So many auteurs, so little time... It's less than 24 hours since the unveiling of Sight & Sound's once-a-decade extensive poll of film critics
to find the quote-unquote greatest film of all time, which for the first time ever, saw Orson Welles'
" fall off the top spot and replaced by Alfred Hitchcock
." And as ever, the list has already inspired extensive and fervent debate.
And as with any such list, there are absences. Not just in terms of films, but also directors who failed to crack the top 50 (all that's been offiicailly revealed by the BFI
so far). While Godard
gets four, Tarkovsky
three, and several other directors more than one, there's all kinds of great filmmakers who miss out entirely. Of course, one shouldn’t read too much into such lists: they will always be divisive and controversial/subjective and many will take them all too seriously, often in a counter-productive, over-emotional manner.
But lists such as this one can also spark debate and discussion, so in the spirit of that notion, we wanted to respond by highlighting some of the most surprising omissions. Below, you can find five classic auteurs and five still-working directors who seem to have been strong candidates for having a film included, and yet still missed out. Angry that both Sight & Sound omitted your own favorites? Let us know in the comments section.
5 Classic, Much-Missed Auteurs
With arguably three masterpieces under his belt (one composing of an entire trilogy, the other spanning a sprawling 10-episode social epic and another chasing his perennial themes of kismet, predestination and chance), the late Polish auteur Krzysztof Kieślowski
never quite gets his due on holistic and sweeping cinephile lists like the Sight & Sound one. Sure, his final film in the Three Colors Trilogy "Red
" was nominated for three Academy Awards
, busting out of the foreign category ghetto to earn plaudits for Best Director and Best Original Screenplay. And even Quentin Tarantino
himself was surprised when "Pulp Fiction
" won the Palme d'Or in 1994 over "Red" (as was some of the audience who booed and jeered the decision vocally). And while "The Decalogue
" -- his masterful 10-episode film series based on the ten commandments about interconnected people living in a housing complex -- the Three Colors Trilogy and "The Double Life of Veronique
" (the latter two having been certified modern classics by the Criterion Collection
) definitely received their rave reviews at the time, Kieslowski always falls short on all-time lists; something we'd love to be reconsidered in the future. The late Stanley Kubrick
, a man known for his reluctance in praising others said about Kieslowski, "[His] very rare ability to dramatize ideas rather than just talking about them [was done with] such dazzling skill, you never see the ideas coming and don't realize until much later how profoundly they have reached your heart.” And Roger Ebert
said, “There were those who believed Kieslowski was the greatest living director. Certainly he ranked with such modern masters as Scorsese
, Kubrick and Kurosawa
.” Called a metaphysicist and a moralist (both two reductive), one could argue Kieslowski was always trying to remake the same film. His was a relentless search of the the invisible mysteries of life, manifesting in doppelgangers and coincidences that were so much more, and the ineffable and elusive intersections where accidents, chance, fate and the synchronicity of time sometimes met and unraveled. Now mind you, Kieslowski's film weren’t remotely close to science-fiction, instead hewing closer to a enigmatic quality of the unforeseeable that was spiritual, but ultimately agnostic. His determined exploration of these themes created deeply moving, thought-provoking and emotionally vibrant films, never over-intellectualizing and always grounding each story with a strikingly relatable moral sheen. For Kieslowski, the world had no strangers, just an interconnectivity that most of us weren’t cognizant about. He is certainly one of the all time greats and the hope is one day he is recognized beyond question.
The Spanish-born Mexican filmmaker Luis Buñuel
is still perhaps best known as the guy who sliced up eyeballs with Salvador Dali
for the infamous 1929 silent surrealist film “Un Chien Andalou
” (immortalized in the Pixies
song “Debaser”). But Buñuel’s long career, which spanned almost six full decades (1929 to 1977) grew into something much more, evoking spiritual themes, scathing and grotesque (and often hilarious) social and political critiques and yes, often within employing an illusory patina of ambiguity and opaqueness. And while the Mexican period of his filmmaking spawned “The Exterminating Angel
” and “Simon of the Desert
” -- the former, a nightmarish and comical look at guests at an upper-class dinner party who find themselves inexplicably unable to leave -- it’s perhaps his final French period (six films, five of which are in the Criterion Collection
” unfortunately being the odd man out) that birthed a period of oblique, surrealist classics like “Belle Du Jour
,” “"The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie
" and perhaps his masterpiece about lust, jealousy and identity, "That Obscure Object of Desire
." Buñuel was well-lauded in his career: "Viridiana
" won the Palme d'Or in 1961, "The Exterminating Angel" won the FIPRESCI prize the following year, 'Charm of the Bourgeoisie' won the Best Foreign Oscar award in 1972 and 'Object of Desire' was nominated for two Academy baubles in 1977. Still, how about a Sight & Sound mention?
