TIFF Roundup 9/19 - Reviews Of Jennifer Hudson's Winnie Mandela Biopic Are In

by Tambay A. Obenson
September 19, 2011 2:27 AM
6 Comments
  • |

Your Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) daily for September 19th... although the festival screened its last film last night. Another TIFF wrapped up!

On Friday night, Jennifer Hudson's long-awaited Winnie Mandela biopic, Winnie, premiered at TIFF; it also screened a second time on Saturday. Reactions? As suspected, given the trailer we all saw, not very good, unfortunately.

First, from The Hollywood Reporter:

Solid performances are undercut by lack of storytelling integrity in this plodding biopic.There are rich dramatic possibilities in the conflicted choices here, but in striving to inflate the tragic love story, Roodt’s film whitewashes too many moral issues, sacrificing nuance and complexity. Hudson, in particular, deserves better. Her one-on-one scenes with Howard have pathos, but as Winnie’s actions grow more questionable, the film can’t decide whether she’s a martyr or a pariah, and the performance doesn’t answer that question. Without insightful dialogue, Hudson’s expressions of uncompromising defiance, wounded dignity or booze-soaked bitterness veer into cliché. And both Hudson and Howard are done no favors by ropey latex work as their characters age. Some imposing locations aside, the most distinguishing visual aspect is the excessive period detail in Pierre Vienings’ costumes; the 1950s and ‘60s scenes, in particular, are awash in fussy design statements, with more hats than a Philip Treacy showroom. Even later on, it’s hard to feel much as Winnie steps through the charred rubble of her burnt-out house when you’re busy taking in the shimmering aquamarine caftan she’s somehow rescued. The Toronto premiere carried a disclaimer indicating that sound and image quality are not final, and end credits were not yet in place. (A turgid Diane Warren power ballad sung by Hudson played over a black screen.) But technical finessing is not going to change much for a film far too antiquated in its approach to epic storytelling, which makes it less likely to work on big screens than as a prestige women’s television event.

From Variety:

With a title that boasts a level of intimacy this biopic simply doesn't possess, "Winnie" tells the story of Nelson Mandela's wife and co-crusader in broad, black-and-white terms, drawing public criticism from its outspoken subject. Premiering in rough form at the Toronto Film Festival, "Cry the Beloved Country" director Darren James Roodt's TV-style treatment reduces South Africa's struggle to the status of an impediment in the blooming romance between life-imprisoned Mandela (Terrence Howard) and his strong-willed partner (Jennifer Hudson), who kept step, only backwards and in heels. Decently acted despite screenplay shortcomings, pic is best suited for femme-friendly cable. The film acknowledges but doesn't quite know how to handle Winnie's disgrace, with Hudson's turn taking a sinister edge as she becomes godmother to a gang of soccer thugs. These later scenes are compromised by stunningly awful makeup effects that lend Howard and Hudson a distracting rubbery look. Otherwise, the production values are reasonably good, judging by the low-resolution print screened in Toronto.

There was one nod, from Elle Canada:

Howard is magnetic on screen as the former South African President silencing and moving the audience with speeches taken directly from history. Playing opposite him in the film’s title role is Jennifer Hudson, as his wife Winne Mandela. Together, the two capture a monumental period in world history, dramatizing events with care and precision, creating a heartfelt picture of Nelson and Winnie Mandela never seen before. Most Sentimental Moment of the Evening: The closing song of Winnie performed by Jennifer Hudson heard through the sound of sniffles in an otherwise silent theatre.

There might be others like that; but judging from the film's Facebook page, which has seemingly taken to posting only the positive write-ups of the film since its Toronto premiere, there probably aren't many; or likely not enough to match the number of negatives, and I've read a few of those.

All that said, I still want to see it for myself, and hopefully I'll get my chance to do so.

If any of our readers were present for either of the TIFF screenings, do chime in.

  • |

More: Film Festival

You might also like:
Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

6 Comments

  • Orville | September 20, 2011 11:55 AMReply

    I just can't take the reviews of white critics seriously about this issue. I read the Hollywood Reporter review and the critic had the audacity to say the movie made white people look bad. Hello, in South Africa during the apartheid era the whites did treat blacks badly! I would even argue NOT MUCH has changed in South Africa since apartheid. I think South African directors or writers need to do a movie about the post apatheid struggle. It is going to take more than 20 years to erase over 400 years of white supremacy. All the reviews praised Jennifer's performance and that's all that really matters anyyway. I don't think most people care about the technical stuff just about the story.

  • Melper | September 20, 2011 4:23 AMReply

    Saw this at the premiere at TIFF. I'm afraid this was a missed opportunity to tell an important story.

    We were given very little insight into what Winnie Mandela was thinking. Most of Jennifer Hudson's acting chops were reduced to staring, gazing, five word sentences and the same expressions of defiance over and over.

    The film felt like a bunch of loosely strung together vignettes with a made for TV feel.

    Terrance Howard was a stand out and given the storytelling, we thought it should be called Mandela.

    I really really wanted to see this film and like this film. Oh well. I'm also curious about why no one asked Winnie Mandela what she thought? Perhaps because she is a controversial character? Maybe she would've had a fee? Dunno. Opportunity missed.

  • Darla & Mark | September 19, 2011 12:38 PMReply

    One of the reviewer said, people who had doubt about jennifer acting, will eat crow.

    rev up to see her acting

  • other song | September 19, 2011 7:50 AMReply

    Paul, you just got owned. Please read before commenting.

  • tambay | September 19, 2011 4:43 AMReply

    @ Paul - Actually 3 reviews. Although, maybe you missed the part where I said: "There might be others like that; but judging from the film’s Facebook page, which has seemingly taken to posting only the positive write-ups of the film since its Toronto premiere, there probably aren’t many."

    I've read more than 3 reviews; but the point is, the reviews I've posted here are reflective of what's out there currently. I don't have to post every single one.

    But if you've found others that challenge what I have here, feel free to share.

  • paul gilliat | September 19, 2011 3:58 AMReply

    two trade reviews are your summation of the response...???

Follow Shadow and Act

Email Updates

Most "Liked"

  • Taraji P. Henson Drama 'From The Rough' ...
  • Electro (Jamie Foxx) Faces Off Against ...
  • Watch Omar Sy In Action As Bishop In ...
  • Black Movie Trivia - Congrats to our ...
  • Interview: Chatting with RZA About Paul ...
  • Sidney Poitier Made Oscar History Today ...
  • Watch TV ONE’s Fascinating & Informative ...
  • Critically-Acclaimed Doc 'The Trials ...
  • Weekend B.O. April 11-13 (Close, But ...
  • 5 Netflix Streaming Titles You May Not ...