Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Katie Walsh's Top 10 Films Of 2012

by Katie Walsh
January 1, 2013 11:49 AM
  • |

5. “Rust & Bone”
Jacques Audiard’s latest stuck with me for days after seeing it, and I wasn’t sure why. Every time I try to tell someone about the film (“Marion Cotillard loses her legs in a whale training accident, so then she starts managing illegal street fighting, and Katy Perry's "Firework" is in it, twice, but no, it’s really really good!”), invariably they look at me askance and say “that sounds horrible/depressing.” Actually, it’s quite life-affirming. Of course, Cotillard is fantastic, but it’s nice to see another side to her; here she’s at times depressed, angry, confused, not so sure of herself, but utterly fearless in a way. Matthias Schoenaerts goes toe to toe with her as the feral, unbridled beast of a man out of touch with his own emotions. Her essence, her profession is managing huge killer beasts with the capacity for violence and destruction who find themselves able to nuzzle up to her love, her touch. The scene where she reconnects with her whale after the accident is not so different from when she allows him to kiss her for the first time. It’s a film about bodies, physicality and environment, emotions and connections with another human being, and Audiard works that into this unlikely love story. It also feels like it couldn’t have been directed in any other way, the dappled sunlight dancing on the back of Cotillard’s neck, the close up of a bloody tooth rattling across pavement. And even with that desperation and violence, “Rust & Bone” is possibly the most romantic movie of the year.

4. “Beware of Mr. Baker"
I’ve sounded the call for this documentary ever since I saw it at SXSW this year, and have been surprised that it hasn’t received more attention. I love rockumentaries, and this one knocks it out of park in terms of subject, content, storytelling and style. Not to mention the music itself. First-time director (yet another one on this list!) Jay Bulger goes on an epic odyssey into the life and times of forgotten genius Ginger Baker, bringing the audience on this wild and rollicking ride, a tough but satisfying tangle with the dangerous Mr. Baker. The film opened this fall at the IFC in New York, and continues to roll out, and here’s hoping it will get more exposure soon, as it’s one of the most creative treatments of the rock biopic seen in a long time. The film itself hums with the beat of Baker’s drum, throbbing with its own unique heartbeat. Beware of Mr. Baker, but don’t stay away.

3. “Anna Karenina”
The experience of watching the sweeping, gorgeous “Anna Karenina” is basically like having goosebumps for two and a half hours. It’s simply delicious, and one of the most cinematic pieces of film this year. The stage-set conceit that Tom Stoppard and Joe Wright brought to the classic novel was, of course, brilliant in its conception and execution, and it also managed to boil the tome down to its most basic themes and ideas. What really made it work for me was the slightly campy tone all the players involved brought to the proceedings. Keira Knightley is over the top as the doomed Anna, with all of her gasping and whirling and swooning, Matthew Macfadyen (so criminally underrated) bursting with ebullience, Aaron Taylor-Johnson so beautiful and so vacant as Vronsky. And yet, in contrast, we have the earthy and sensual Levin (Domhnall Gleeson) and Kitty (Alicia Vikander), bringing the proceedings back down to earth. It perfectly captures the themes of the artifice of aristocracy battling against the simple country life. That all of these things are expressed visually and so beautifully is a testament to Mr. Wright.

2. “How To Survive a Plague”
Another first feature from a debut filmmaker, journalist David France culled an extensive library of video archives to create the document of the influential historical moment that was ACT UP and the AIDS crisis. This documentary plays like Activism 101, watching these young artists, intellectuals and bohemians of New York City try to understand and combat this mysterious illness that felled so many of them without seeming rhyme or reason. But it’s not just the blueprint for how these fierce individuals educated themselves and took on AIDS without any outside support, it’s also a tender and touching tribute to those who were lost. The most important thing these activists did was assert their own human rights and demand the full attention of those who might deny it, thereby creating themselves as citizens in a world where they were not fully recognized. The film is masterful in its storytelling -- there’s a moment about three quarters of the way through the movie so brilliant that you realize that France isn’t just telling the story of these people, he’s recreating that experience for the audience. At one point during the film, I stepped out of the theater, sobbing, and France was standing outside. He just wrapped me in a big hug. A truly remarkable artist, and I can’t wait to see what he does next, but if this were to be his only film, it would be more than enough. 

