Pictures Will Distribute Chris Rock's 'Top Five' Worldwide Interview: Taraji P. Henson On 'No Good Deed' and A Woman's Intuition Interview: Taraji P. Henson On 'No Good Deed' and A Woman's Intuition Crowdfund This: 'Newlyweeds' Star Trae Harris Is a 150-year-old African American Vampire in 'Octavia' Crowdfund This: 'Newlyweeds' Star Trae Harris Is a 150-year-old African American Vampire in 'Octavia' Black Kids from Ferguson Speak Out in 'Hey White People' Comedic Video Educating Whites on Racism Black Kids from Ferguson Speak Out in 'Hey White People' Comedic Video Educating Whites on Racism African Americans on TV Guide’s "TV’s Highest Paid Stars 2014" List. You Might Be Surprised African Americans on TV Guide’s "TV’s Highest Paid Stars 2014" List. You Might Be Surprised 'Terror at the Mall,' Documentary on Siege of Westgate Mall in Nairobi, Kenya, Coming to HBO (Trailer) 'Terror at the Mall,' Documentary on Siege of Westgate Mall in Nairobi, Kenya, Coming to HBO (Trailer) Woody Allen Says He Won’t Hire a Black Actor Unless the Role Calls for One... Whatever That Means Woody Allen Says He Won’t Hire a Black Actor Unless the Role Calls for One... Whatever That Means Watch First Trailer for Tyler Perry's New OWN TV Drama 'If Loving You Is Wrong' Watch First Trailer for Tyler Perry's New OWN TV Drama 'If Loving You Is Wrong' OWN Announces Cast for New Drama Series 'If Loving You is Wrong' From Tyler Perry OWN Announces Cast for New Drama Series 'If Loving You is Wrong' From Tyler Perry Aaron McGruder Finally Explains Why He Left 'The Boondocks' Aaron McGruder Finally Explains Why He Left 'The Boondocks' Lifetime Launches New Series Set In Elite World Of Hip-Hop Majorette Competitions (Watch Preview) Lifetime Launches New Series Set In Elite World Of Hip-Hop Majorette Competitions (Watch Preview) Netflix Explains Why It Doesn't Always Have That Film Or TV Show You Really Want To See (Video) Netflix Explains Why It Doesn't Always Have That Film Or TV Show You Really Want To See (Video) Tichina Arnold Says She Talked To Martin Lawrence About Doing A 'Martin' Movie... Tichina Arnold Says She Talked To Martin Lawrence About Doing A 'Martin' Movie...

good kid, m.A.A.d. lilies: The French New Wave's Influence on Hip-Hop - Part 2

Shadow and Act By Dylan Green | Shadow and Act June 16, 2014 at 11:23AM

It's safe to say that, at this point, the parallels, similarities, and differences between the French New Wave and the Hip-Hop New Wave have been made apparent.
3
Godard - Gambino

Please read Part 1 of this 2-part series HERE before continuing...


3: The History of the Hip Hop Music Video

Hip-hop has dipped its toes into many different facets of popular culture, but no area more prominently than music. The style of sampling old R&B and jazz songs with an emcee (lyricist) rhyming over the beat is part of the core of the hip-hop experience. It was fresh and invigorating in the early 1980s, with sounds as diverse as the good- natured party jams of Run DMC and the lyrically dense, socially conscious rhymes of Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five filling the airwaves. Hip-hop was introduced to popular culture at large by way of the music video in the early 1980s. Ever since Malcolm McLaren and the World Famous Supreme Team's video for their song Buffalo Gals was first released, and later when Run DMC's Rock Box popularized it, hip-hop has had a place in the world of the music video.

