Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
The Gift That Keeps on Giving - Leaked Sony Email Challenges Denzel Washington's Overseas Box Office Appeal The Gift That Keeps on Giving - Leaked Sony Email Challenges Denzel Washington's Overseas Box Office Appeal Backlash Against New VH1 Series 'Sorority Sisters' Backlash Against New VH1 Series 'Sorority Sisters' Tessa Thompson Books Female Lead Role in Ryan Coogler's 'Creed' Opposite Michael B. Jordan Tessa Thompson Books Female Lead Role in Ryan Coogler's 'Creed' Opposite Michael B. Jordan Why Aren’t We Talking About the Sexual Assault in 'Beyond the Lights'? Why Aren’t We Talking About the Sexual Assault in 'Beyond the Lights'? Page to Screen Possibilities for Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie's 'Americanah' (Lupita Nyong'o, David Oyelowo Starring) Page to Screen Possibilities for Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie's 'Americanah' (Lupita Nyong'o, David Oyelowo Starring) David Oyelowo Joins Lupita Nyong’o in 'Americanah' Film Adaptation David Oyelowo Joins Lupita Nyong’o in 'Americanah' Film Adaptation Leaked Sony Emails Reveal Interest in Destiny's Child Biopic + Immersive Kanye West Feature Film Experience Leaked Sony Emails Reveal Interest in Destiny's Child Biopic + Immersive Kanye West Feature Film Experience Weekend B.O. Dec. 12-14 (So How’s That Boycott Working for Ya?) Weekend B.O. Dec. 12-14 (So How’s That Boycott Working for Ya?) FX Orders Comedy Pilot on Atlanta Hip-Hop Scene From & Starring Donald Glover FX Orders Comedy Pilot on Atlanta Hip-Hop Scene From & Starring Donald Glover Chadwick Boseman, David Oyelowo, Gugu Mbatha-Raw, Rosario Dawson, Others Share Kisses in NY Times Shorts Chadwick Boseman, David Oyelowo, Gugu Mbatha-Raw, Rosario Dawson, Others Share Kisses in NY Times Shorts What Sony Pictures Chief Amy Pascal Should Do if She Sincerely Wants to Make Amends What Sony Pictures Chief Amy Pascal Should Do if She Sincerely Wants to Make Amends Ava DuVernay Earns Her Way Into the History Books - First Black Woman Director to Be Nominated for a Golden Globe Award Ava DuVernay Earns Her Way Into the History Books - First Black Woman Director to Be Nominated for a Golden Globe Award Woody Allen Says He Won’t Hire a Black Actor Unless the Role Calls for One... Whatever That Means Woody Allen Says He Won’t Hire a Black Actor Unless the Role Calls for One... Whatever That Means Will You Join The Boycott 'Exodus' Movement? (Or You Don't Care) Will You Join The Boycott 'Exodus' Movement? (Or You Don't Care) My MoviePass Experience - What Works & What Could Be Improved (The Movie Theater Subscription Service) My MoviePass Experience - What Works & What Could Be Improved (The Movie Theater Subscription Service) Co-Screenwriter of 'Noah' Explains Why There Are No Black People Or POC In The Film Co-Screenwriter of 'Noah' Explains Why There Are No Black People Or POC In The Film Lifetime Launches New Series Set In Elite World Of Hip-Hop Majorette Competitions (Watch Preview) Lifetime Launches New Series Set In Elite World Of Hip-Hop Majorette Competitions (Watch Preview) Netflix Explains Why It Doesn't Always Have That Film Or TV Show You Really Want To See (Video) Netflix Explains Why It Doesn't Always Have That Film Or TV Show You Really Want To See (Video) Will Smith Explains Why Willow Smith Dropped Out Of 'Annie' Remake Will Smith Explains Why Willow Smith Dropped Out Of 'Annie' Remake Tichina Arnold Says She Talked To Martin Lawrence About Doing A 'Martin' Movie... Tichina Arnold Says She Talked To Martin Lawrence About Doing A 'Martin' Movie...

