The Five Winners Presenting Thing

by thelostboy
February 25, 2009 2:04 AM
3 Comments
  • |

I've read around that the industry is still raving about Oscar's greatest makeover tool: Getting five previous winners to give it to the next one. Allegedly, its got a good chance of sticking around. And I'm all for that. But I wonder about best supporting actor. Notably the weakest quintet in terms of star power, best supporting actor is a problem because its traditionally an "old man category." And a lot of them are dead (not to mention, with all due respect, this year was a posthumous winner).

Only 3 winners - Joel Grey, Christopher Walken and Robert deNiro - are alive from the seventies (all of which presented, though deNiro in lead, Sunday night). The 80s has six, and the 90s seven. Add that to another 7 from the '00s, and include the fact that Michael Caine is a repeat, that's only 25 possibilities, many of them in their 70s and 80s. And five of them have also won in lead, which makes me wonder if they'd grace the "lesser" stage. And five of them have already presented this year. And some of them might want not to do it.

Supporting actress, on the other hand, has options going way back to the 1950s (Dorothy Malone, Eva Marie Saint).

Either way, the point of this entry was more to make suggestions for next year than suggest that this format may have a 3 year expiry for supporting actor.

For next year:

Best Actor
Sidney Poitier
Dustin Hoffman
Jack Nicholson
Tom Hanks
Sean Penn

Best Actress
Jane Fonda
Diane Keaton
Meryl Streep
Susan Sarandon
Kate Winslet

Best Supporting Actor
Sean Connery
Robin Williams
Morgan Freeman
George Clooney
Javier Bardem

Best Supporting Actress
Maggie Smith
Diane Wiest
Geena Davis
Cate Blanchett
Penelope Cruz

Yours?

get email updates
  • |

More: Awards Season

You might also like:

3 Comments

  • Fred | February 27, 2009 10:07 AMReply

    I like this concept a lot. The speeches delivered were very moving. Even if it is not meant to last. I was thinking of Denzel Washington, Jodie Foster and Judie Dench (for supporting actress in her case)...among many others...for the next three years.

  • Jess | February 26, 2009 3:40 AMReply

    What about Daniel Day Lewis? He seems like an eloquent guy, and if I were nominated and he spoke about me, I would die a happy woman (well, man, seeing as it would be the dude category). I agree that this format is way better than previous years, as it gives those who have no chance of winning a little time in the spotlight (like they deserve) - like Richard Jenkins this year. And didn't William H. Macy win at some point? He should be up there...or, he should win something.

    Your picks for best actress presenters are spot on. Streep, Sarandon, and Keaton combined are the epitome of the female actor.

  • Jess | February 26, 2009 3:40 AMReply

    What about Daniel Day Lewis? He seems like an eloquent guy, and if I were nominated and he spoke about me, I would die a happy woman (well, man, seeing as it would be the dude category). I agree that this format is way better than previous years, as it gives those who have no chance of winning a little time in the spotlight (like they deserve) - like Richard Jenkins this year. And didn't William H. Macy win at some point? He should be up there...or, he should win something.

    Your picks for best actress presenters are spot on. Streep, Sarandon, and Keaton combined are the epitome of the female actor.

Follow Me

Latest Tweets

Follow us

Most "Liked"