Author Jeff Chang talks at length about the evolution of the hip-hop music video in his book Total Chaos: The Art and Aesthetics of Hip-Hop. In the chapter entitled "Put Your Camera Where My Eyes Can See: Hip-Hop, Film, and Documentary," Chang mediates a discussion between various sources, from writer-director Rachel Ramist to hip hop journalist Eric Arnold. Ramist begins by making clear what exactly the hip-hop aesthetic on film means: “The hip hop aesthetic encompasses anything from a no-budget, gritty hip hop concept- driven piece to a multimillion dollar music video where everything’s shiny and steady- cammed, but it features some artist or some hip hop inspired fashion.” (308) This distinction draws a link to FNW films, in that the environments may vary, from the hard-bitten streets of France in 400 Blows to the bourgeois apartments of "Le Petit Soldat" and "Masculin Feminin."   What becomes clear is that both the FNW and HHNW utilize contemporary mood and fashion to help their themes shine through with visual style.

A recurring theme throughout Kendrick Lamar's song "Bitch, Don't Kill My Vibe," and one that the accompanying music video communicates very well, is the theme of isolation. In his refrain of “I can feel your energy from two planets away/ I got my drink, I got my music/ I would share it, but today I'm yelling/ Bitch don't kill my vibe,” Lamar is flippantly dismissing the entire world. The overwhelming nature of being surrounded by people on a near constant basis (especially given his newfound celebrity in the hip-hop world). "Bitch Don't Kill My Vibe" is one of a few songs on "good kid, m.A.A.d city" that isn't a part of the overall narrative, instead featuring Lamar directly communicating to this audience his desire to be treated like a normal person and have a little space. Lamar matter-of-factly states the isolation he craves, but the video shows us even more than words can say. Many scenes throughout the music video show Lamar, clad in an all-white suit, isolated from those around him. In the beginning, there are close-ups of Lamar standing alone in a section of church pews separated from other churchgoers and a grand sweeping mid-long shot of Lamar standing out in an open field, a singular black/white dot in a sea of green and light brown.

Moments of isolation and peace like this are juxtaposed with close-up scenes of Lamar partying in the cramped backseat of a limousine with four or five other people, the loudest and most close-quarters space shown in the video. The tone of the video, much like the song itself, is defiant yet relaxed, and the juxtaposition of isolation from to saturation of people for Lamar reflects this. Much like the bathroom scene in "Masculin Feminin" that also showed a sense of isolation in Paul's playful yet futile attempts to flirt with Madeline by literally forcing Paul out of the shot entirely, Lamar shows his want for isolation and reflects the tone of the entire song through stylistic visual choices, similar to how Godard did.


4: Long Takes and 30-Degree Rule: Jean Luc-Godard and Donald Glover

One aspect of the many that differentiated the French New Wave filmmakers from Hollywood filmmakers of the time, was the freedom from traditional film constraints practiced by their American counterparts in Hollywood. Because of the United States’ amassed influence over the international movie scene, American cinematic techniques, such as the 30 Degree Rule, a rule that demands the camera move at least 30 degrees between shots in order to seamlessly keep the audience immersed in the story and prevent jump cuts, among others, became commonplace among filmmakers worldwide. French New Wave filmmakers, particularly Godard, directly challenged this approach to film and would pay no mind to the 30 Degree Rule, and would often makes cuts between shots that are similarly angled. These similarly angled shots serve to abruptly draw attention to the passage of time in a scene and the constructed nature of film itself, as opposed to a more seamless shot transition that the 30 Degree Rule would foster. Given the film critic background of French New Wave filmmakers including Godard and Truffaut, both of whom were film critics and avid cinephiles before even picking up a camera, this meticulous counterattack comes across as very deliberate.

