Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Ridley Scott Says 'Exodus' Would Never Get Financed Starring "Mohammad So-and-So From Such-And-Such” Ridley Scott Says 'Exodus' Would Never Get Financed Starring "Mohammad So-and-So From Such-And-Such” Ridley Scott Says 'Blade Runner 2' Shoots In 2015 But He Won't Direct, Harrison Ford Will Show Up In The Third Act Ridley Scott Says 'Blade Runner 2' Shoots In 2015 But He Won't Direct, Harrison Ford Will Show Up In The Third Act Retrospective: The Films Of Francis Ford Coppola Retrospective: The Films Of Francis Ford Coppola Watch: Joe Wright Enters Fairy Tale Land With First Trailer For ‘Pan’ Starring Hugh Jackman & Rooney Mara Watch: Joe Wright Enters Fairy Tale Land With First Trailer For ‘Pan’ Starring Hugh Jackman & Rooney Mara Watch: James Franco And Seth Rogen Are Burning Down The House In Final Trailer For 'The Interview' Watch: James Franco And Seth Rogen Are Burning Down The House In Final Trailer For 'The Interview' Watch: Carla Gugino Has Ulterior Motives For Meeting Patrick Stewart In The Trailer For ‘Match’ Watch: Carla Gugino Has Ulterior Motives For Meeting Patrick Stewart In The Trailer For ‘Match’ DOC NYC Review: 'Matt Shepard is a Friend of Mine' A Moving Eulogy To A Life Lost, But Not Forgotten DOC NYC Review: 'Matt Shepard is a Friend of Mine' A Moving Eulogy To A Life Lost, But Not Forgotten Watch: Stanley Kubrick Supercut Explores The Director's Use Of Red Watch: Stanley Kubrick Supercut Explores The Director's Use Of Red Watch: Entire First Season Of Brit TV Series 'Widows' That Steve McQueen Is Remaking For His Next Film Watch: Entire First Season Of Brit TV Series 'Widows' That Steve McQueen Is Remaking For His Next Film Watch: Al Pacino Plays An Aging Rocker Transformed By John Lennon In First Trailer For ‘Danny Collins’ Watch: Al Pacino Plays An Aging Rocker Transformed By John Lennon In First Trailer For ‘Danny Collins’ Listen: 45-Minute Talk With Christopher Nolan, Plus The Big Twist From Steven Spielberg's 'Interstellar' Script And More Listen: 45-Minute Talk With Christopher Nolan, Plus The Big Twist From Steven Spielberg's 'Interstellar' Script And More Watch: 3 Graphic, Very NSFW Clips From Lars von Trier's 'Nymphomaniac Vol II — Director's Cut' Watch: 3 Graphic, Very NSFW Clips From Lars von Trier's 'Nymphomaniac Vol II — Director's Cut' The Best Films Of 2014 So Far... The Best Films Of 2014 So Far... 21 Movies About Weird, Kinky Or Compulsive Sex 21 Movies About Weird, Kinky Or Compulsive Sex SXSW Review: Spierig Brothers 'Predestination'  Starring Ethan Hawke SXSW Review: Spierig Brothers 'Predestination' Starring Ethan Hawke From Worst To Best: Ranking The Films Of Hayao Miyazaki From Worst To Best: Ranking The Films Of Hayao Miyazaki The 15 Best Documentaries Of 2013 The 15 Best Documentaries Of 2013 The 15 Best TV Shows Of The 2012/2013 Season The 15 Best TV Shows Of The 2012/2013 Season The Playlist Bares All: 20 Unforgettable Nude Scenes The Playlist Bares All: 20 Unforgettable Nude Scenes 16 Great Revenge Movies Worth Hunting Down 16 Great Revenge Movies Worth Hunting Down

James Franco Thinks Being A Sex Addict In 'Shame' Wasn't So Bad, Criticizes Gay Club Sequence

Photo of Kevin Jagernauth By Kevin Jagernauth | The Playlist November 15, 2013 at 2:10PM

So, James Franco has seen "12 Years A Slave" three times already. And after the second viewing, he penned a review for Vice because that's what he does sometimes these days, and leave it to Franco to reference Alexis de Tocqueville and two of his own movies ("Homefront," "This Is The End") in the process. But he also talks about "12 Years A Slave," the book versus the movie and the previous movies of director Steve McQueen, notably "Shame," which Franco has some problems with. Mostly, he thinks being a sex addict probably isn't so bad, and more crucially, he thinks the downward spiral culminating in a gay sex club visit during the third act was a bit offensive.
28
Shame James Franco

So, James Franco has seen "12 Years A Slave" three times already. And after the second viewing, he penned a review for Vice because that's what he does sometimes these days. And leave it to Franco to reference Alexis de Tocqueville and two of his own movies ("Homefront," "This Is The End") in the process. But he also talks about "12 Years A Slave," the book versus the movie and the previous movies of director Steve McQueen, notably "Shame," which Franco has some problems with. Mostly, he thinks being a sex addict probably isn't so bad, and more crucially, he thinks the downward spiral culminating in a gay sex club visit during the third act was a bit offensive: 

Watch Michael Fassbender in Twelve Years a Slave. He has been in every McQueen film to date—did McQueen’s parents like the actor Steve McQueen? Just wondering...—first as the hunger striker, Bobby Sands, in Hunger; then as the sex addict in Shame. He wasn’t such an addict in my opinion, though. I mean, what did he do? Watch porn and screw a handful of people a week? I could point to quite a few folks who do that. And that scene where he’s at his lowest point and wants to fuck and goes into a gay club, and it’s depicted like the seventh level of hell... I mean, it goes back to the horrible representations of gays in the 70s, where the gay club is meant to signify everything dark and depraved. Then the guy gets a minor blowjob, from, Oh no, a man! The horror

Of course, Franco seems to be missing the point that it's not about who Fassbender's character is getting sexually involved with, it's more that his addiction has gone beyond desire or carnality into just needing a fix any way he can get it. That it's in a gay club adds a dramatic weight for a character that is straight, but we do see where Franco is coming from in how the club is presented. Anyway, it's some interesting food for thought. As for "12 Years A Slave"? Franco is utterly blown away by Fassbender's performance and movie itself, and watched it two nights in a row. We'll just let him explain.

This is Fassbender’s film. I don’t say that because the other actors don’t give equally strong performances; it has less to do with the work by the actors and more to do with the way the characters are framed and the kind of material they are given to perform. (As a contrast watch Fassbender in The Councilor [sic] and see him in a passive role. He didn’t suddenly turn into a lesser actor—he filmed it immediately after Twelve Years a Slave—but he was given a part that doesn’t take action, he just sits and suffers.) If this is, in fact, a movie about Epps the slave owner as much as Northup the slave, what does that mean for the audience? We get to watch an incredible actor behave like a monster and we like it, we love itbecause he is so charming, and handsome. We like watching humans get beaten, and if such beatings are framed in the right way, in this case, in an important film about American history, then we will lap up all that brutality and want more. I know I did. I watched it two nights in a row. I love this film. I’m beguiled by it.

*A little postscript after watching the film for the third time: Northup is a hero for the ages, and McQueen has given us a gift.

Agree or disagree with Franco? You know where to go ...

This article is related to: Shame, James Franco, 12 Years a Slave


The Playlist

The obsessives' guide to contemporary cinema via film discussion, news, reviews, features, nostalgia, movie music, soundtracks, DVDs and more.


E-Mail Updates