The Academy Got It Wrong: Black Oscar Winners and the Roles They Should Have Won For

Features
by Jai Tiggett
February 28, 2014 10:30 AM
20 Comments
  • |

It's an inevitable debate during awards season - who won, who really should have won, and for which role. When it comes to black actors in particular, there's a longstanding belief that the Academy routinely gets it wrong, snubbing certain Oscar-worthy performances and choosing instead to hand out the trophy for roles that don't quite cut it.

In anticipation of the Academy Award ceremony this weekend, here's a look back at the black actors who've taken home the Oscar, and which other roles they should have won for, if any.

 

Best Actor

Sidney Poitier           

Won for: Homer Smith, Lilies of the Field (1963)                       

Should have won for: Virgil Tibbs, In the Heat of the Night (1967). Poitier's role as detective Virgil Tibbs is one of his most memorable, but Poitier was possibly passed over in light of his recent win. In The Heat of the Night was also nominated in seven other categories, winning five, including Best Picture.



Denzel Washington

Won for: Alonzo Harris, Training Day (2001)

Should have won for: Malcolm X, Malcolm X (1992). Maybe the most obvious entry on this list, as the slain civil rights activist is still considered one of Washington's most iconic roles. X director Spike Lee is remembered for his criticism of the Academy for failing to recognize both Washington and the film, saying, "I'm not the only one who thinks Denzel was robbed on that one."



Jamie Foxx

Won for: Ray Charles, Ray (2004)

This one was on the money as far as Foxx's performances go. Until Ray in 2004, Foxx's most acclaimed roles had been supporting turns as Drew "Bundini" Brown in Ali (2001) and Willie Beamen in Oliver Stone's Any Given Sunday (1999). But in the "got it wrong" category, some felt the Best Actor Oscar should have gone to Don Cheadle, who starred in Hotel Rwanda that year.


You might also like:
Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

20 Comments

  • Albie | March 4, 2014 1:00 PMReply

    Although I agree with the Oscar mistake, I disagree with the comments about Cuba Gooding Jr. I think he is a very talented actor. His dramatic roles are superb but they seem to be overshadowed by his stereotypical comedic roles. His work in "MEN OF HONOR" is worthy of recognition. With performances in films like RADIO, THE TUSKEGEE AIRMEN, and AMERICAN GANGSTER his star shines. It's just too bad he has to many performances in films like CHILL FACTOR, SNOW DOGS, and THE FIGHTING TEMPTATIONS that diminish his film legacy.

  • Movie critic | March 2, 2014 7:34 PMReply

    Morgan Freeman as the pimp Fast Black in "Street Smart", Don Cheadle as Mouse in "Devil In a Blue Dress" (Jeffrey Wright in Basquiat - it is a travesty that none of these timeless, extraordinary performances were even nominated.

  • MOVIE WATCHER | March 29, 2014 9:03 PM

    Morgan Freeman received an Oscar nomination for Street Smart.

  • Troy Johnson | March 2, 2014 6:40 PMReply

    As far as I'm concerned Idris Elba not being nominated for best Actor and "Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom" http://aalbc.it/mandelamovie deserved to at least be nominated and in my book deserved to win.

  • Moviecritic | March 2, 2014 7:36 PM

    Agreed. And Naomie a harris KILLED as Winnie Mandela.

  • deecreative | March 1, 2014 11:11 AMReply

    as big a crime it is that Malcolm X didn't win any awards 'The Color Purple' not winning ANY awards is probably THE Oscar crime of the 20th century. Everything about that movie and dag gone near all the performances were Oscar worthy and I agree with Denzel's performance in 'A Soldier's Story'. Shoooot Mo' Betta Blues was an Oscar worthy performance.

  • Ignorance Lives | March 4, 2014 4:16 PM

    @ BRUTAL, Gerard, why did you change your name?

  • brutal honesty | March 1, 2014 4:30 PM

    color purple is an important black film directed by an overrated white man
    malcom X is maybe the best film of the 90s directed by a racist
    either way..
    the academy were in no rush to ''award'' those motion pictures

  • Yvette | February 28, 2014 6:32 PMReply

    I would like to add Angela Bassett and Laurence Fishburne should have won for their roles in What's Love Got To Do With It.