Godard's films defy traditional filmmaking practices with their liberal use of jump cuts to re-orient perspective and technical taste, utilizing shorter angle changes in his cuts that are the choppy opposite to the smoother cuts of a Hollywood production. "Masculin Feminin" is an example from 1966 that follows the exploits of Paul (Jean-Pierre Léaud), a romantic and literary wanna-be who sets his idealistic mind on mini-celebrity Madeline (Chantal Goya) and begins a quasi-four way relationship with her two roommates, Catherine (Catherine-Isabelle Duport) and Elisabeth (Marlène Jobert). I'll be examining a scene detailing one of the first interactions between Paul and Madeline to show how Godard uses jump cuts. A mid-shot of Paul opens the scene. He is standing inconspicuously underneath a row of coat hangers with one brown coat hanging lifeless next to him; he runs his fingers through his short brown hair before moving his fingers nervously back and forth against themselves. To his left, the bathroom stall door opens and Madeline steps outside. After he takes a sip or two from his glass of water and returns to his spot next to the brown coat, the film cuts to a close shot of Madeline’s face while standing next to the sink. Madeline and Paul continue to discuss the nature of lying and relationships.

Throughout the course of the scene, Godard's invasive jump cuts place the audience in a voyeuristic position, which is remarkable especially given that there are only two cuts in the entire scene altogether. As Madeline approaches the mirror, the shot immediately cuts to the close-up mentioned earlier; the camera repositions itself from one diagonal side of her body to the other as Paul’s non-diegetic sound comes from the other side of the bathroom. As opposed to an American counterpart at the time, Godard appears to be utilizing the placement of the shot to say something, a clever implementation of another cinematic rule, Show, Don’t Tell; with the placement of this shot, Godard is communicating the emotional distance between Madeline and Paul, who are just beginning their courtship, by completely eliminating the physical presence of Paul and isolating Madeline in the center of the shot while Paul asks her questions off-screen, resulting in an awkward detached dissonance felt by the audience and Paul as his attempts to get truthful answers from Madeline are deflected. This dissonance wouldn't have been communicated well enough if not for the awkward and attention-grabbing nature of the jump cuts Godard uses throughout.

A different variation on breaking the 30 degree rule can be seen in another of Godard's films. Set during the Algerian War for Independence, "Le Petit Soldat" ("The Little Soldier") is a melancholy tale of life, love, and loyalty in 1960s France. Filmed in 1960 but initially banned in its native France for its infamous torture scene, Soldat didn’t see release until 1963, being released as his fourth movie even though it was his second feature. The film is also notable for featuring the first appearance of Godard’s l actress-turned wife Anna Karina. There is one scene in particular throughout the course of "Le Petit Soldat" that clearly emphasizes the break in the 30 degree rule: a scene where protagonist Bruno (Michel Subor) asks questions of Veronica (Karina) while taking photographs of her. The camerawork in this scene (and this film in general) is more creative with how it deals with space than the similar scene in “Masculin Feminin.” As opposed to only a handful of cuts punctuated with violations of the American-established 30 Degree Rule, Veronica and Bruno’s interactions move faster and between many more shots. Almost every time Bruno take a photograph of Veronica, the film cuts to a different angle, sometimes breaking the 30 Degree Rule, sometimes not; instead of breaking the rule often, Godard simply films many long shots, panning the camera to focus on whichever character is talking at the time, further bringing attention to the fact that this is a French New Wave film before conforming to a variation of the standard shot-reverse-shot formula. Godard is still willing to hold a long shot, especially in the opening shot where Veronica shows Bruno around her apartment. While Bruno’s criticism of actors in “Le Petit Soldat” features one of the longest takes in the scene (26 seconds), that isn’t even the most intriguing aspect of the sequence; as he mentions that “You tell them to laugh...they laugh,” he stares and smiles right at the camera lens. This nodding self-reflexivity served to continually remind the audience that they were indeed watching a film, one that is studying (and subverting) the history of the medium as much as its audience was studying it. Godard’s sweeping camera movements, long takes, and moments like Bruno smiling at the camera echoed the revolutionary sentiment of films of the French New Wave.

