"A Beautiful Mind" (2002)
One of the more common tactics to take down a movie (as shown by the campaigns against "Lincoln
" and "Zero Dark Thirty
" this year) is to attack the movies for being factually inaccurate if they're based on a true story. There've been plenty of cases of this one over the years, but perhaps the film that got hit the most aggressively was "A Beautiful Mind
." Ron Howard
's biopic was an early Oscar frontrunner against the likes of "The Fellowship Of The Ring
," "Moulin Rouge!
" and "In The Bedroom
." But at the end of December, a number of stories started emerging, claiming that the film whitewashed homosexuality and anti-semitism from the character of John Nash, as well as being generally wooly with the truth. Not to mention allegations that Akiva Goldsman
's screenplay borrowed from another unmade one. Mostly coming from The Drudge Report and Fox News' Roger Friedman, the allegations were bitterly denied and refuted by distributors Universal
(who'd had similar problems with "The Hurricane
" two years earlier, which proved fatal to the studio), studio chief Stacey Snider saying,
"There's been a shocking absence of self-restraint. Lines that should be clear to all of us have recklessly been crossed. Filmmakers who have done honest work that was never engineered to win an award now are having to defend their intentions." But things got particularly bitter when rumors linked Miramax
, who were pushing "In The Bedroom
," to the campaign. Harvey Weinstein
confronted Snider at the Golden Globes
, saying he'd "bury" the film if the rumors continued, before Miramax sent a letter defending their Oscar tactics to the LA Times. But regardless who was behind it, it didn't work; the film won Best Picture, Director, Supporting Actress and Screenplay.
"Gangs Of New York" / "The Hours" / "The Pianist" (2003)
If 2002 marked the most memorable case of Oscar swift-boating, 2003 was really when the dirty tricks hit something of a peak, with three major films all facing attacks, or seemingly bending the rules to get a head start. Rumors came up suggesting that "The Hours
" star Nicole Kidman
had an affair with then-married co-star Jude Law
on the set of "Cold Mountain
," rumors which were never confirmed and didn't prevent her from winning Best Actress. Meanwhile, a few weeks before the awards, thesmokinggun.com published documents detailing Roman Polanski
's sexual assault of the then 13-year-old Samantha Geimer
(while Geimer herself gave an interview in which she said that "The Pianist
" should be judged on its own merits). And most memorably, legendary filmmaker Robert Wise
("The Sound of Music
"), a former Academy president wrote an editorial arguing that Martin Scorsese
should win the Best Director Oscar for "Gangs Of New York
." The editorial, used in several ads by the studio, was seen by many Academy members as breaking campaign rules, which was further aggravated when it emerged that the editorial had actually been written by Miramax
publicist Murray Weissman
. Some Academy members tried to get their ballots back to change their vote, but it didn't matter anyway as Scorsese lost to Polanski (he would finally win four years later, but Wise didn't live to see it, passing away in September 2005).
"The Hurt Locker"
's Iraq war drama was both the victim of a campaign and the perpetrator, both to the film's detriment (though once again, not to the extent that it lost Best Picture). One of the film's producers, Nicolas Chartier
, wrote a mass email asking them to vote (or encourage friends to vote) for "The Hurt Locker
" rather than "a $500 million film, we need independent movies to win like the movies you and I do." Competitors, not least Fox
, who were behind "Avatar
" (the $500M film Chartier speaks of) were outraged, as were the Academy, who banned Chartier from the ceremony (though the producer still received a statuette when it won). Meanwhile, around the same time, a number of pieces emerged attacking the film's accuracy, quoting real-life bomb disposal in the LA TImes
(a paper that wrote five separate takedown pieces on the movie) saying "There is too much John Wayne
and cowboy stuff. It is very loosely based on actual events," a piece that followed hot on the heels of similar ones by Newsweek and The Associated Press. Once again, Harvey Weinstein,
who was pushing "Inglourious Basterds
" at the time, was widely expected
to be behind the salvo, but whoever it was, it again proved unsuccessful.
It gets ugly out there people. Any paticular smear campaigns you remember that we didn't mention? Sound off below.