1. Beasts of the Southern Wild
I’ve known and followed the work of Benh Zeitlin and Court 13 for years, and was eagerly anticipating his feature debut. However, I didn’t quite expect the reaction I continue to have to this diamond in the rough of a film. 'Beasts' is a delight because of its context: made on a micro-budget by a wild band of novice filmmakers who lived inside of this film in order to get it made, but also in its content. There’s an overwhelming sense of the strength of human spirit communicated in the determined jaw of a tiny Hushpuppy, the wild abandon of her warrior shriek, the rough, tender relationship between her and father Wink. When the score opens up and the restless camera alights on the wondrous face of Quvenzhané Wallis, it’s almost too much to bear. Strikingly original, gloriously human, it’s no wonder “Beasts of the Southern WIld” took the world by storm in 2012.

Honorable mentions: “Moonrise Kingdom,” "Take This Waltz," “Cloud Atlas,” “Cabin in the Woods,” “Starlet,” “Teddy Bear,” “The Iran Job,” “Beauty is Embarrassing,” “Paul Williams: Still Alive.”

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    


  • anonymous | January 4, 2013 12:09 AMReply

    not even a mention of madea goes to jail?

  • Silvana | January 1, 2013 8:07 PMReply

    Rust and Bone is a wonderful film, a masterpiece!

  • Sia | January 1, 2013 6:34 PMReply

    great list.

  • Joel Johnson | January 1, 2013 1:12 PMReply

    I found most of your list quite interesting and helpful in drawing attention to a number of worthy films that may have been overlooked. In talking with some friends last evening, we had agreed that it had been a pretty good year for films with multiple possibilities for inclusion in a best films list for 2012. "The Master" was unsatisfying, but according to your logic expressed in regard to "Holy Motors" such a shortcoming should not be an impediment to being on your list in that you do ascribe to it "technical perfection." To me it seemed that "The Master" felt like a part of a larger story though I am not aware that Paul Thomas Anderson has indicated any intention to expand on this story either earlier or after the time-period depicted. I was particularly intrigued by your inclusion of "Holy Motors" on your list. I appreciate your honesty in admitting that you were baffled and befuddled by it. I am sure that this was precisely the reaction from the vast majority of filmgoers who went to see it which certainly would explain why you were watching it in an empty theater on a Friday night. However, I am not persuaded by what you have written that a film that leaves its audiences totally confused--including film academics who should be the best prepared to deal with its continual referencing of prior films--and assaulted by a variety of visual grotesqueries warrants inclusion on a list of 10 Best Films. It seems to me that many film critics have fallen in love with this totally unique film and that others have included it on their lists just to avoid expulsion from the fraternity. Your rationale for including it when you still aren't sure what to make of it and can't even say you enjoyed the journey when you watched it suggests you are following the herd and listing it because so many other critics are.

  • Katie Walsh | January 1, 2013 1:35 PM

    I certainly understand why you might find fault with my logic there, but ultimately it comes down to that inexplicable subjectivity that can't really be explained with logic: I just liked Holy Motors better. I really debated with myself about whether to include it, and ultimately I think it's a more interesting, and yes, enjoyable mindfuck than The Master, which was an uncomfortable two and half hours that I have no desire to sit through again. Also, Holy Motors has a lot more heart and humanity, and fit into my "life-affirming" theme that became the overarching idea of why I connected with certain films this year. There's really no rhyme or reason or logic, sorry to say.

  • oogle monster | January 1, 2013 12:47 PMReply

    Anonymous strikes again! The Master is superb but Katie's list isn't half bad.

  • anonymous | January 1, 2013 11:53 AMReply

    Don't feel bad for disliking The Master. It has a hollow core of nothing. Its stupid.

  • maggie | January 1, 2013 1:28 PM

    the master was a great movie

Email Updates