Clapping For The Wrong Reasons:

A figure within the world of hip-hop film who utilizes long takes of this variety is Donald Glover. Alias Childish Gambino, Glover is an artist who takes advantage of every form of media he possibly can, from music to television to film. Starting his career off with stand-up comedy group Derrick Comedy on YouTube, he branched out from there and began writing for popular NBC sitcom “30 Rock,” where he had time to further build his comedic muscle. Around the time he left his position at “30 Rock,” Glover independently released his first album as Childish Gambino, entitled “Sick Boi,” and branched out to an acting role on fellow NBC sitcom “Community.” As he began to release more albums and mix tapes (Culdesac, Camp, Royalty), he decided it was high time that he begun to make his own independent projects in film and television as well; the first of these projects is a 24-minute short film that he wrote, co-executive produced, and starred in called Clapping For The Wrong Reasons.

Even with the French New Wave influence on the project, Clapping still feels very much like a new age music video in the same vein as French New Wave films because of the jump cuts and camera pans constantly reminding us that this is a work of (mostly) fiction. In this case, it is far removed from the categories of hip-hop film that Jesse Stewart brought up in his article "Real to Reel," those being the pseudo-biographical hip-hop film like "Wild Style"   (Stewart 50) ,the “hood” film along the lines of "Boyz n the Hood" or "Menace II Society" (52), and the historical recounting of the hip-hop documentary (53-55). Glover has created a film here that features figures in contemporary hip-hop like Chance The Rapper and Trinidad James, but isn't so much about hip-hop itself as it is about a day in the life of a particular artist. The fact that it feels so naturalistic yet so self aware, like films of the French New Wave, really speaks to Glover’s eye for the existential in a screenplay and he and director Hiro Murai's meticulous shot composition in a similar way to Godard's.

I'll be looking at two scenes in particular here, namely an opening scene in the short film where Glover answers a call from a collection agency and a push-up contest between Glover and Chance The Rapper. As Glover is awakened from a night’s rest by a mysterious girl, he wakes up, shirtless, and throws a shirt on before heading outside. A medium wide shot reveals Donald walking down a hallway, rubbing his eyes and the camera pans toward the house phone that he’s reaching for. He answers, “Hello?” The person on the other end asks “Hello, who’s this?” “You called me.” Donald says after a pause. After mentioning the fact that she’s with a collection agency of some kind, Donald passively says “I know who you’re looking for. He’s not here.” After a beat, the collector asks when he’ll return, to which Donald asks her what month it is; “June, I believe,” she replies. “Well then he’s probably in the northern hemisphere somewhere,” he says in the same flat tone before hanging up the phone and walking out of frame.

This use of a long take would have been looked down upon during the pre-French New Wave days of cinema. By conventional Hollywood standards, a scene like this would either be cut from different angles or simply not exist at all, and certainly wouldn’t feature a camera pan of any kind, so as to keep up the illusion and not bring attention to the fact that an audience is, indeed, watching a film; by letting the shot linger in real time for 48 seconds with a pan and not featuring any additional camera angles, auteur theory (the theory of directorial fingerprints believed/practiced by French New Wave filmmakers) would suggest that Murai and Glover are deliberately trying to communicate something to the audience (maybe the fact that Donald lives a quiet, mellow life from the lack of activity in the foyer or even outside) and make an artistic statement through the panning breaking of the coveted 30 degree rule. This stands in contrast to the photography scene in Godard’s "Le Petit Soldat" between Veronica and Bruno with its mix of fast-cutting, different angles, and occasional long shots and harken more to the bathroom scene from Godard’s "Masculin Feminin" which had a total of three to four different jump cuts and a handful of longer shots.

A scene of Glover and Chance The Rapper doing push-ups in the backyard continues the French New Wave technique seen throughout “Clapping.” While any traditional director may have rapidly intercut shots of Glover and Chance doing push-ups to increase tension and suspense, the plainness of the set-up and the distance (long shot) betrays the overall smallness of the competition. This shot is similar for the reasons listed in the opening scene; there is only one jump cut in the entire scene and no angle change on the camera, voiding the 30 Degree Rule and disrupting the flow of the cinematic universe...not really. Being a music video director, the shot choices that Murai makes throughout Clapping For The Wrong Reasons all come off as unorthodox, because they reflect editing techniques of Godard and Truffaut more than anyone else.