Head to any independent film festival, particularly in America, but also across the world, and one starts to understand how hugely influential John Cassavetes
is. From the mumblecore movement to big-budget studio comedies from Judd Apatow
, the director changed the face of American cinema, essentially creating the independent genre as we now know it and inspiring many to pick up a camera. A veteran character actor who used his acting roles (including "The Dirty Dozen
," for which he was nominated for an Oscar, and "Rosemary's Baby
") to finance his films, he made his directorial debut with 1959's "Shadows
" (a film he had already shot in 1957, but disregarded and shot again), and went on to make several films, including "Faces
" "A Woman Under the Influence
," "The Killing of a Chinese Bookie
" and "Opening Night,
" in a similar style: self-financed, using a regular rep company, including Seymour Cassel, Peter Falk, Ben Gazzara
, and wife Gena Rowlands
), and featuring non-traditional, oblique and challenging characters and situations. By putting the actors first, and with his visual style tailored to the resources available -- handheld visuals, little or no lighting -- Cassavetes made filmmaking look achievable for those outside the system, while still delivering a number of searing dramas. Cassavetes' films seem curiously out of fashion among critics, given their influence, which seems to be the major reason for their exclusion. Still, we live in hope for the next time around.
Michael Powell & Emeric Pressburger
Arguably the greatest British filmmakers in history (or at least the ones who stayed in Britain), the team of Powell & Pressburger
(Hungarian emigre Emeric Pressburger
wrote the scripts, Michael Powell
directed, and the two produced together) were behind a string of solid-gold classics through their company The Archers
, mostly in the 1940s, beginning with 1943's "The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp
." Among their best-loved films: 1946's wartime fantasy "A Matter of Life and Death
," dark, nunnery-set psychological thriller "Black Narcissus
" and perhaps most of all, 1948's dance-fuelled fairy tale "The Red Shoes.
" By 1957, the two had amically parted, and never quite matched their early success, particularly after Powell directed the critically-reviled thriller "Peeping Tom,
" which derailed his career near-permanently, and as a result, the films never quite got the critical standing of some of their contemporaries. Their reputation was restored thanks to Martin Scorsese
(whose editor, Thelma Schoonmaker
, married Powell in 1984), and they've been mainstays in lists of the finest British films ever ("The Red Shoes" placed at number nine in the BFI's list in 1999). But like fellow British director David Lean
, they missed out on the top 50 this year. Will their critical standing improve by next time around or are they destined to always miss out?
Rainer Werner Fassbinder
Few filmmakers in the history of medium burnt as brightly in such a short period of time as Rainer Werner Fassbinder
. Despite passing away in 1982 at the age of 37, the German filmmaker produced forty feature films, two television series, three shorts and twenty-four stage plays. The director was always controversial and divisive, but his critical standing has only improved over time thanks to retrospectives and the like. And while his track record isn't flawless, the best of his work -- "Love Is Colder Than Death,
" "The Bitter Tears of Petra Von Kant,
" "Ali: Fear Eats The Soul,
" "The Marriage of Maria Braun
," "Veronika Voss
" (read our retrospective
on the director for more) -- stands with anything that German cinema produced during the 1960s and '70s. But while he's always had passionate advocates, it may be that his Douglas Sirk
-influenced films are too brash and vulgar for some of the polled critics in Sight & Sound. And with such an enormous filmography, which even the most passionate cinephile is bound to have a few gaps in, it may have been that the votes were spread too thinly among his work to register in the top 50 (we'd be interested to know where he comes in the poll of critics' favorite directors, which will be revealed soon). Short of his influence being called upon by a new generation of filmmakers, we're less confident that Fassbinder will ever crack the top of this list, but we can always hope.