Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Review: Entertaining And Well-Crafted 'The Imitation Game' Starring Benedict Cumberbatch & Keira Knightley Review: Entertaining And Well-Crafted 'The Imitation Game' Starring Benedict Cumberbatch & Keira Knightley Watch: Vince Vaughn Has 'Unfinished Business' In NSFW First Trailer Watch: Vince Vaughn Has 'Unfinished Business' In NSFW First Trailer Do You Like Spy Movies? Watch The New Trailer For 'Kingsman: The Secret Service' With Colin Firth & Samuel L. Jackson Do You Like Spy Movies? Watch The New Trailer For 'Kingsman: The Secret Service' With Colin Firth & Samuel L. Jackson Watch: Vintage Footage Of The Real John Du Pont, Plus Over 1 Hour Of 'Foxcatcher' Interviews With Director And Cast Watch: Vintage Footage Of The Real John Du Pont, Plus Over 1 Hour Of 'Foxcatcher' Interviews With Director And Cast Watch: Wes Anderson's Original Black And White Short ‘Bottle Rocket’ Watch: Wes Anderson's Original Black And White Short ‘Bottle Rocket’ Review: 'The Penguins of Madagascar,' Featuring The Voices Of Benedict Cumberbatch, John Malkovich & Werner Herzog Review: 'The Penguins of Madagascar,' Featuring The Voices Of Benedict Cumberbatch, John Malkovich & Werner Herzog David O. Russell Talks Music In Film, Led Zeppelin, Jon Brion’s Unused ‘Fighter’ Score & ‘American Hustle’ On Vinyl David O. Russell Talks Music In Film, Led Zeppelin, Jon Brion’s Unused ‘Fighter’ Score & ‘American Hustle’ On Vinyl Watch: New International Trailer And Images For 'Jupiter Ascending' With Channing Tatum And Mila Kunis Watch: New International Trailer And Images For 'Jupiter Ascending' With Channing Tatum And Mila Kunis Watch: Christopher Nolan, Angelina Jolie & Bennett Miller Remember Mike Nichols Plus 8-Minute Video Essay On His Career Watch: Christopher Nolan, Angelina Jolie & Bennett Miller Remember Mike Nichols Plus 8-Minute Video Essay On His Career Watch: Zac Efron Talks About His Masturbation Techniques In 'The Interview' Segment With James Franco Watch: Zac Efron Talks About His Masturbation Techniques In 'The Interview' Segment With James Franco The Park Is Open: First Brief Teaser & Poster For 'Jurassic World' Arrives The Park Is Open: First Brief Teaser & Poster For 'Jurassic World' Arrives Watch: 3 Graphic, Very NSFW Clips From Lars von Trier's 'Nymphomaniac Vol II — Director's Cut' Watch: 3 Graphic, Very NSFW Clips From Lars von Trier's 'Nymphomaniac Vol II — Director's Cut' The Most Underrated And Underseen Films Of 2014 So Far The Most Underrated And Underseen Films Of 2014 So Far Ranking The 10 Best And 10 Worst Villains In Superhero Movies Ranking The 10 Best And 10 Worst Villains In Superhero Movies 21 Movies About Weird, Kinky Or Compulsive Sex 21 Movies About Weird, Kinky Or Compulsive Sex SXSW Review: Spierig Brothers 'Predestination'  Starring Ethan Hawke SXSW Review: Spierig Brothers 'Predestination' Starring Ethan Hawke 25 Films About First Love To Fall For 25 Films About First Love To Fall For The 15 Best TV Shows Of The 2012/2013 Season The 15 Best TV Shows Of The 2012/2013 Season The Playlist Bares All: 20 Unforgettable Nude Scenes The Playlist Bares All: 20 Unforgettable Nude Scenes 16 Great Revenge Movies Worth Hunting Down 16 Great Revenge Movies Worth Hunting Down

David Cronenberg Clarifies Comments About 'Dark Knight' Series, Questions Comic Book Movies As Cinematic Art

Photo of Kevin Jagernauth By Kevin Jagernauth | The Playlist January 2, 2013 at 1:55PM

Last summer, David Cronenberg caused a bit of an uproar among fanboy circles when it was reported that he said Christopher Nolan's best film was "Memento," and by comparison, his Batman films were "boring." Of course, this caused quite the heated reaction on the interwebs, but with his own "Cosmopolis" hitting home video his week, we got a chance to sit down with Cronenberg and we couldn't help but ask him about that minor controversy. And while he chalks up some of it to his words being taken out of context, he's still not convinced of the potential of the comic book movie genre. 
55
The Dark Knight Rises David Cronenberg

Last summer, David Cronenberg caused a bit of an uproar among fanboy circles when it was reported that he said Christopher Nolan's best film was "Memento," and by comparison, his Batman films were "boring." Of course, this caused quite the heated reaction on the interwebs, but with his own "Cosmopolis" hitting home video his week, we got a chance to sit down with Cronenberg, and we couldn't help but ask him about that minor controversy. And while he chalks up some of it to his words being taken out of context, he's still not convinced of the potential of the comic book movie genre. 

"No, I haven't seen ['The Dark Knight Rises']. See, this is how it all gets distorted. The question was asked, to me. And, of course, when they quote me, they never quote themselves or the question that provoked the response," Cronenberg explained. "I was asked, then the journalist woman said, 'By the way, superhero comic book movies have shown to rise to the highest level of cinematic art – would you be interested in doing one?' And I said, 'Wait, who said they have risen to the highest level of cinematic art?' That's when I started my little rant. I was really responding to that. She proposed that about the new Batman movies. I had seen the one before this ['The Dark Knight'], not the new one, and I think at that time only journalists had seen it. So I wasn't talking specifically about that movie and I wasn't criticizing it directly." 

It should be noted that Cronenberg's comments came a few weeks after 'Rises' hit theaters, but that's also besides the point. However, what he does want to make clear is that his feelings were more directed at the genre as a whole, and not Nolan specifically. "What I was saying was that a comic book movie is really a comic book movie. Comic books were -- especially those comic books which I was raised on (I loved Captain Marvel) -- created for adolescents and they have a core that is adolescent," he elaborated. "To me, that limits the discourse of your movie if you're basing it accurately on that, and you cannot rise to the highest level of cinematic art. That's my take on it. I went on to say that, of course, technically they can be incredibly interesting, since there are very clever people making the movie and of course have a lot of money they are throwing at it. But creatively, artistically, they are incredibly limited. It got bent out of shape that I was dissing Christopher Nolan, which just wasn't the case."

Certainly, with Nolan's 'Rises' proving to be an ambitious capper to his groundbreaking trilogy and with "The Avengers" becoming a global blockbuster and one of the biggest movies of all time, there are many who will dispute Cronenberg's assertions. What are your thoughts? Can comic book movies also double as cinematic art? Weigh in below and stayed tuned for more from our chat with Cronenberg tomorrow.

This article is related to: David Cronenberg, The Dark Knight Rises


The Playlist

The obsessives' guide to contemporary cinema via film discussion, news, reviews, features, nostalgia, movie music, soundtracks, DVDs and more.


E-Mail Updates