5: Culture Shock?: Content Similarities in "Wolf" and "Jules et Jim"

Beyond many of the technical and structural similarities I've been covering over the course of this journey, there are of course similarities purely in content, too. Love is an issue that has had youth culture in a bind for decades, especially in relation to that age-old caveat, the love triangle. The love triangle may have just re-emerged as a universally accepted plot dynamic in contemporary culture (needless to say of just film and music), but filmmakers like Francois Truffaut have relished the opportunity for romantic tension for quite some time. Truffaut's film Jules et Jim (Jules and Jim), a 1962 love story told before, during, and after World War II in Western Europe serves as a great companion piece to portions of hip-hop artist Tyler Okonma, aka Tyler, The Creator's album “Wolf,” itself partially occupied with the boiling over of a fledging love triangle. I'll be focusing on Okonma's third album “Wolf” in particular here, where the aforementioned love triangle comes from. The characters of Wolf and Samuel are largely symbolic, representing the more relaxed acceptive side and the aggressive yet repressed side of Tyler, respectively.

Both works revolve around the start and eventual decay of a three-way relationship, though on slightly different terms. Truffaut's film chronicles the story of two male friends in pre-war France: shy Austrian writer Jules (Oskar Werner) and more outward and sociable Jim (Henri Serre), two purveyors of the then-contemporary Bohemian lifestyle. The nature of their friendship is tested when both men meet the enchanting Catherine (Jeanne Moreau), who both men eventually become enamored of and begin to compete for her affections, with Catherine hopping back and forth between the men. As already stated, this is yet another Truffaut story about a young man being confronted with a life-questioning existential situation, though this time having to do with love, one of his flourishes of auteurism. Conversely, Okonma's album tells the story of two boys, a mild-mannered boy named Samuel and a seemingly more aggressive guy named Wolf, who are at odds over a girl named Salem, all over the course of one summer at Camp Flog Gnaw. Similarly to Truffaut's characters in Jules et Jim, Okonma's characters also take stock of their lives and become confused amidst a cloud of love, his While the overall content and structure of Okonma's project (which we'll come back to later) relegates the love triangle business to the b-story, Truffaut decides to make Jules and Jim's friendship and their identical feelings for Catherine the main narrative thrust of Jules et Jim. Truffaut is much more pre-occupied with the concept of love, and how it can foster, endanger, and even completely destroy friendships.

The nature of Jules and Jim's relationship with each other is outlined neatly in the opening sequence of the film. 'Jules et Jim' speeds through the origin of the two men's friendship, with narration from Michel Subor, before depicting a scene where both men become entranced by a marble bust of a woman with a serene smile across her face. The camera pans back and forth, examining the bust in all of its marble detail as Subor talks over Jules and Jim's sudden fascination with its face. “Had they ever seen such a smile before? Never,” the narrator elaborated. “And if they ever met it? They'd follow it.” This beginning scene offers the audience insight into the single mind that these two men seem to share, confirming for us that their two sets of eyes might as well be working as one. Jules and Jim are set up as two men who are so alike in their common interests and tastes that their subjective view melds into one vision, a vision that will be given an ambulatory figure once Catherine enters the picture a little later on.

Okonma structures his opening differently than Truffaut decided to, but the narrative similarity in is undeniable. On the opening track entitled 'Wolf,' an eerie melody gives way to a deep-voiced camp counselor who compliments Sam's musicianship (“Music sounds good, man. You've been practicing.”), confirming that the character is the one who played the refrain at the beginning, before introducing Sam to the new kid at Camp Flog Gnaw, Wolf. Sam is immediately dismissive of Wolf and tells him “You stay the fuck out of our way and we'll stay out of yours, capisce?” As opposed to the two like-minded friends passive aggressively competing for the hand of a woman in 'Jules and Jim,' Samuel and Wolf are immediately set up as polar opposites from the jump. The overall mood of the album, which follows both of the boys as they talk about the respective problems they have to deal with back home (most of which are real-world problems Okonma is dealing with himself), falters between saccharine and despondent through various moments of recollection.