  • Ignorance Lives | March 4, 2014 4:19 PM

    GERARD, kindly stfu.

  • gerard kennelly | March 1, 2014 4:32 PM

    holly hunter was the better performance
    call it racist
    call it the truth
    call it what you want
    hunter was better same as 'The Artist' was superior to other movies the year it won

  • Roberto | February 28, 2014 6:18 PMReply

    I think Halle deserved her Oscar for Monster's but was even better in the film Things we Lost in the Fire, she should have been nominated for that role at least

  • gerard kennelly | March 1, 2014 4:34 PM

    TWLITF also starred alison lohman
    hers was the definition of an oscar worthy performance

  • Syrich | February 28, 2014 11:02 AMReply

    I always felt that Denzel should have won for "Hurricane" and he should get sometype of mention for A soldier's Story.

    And the only thing I have ever seen HB in that I thought she gave a decent performance was Jungle Fever otherwise her acting has never really appealed to me. I just saw "Call" and I kept thinking this movie would be so much better if HB and that little girl were not in it. They both over and under acted.

  • Moviectitic | March 2, 2014 7:27 PM

    Agree re: a Hurricane. Denzel totally got shafted on that

  • Adam Scott Thompson | March 2, 2014 7:04 PM

    Between Washington's and Spacey's performances, it was a dead heat. Both men were in their prime and with access to la crème material. That said, it was probably the controversy regarding the historical accuracy of "The Hurricane" that allowed Spacey to pull ahead.

    The same thing happened the year Denzel won for "Training Day." Although a "Beautiful Mind" ultimately won Best Picture, it too was accused of fudging or omitting facts (Nash was bisexual; he left his first wife [not Jennifer Connelly] and kid and didn't pay child support; schizophrenics' hallucinations are auditory, not visual).

    All it takes sometimes is for a rival studio to initiate a smear campaign, or for the actor to decide they won't lobby that hard.

  • maximus decimus meridius | March 1, 2014 4:37 PM

    @ Sergio

    ironic

    his ''win'' for training day in 2001 was after the russell crowe BAFTA controversy

  • Sergio | February 28, 2014 5:45 PM

    As I wrote in my piece back last fall when the blu-ray DVD for Hurriance was announced Washington had been a lock to win the Oscar but it was the controversy about the film that could have hurt his chances



    "After the film was released, there was a huge outcry over the inaccuracies in it. Furthermore several people, who had previously worked on proving Carter’s innocence for years, weren’t even mentioned in the film, which gave the impression that the Canadian group did all the work, when, in reality, they came in very late into the game, and used the work by those previous others to prove Carter’s innocence. And being that (director Norman) Jewison is Canadian himself, one can understand his favoritism."

    "In fact, it was speculated by some that the controversy may have cost Washington winning the Oscar, and that his win for Training Day in 2001 was partially a sort of “make up” for The Hurricane loss."

  • Jai | February 28, 2014 4:27 PM

    True, he did get another nomination for 'Hurricane' in 1999 but lost to Kevin Spacey for 'American Beauty." Some think that's the reason they finally gave it to him for 'Training Day' two years later.

  • Rocket | February 28, 2014 1:51 PM

    I agree on "Hurricane". It gets lost in the shuffle when people talk about Denzel's extensive career.

Follow Shadow and Act

Email Updates

Most "Liked"

  • Taraji P. Henson Drama 'From The Rough' ...
  • Interview: Marlon Wayans Talks Career, ...
  • Electro (Jamie Foxx) Faces Off Against ...
  • Watch Omar Sy In Action As Bishop In ...
  • Black Movie Trivia - Congrats to our ...
  • Interview: Chatting with RZA About Paul ...
  • Sidney Poitier Made Oscar History Today ...
  • Watch TV ONE’s Fascinating & Informative ...
  • Critically-Acclaimed Doc 'The Trials ...
  • Weekend B.O. April 11-13 (Close, But ...