London Critics Lambaste Thandie Newton's West End Debut In "Death And The Maiden" + 1st Look Images

Photo of Tambay A. Obenson By Tambay A. Obenson | Shadow and Act October 25, 2011 at 6:35AM

Ariel Dorfman's Death and the Maiden opened last night on London's West End (equivalent of NYC's Broadway) Harold Pinter Theatre, with Thandie Newton starring in the play's revival; and while most critics gave good enough marks to the overall production (3 out of 5 stars is about the average rating), they weren't as kind to the actress' performance, which is unfortunate.
10

Ariel Dorfman's Death and the Maiden opened last night on London's West End (equivalent of NYC's Broadway) Harold Pinter Theatre, with Thandie Newton starring in the play's revival; and while most critics gave good enough marks to the overall production (3 out of 5 stars is about the average rating), they weren't as kind to the actress' performance, which is unfortunate.

My introduction to the play came in the form of the Roman Polanski film which starred Sigourney Weaver and Ben Kingsley. A superb drama/thriller I thought, thanks to strong performances from the cast, Polanski's direction, lush cinematography, all complimented by the haunting Schubert soundtrack.

Thandie Newton plays the role Sigourney Weaver played in the film.

And what are the Brit critics saying about her performance after the play's revival opening last night?

From the Telegraph:

Unfortunately the Hollywood actress Thandie Newton almost entirely misses the flayed intensity, horror and exhilaration that Juliet Stevenson brought to central character 20 years ago. Indeed this strikes me as a classic case of the dangers of star casting. Miss Newton simply doesn’t have the theatrical chops for so demanding a role and her tight, strained voice, improbably immaculate hair-do and inability to really let rip and lay herself bare emotionally severely diminishes the play’s impact. There are decent performances from Tom Goodman-Hill as her anxious husband and Anthony Calf as the now tormented torturer who once played Schubert to his terrified victims. But director Jeremy Herrin cannot disguise the fatal weak link at the heart of his production.

Um... ouch?!? Certainly not what the show's lead actress thought she'd wake up to this morning.

And it doesn't get any better; from The Arts Desk:

This time, all eyes are on Thandie Newton - who was big in Crash, Run, Fatboy, Run and Mission Impossible 2 - and here makes her West End debut. Certainly, the casting of a mixed-race actor in a contemporary classic is an excellent idea, and has gained some added relevance from the recent BBC documentaries about the subject. But is she right for the part? The short answer is no. Newton’s voice is chirpy and cheery, and her performance lacks the pain of experience and the depth of, well, character. Her sobs are as superficial as shrugs; her passion is as bloodless as thin broth. When she talks dirty, it sounds like a schoolgirl taking a dare. There’s really no weight at all behind this acting.

Damn! And from London's Evening Standard:

This revival also marks the West End debut of Thandie Newton. She plays the vengeful Paulina Salas, who believes that the man her lawyer husband Gerardo has brought into her home is her former torturer. It's a performance of elegance but insufficient weight. Newton is feline and coolly glamorous. However, she is much sleeker than the role demands, and vocally she has limitations. Her delivery doesn't have enough variety to convey Paulina's range of emotions as she exacts violent revenge for past abuses.

Not as rough as the first 2, but still pretty much saying the same thing: in short, she's all-too wrong for the part.

Anyone care to challenge? Enter the Guardian with this:

Jeremy Herrin's production nevertheless generates considerable tension and marks the West End debut of film star Thandie Newton as Paulina. Even if her voice could do with more modulations of tone, she performs with great assurance, shifting from vengeful fury to sudden vulnerability with total plausibility

Ok, still not a ringing endorsement, but certainly kinder than the others.

It's worth keeping in mind that this was the show's opening night; adjustments could be made (especially after what seems like a near-consensus (negative) on Thandie's performance); and reactions could be different after several more runs of the show; or nothing could change, reactions stay the same, and Thandie wears this one like the Scarlet Letter on her stage resume.

Obviously, I haven't seen the show (though I wonder if MsWOO plans to, since she lives in London - ahem), so I can't comment on her performance in it; but I generally like Thandie Newton as an actress. My only reference to the play, as already noted, was the Polanski movie, and Sigourney Weaver's performance in it, which, as I said earlier, was strong. She was quite raw in it, as I recall; I believed her. But I'd like to think Thandie could "let go," with a similar kind of reckless abandon, and match her intensity on stage, even though I'd say Weaver's overall physicality trumps Newton's.

Ah well... *shrug*

Might a revival run on Broadway be forthcoming? Who knows. If it does well in the UK, it might travel, as others have done recently. Also, it hasn't been performed on Broadway since 1992, so a revival might be in someone's sights (likely minus Thandie though).

Anyway, good luck to her for the rest of the show's run. It's a challenging role to play.

This article is related to: Theater


Shadow & ActNewsletter