The introduction we receive to Catherine in Jules and Jim is much lighter and romanticized than Okonma's introduction to Salem, but both stories of love follow a similar pattern. After having seen the bust with the angelic face and smile, both Jules and Jim both attend a lunch, set up by the promiscuous Jim, with “A girl from Berlin, one from Holland, and a French girl.” It's at this lunch that the two friends meet Catherine, who bears a striking resemblance to the perfection of the bust that they saw earlier. As the group has lunch together, Jules and Jim have a silent battle with Catherine's feet under the table. Jim touches Catherine's feet, but she gently moves them out of the way. Sitting next to Jules, a black outline covers the screen except for a box showing Catherine and Jules' heads as the narrator tells the audience that “a shy, happy smile played on Jules' lips,” him beating Jim at his own game and seeing Catherine for a little over a month after their lunch. While Truffaut makes the relationship between the three lovers in Jules and Jim the main narrative thrust, Okonma relegates it more to the background, but even though his personal life serves as the main inspiration for the spat between Samuel and Wolf, he manages to relate it all back to the love story at the core of the story of 'Wolf.' The gruff Samuel tells Wolf of how he first met Salem, the girl that both boys eventually fall for, on the song 'Awkward.' He spends the length of the song elegantly describing how awkward their first encounter was with lines like “I play in your hair as you rub on my ears. Then we awkwardly stare until our lips locked, then we awkwardly stared because our lips locked...Man, this feels like a dream because our lips locked, you officially put my feelings inside a Ziplock bag.” Samuel's tough-boy exterior fades for a while in the middle of his reminiscing about how he wants Salem to “treat my palms like a bowling ball and grip and keep holding on, girl,” revealing that even though their relationship may have had an awkward start, he loves the way that she makes him feel and he wants to continue being around her. As the relationship between the three continues to develop, from foot races across miniature bridges to spontaneous dives into the river fully clothed, the audience is offered a view of a sort of polyamorous relationship, with all three members taking a liking to each other and getting into all kinds of silly adventures. This is in direct contrast to the darker tone of Sam/Wolf/Salem's relationship troubles in 'Wolf.' Sam is a volatile kid at summer camp whose few fleeting moments of happiness come from his girlfriend, Salem. When she runs off with the new kid Wolf, he goes on a rampage and eventually winds up killing Wolf. While taking place in different times and indeed in different parts of the world, the respective stories of Jules et Jim and “Wolf” both approach romance in an unconventional way. Given the FNW's pretense toward this kind of subject matter that I've showcased already (Masculin Feminin, Le Petit Soldat), that shouldn't come as a surprise.

Okonma and Truffaut attack the concept of the love triangle from different tonal angles and seem to have different things to say about young love, at first. The dark, brooding angst felt through the story of 'Wolf' couldn't be any different from the first act of 'Jules and Jim,' with the trio frolicking the streets of Paris together and having crazy adventures. But as both stories come to their respective ends, both stories end in the unexpected death of one part of the respective trio. 'Jules and Jim' ends with a distraught Catherine, now having left Jules for Jim while still maintaining the group dynamic they had before, asking Jim to take a car ride with her, saying that she has something important to tell him. She then drives the car off of a cliff into the water, killing both herself and Jim. The climax of 'Wolf' finds Sam on the warpath after finding out about Wolf and Salem's frolicking by the lake. Sam kicks down Wolf's cabin door and guns him down in cold blood. Both ending are unexpectedly violent, but beyond that superficial similarity, they both ask one important question: what next? Jules is left to deal with the ashes of his deceased friends, while we never do figure out what happens between Samuel and Salem. Do Samuel and Salem patch things up? Does Samuel go to jail? Does Jules end up keeping the ashes of his deceased friends over his fireplace or release them over another lake? Both endings take both works to their illogical extremes and leave us with more questions than answers, which may be the point that both Truffaut and Okonma might be trying to make. With a construct as unpredictable as a love triangle, anything could happen. We all make our own ending. Both Jules et Jim and “Wolf” prove that three-way romance knows no national border and that Truffaut and Okonma both helm their respective works with the hand of an auteur.

Epilogue: Revolutionary Context

It's safe to say that at this point, the parallels, similarities, and differences between the French New Wave and the Hip-Hop New Wave have been made apparent. But the only remaining question to ask is one that pervades the whole of both movements and one that I've merely scratched the surface of prior: What was the catalyst for both of these respective movements? What were the respective contexts that kickstarted these revolutionary movements? What were the domestic and international models and situations that birthed them?

I've mentioned Hollywood films and the Hollywood aesthetic many times over the course of this analysis, but only because the Hollywood model of the 30s and 40s, from subject matter to shooting style, was so utterly dominant of the international cinematic stage. Scholar Cecile Sorin notes as such in his article The art of borrowing: French popular cinema before the New Wave, referencing the saturation of Hollywood films in the French film market at the end of World War II and in the wake of the Blum-Byrnes agreement of 1946, an agreement that erased much of France's debt to America after World War I (Sorin 53). Even with the extra American influence, French filmmakers and film companies still managed to circumvent these foreign imports by creating versions of their own. By borrowing certain genres and mechanics that were popular in America at the time, particularly in the Western and the police thriller/gangster film, French filmmakers found a way to “acquire Hollywood know-how, but mock it in a political context framed by the Blum-Byrnes agreement and American anti-communism...It became more than simply a political attitude; it became a way of thought.” (Sorin 54) This new trend of borrowing from American cinema was very much debated at the time, with many holding said films and their imitators under scrutiny simply because of the fact that they came from the US. Others took the time to recognize talent in American filmmakers and judge their work based solely on style. The latter camp was staffed by Andre Bazin and Alexandre Astruc, major critical players in what would become the magazine Cahier du Cinema and the French New Wave.

This borrowing extended into the FNW, of course. Sorin notes that filmmakers of the FNW had actually learned a lesson from contemporary popular French cinema, that being “this ability to absorb American cinema in the pursuit of its own identity.” (62) As former critics themselves, Truffaut and especially Godard, among their other peers in the movement, were able to step back and examine exactly what about American films worked, and what wasn't worth preserving in their own translation, in order to establish themselves as the independent renegades that they would eventually become. As much as the FNW may borrow and mock American cinema, it wouldn't exist without the influence and ideas that American imported films brought their way

The beginnings of hip-hop on American shores also stem from growth following a landmark legislature. The America of the 1970s existed in the aftermath of the Civil Rights Movement and the passing of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, rectifying the forced second-class citizenship of African-Americans. According to scholar Nelson George, whose first chapter of the book “Hip-Hop America” details some of the struggles of 1970s America, especially African Americans. The “new black middle class,” as George calls it, was facing a new challenge in post-Civil Rights Act America: integrating and being accepted into a still predominantly white-run society (George 2). This also led to record companies, still living off of the money generated by countercultural artists like Jimi Hendrix, The Doors, etc, creating “black music” divisions that would sniff out talent off the beaten path like the aforementioned. George draws the path that starts with the rise and fall of popularity regarding disco music in the 1970s, a black-centric genre of music at the time. He estimates that thanks to the combination of crossover appeal, the inescapability and profitability of disco, and the newly corporate-owned American record business led to them snatching up whatever new fads they could find, disco included: “The group mindset that grew out of this concentration of record companies, and the tendency of its executives to make professional judgments while doing blow in restroom stalls, is one reason the most important musical-cultural phenomenon of the last twenty years took so long to go mainstream.” (George 9)

Discotheques, early variations on nightclubs, was where you'd find the hottest recorded music on the street at the time. Three artists/DJs/emcees who would play discotheques/club often were known as Afrika Bambatta, Kool Herc, and Grandmaster Flash, all of whom can be credited with the rise in popularity of hip-hop over the course of the 1980s (George 17-18). The first breakout single in hip-hop history of course belongs to The Sugarhill Gang, whose song “Rapper's Delight” kicked off the mainstream visibility of the medium that Bambatta, Herc, and Flash would help to refine.

In the construction of “beats,” the colloquial slang for the instrumentation of a hip-hop track, more often then not the art of sampling is involved, especially in the early days of the medium. For example, the beat behind “Rapper's Delight” is the breakdown of the song “Good Times” by disco-funk-rock act Chic. But sampling tends to go deeper than that. Many producers, from Bambatta and the like, up to contemporary producers/DJs such as Madlib or The RZA, will pull or borrow samples from various songs in order to craft something new out of them. Producers will pull a drum loop from one song, some guitar or synths from another song, etc until they've created a wall of sound constructed from other songs. While not what every producer today might use, this style of hip-hop production was the standard in the beginning stages of the genre and continues to be a popular avenue for production to this day. Public Enemy, a group formed in 1982 consisting of emcee Chuck D and hype man Flavor Flav, utilized this sampling techniques with their production team The Bomb Squad and mixed it with a socio-political edge that brought them much mainstream success on their third album, "Fear of a Black Planet."

At their very cores, both hip-hop, contemporary or old-school, and films of the French New Wave are bound together in this respect. They both not only pull from older source material in order to establish their own individual identity, but they both did so in a revolutionary fashion unlike any other that had been seen before in either of their respective mediums. My hope is that throughout the course of this paper, I've proved that point.


Bibliography

Andrews, David. No Start, No End: Auteurism and the auteur theory. Film International 10 .6, 2012

Bluher, Dominique. Hip Hop Cinema in France. Camera Obscura 16.46, 2001

Bernez, Nicole. The Ultimate Doomed Victims of the Romantic Dream. Framework: The Journal of Cinema Chang, Jeff. Total Chaos: The Art and Aesthetics of Hip Hop. 1st. 1. New York: Basic Civitas, 2007.

Douchet, Jean. French New Wave. 1st ed. 1. Archer Fields, Inc, 1999

George, Nelson. “Post-Soul.” Hip Hop America. 1st ed. New York: Penguin Books, 1998

Neupert, Richard. History Of The French New Wave. 2nd . 1. Madison: University of Wisconsin, 2007

Rose, Tricia. Black Noise: Rap Music and Black Culture in Contemporary America. 1St ed. 1. Wesleyan Stewart, Jesse. Real to Reel: Filmic Constructions of Hip Hop Culture and Hip Hop Identities 1.1, 2009

Sorin, Cecile. The art of borrowing: French popular cinema before the New Wave. 4.1. Studies in French Truffaut, Francois. A Certain Tendency of the French Cinema. Cahier du Cinéma 1 Jan. 1954


Filmography

The 400 Blows. Dir. Francois Truffaut. Cocinor. 1959. Film.

Boyz n the Hood. Dir. John Singleton. 1991. DVD

Clapping For The Wrong Reasons. Dir. Hiro Murai. 2013. YouTube

Juice. Dir. Ernest R. Dickerson. 1992. DVD

Jules et Jim. Dir. Francois Truffaut. Janus Films. 1962. DVD

Masculin Feminin. Dir. Jean-Luc Godard. 1966. VHS

Menace II Society. The Hughes Brothers. 1993. DVD

Le Petit Soldat. Dir. Jean-Luc Godard. 1963. DVD


Discography

Chance The Rapper, Acid Rap (Independent, 2013)

Childish Gambino, Because The Internet (Glassnote, 2013)

Kendrick Lamar, good kid, m.A.A.d. city (Interscope, 2012)

Tyler The Creator, WOLF (Sony Music Entertainment, 2013)

This article is related to: Things That Make You Go Hmm...


Shadow & ActNewsletter