Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Oscars: What Films Are Looking Good Coming Out Of Venice, Telluride & TIFF?

Awards
by Oliver Lyttelton
September 12, 2013 4:36 PM
15 Comments
  • |
Hugh Jackman, Prisoners

Looking Good, But Quite Not There Yet
Telluride saw the first screenings of Denis Villeneuve's "Prisoners" and Ron Howard's "Rush," and both were, in general, warmly received, and look life definite prospects. From long range, we'd considered the former to be a principally commercial prospect, but reviews thus far have been fairly stellar. Having been nominated for the Foreign Language Oscar a few years back with "Incendies," Denis Villeneuve looks to be continuing an awards run, and Hugh Jackman and Jake Gyllenhaal are both prospects for nomination, even if our gut says they'll be outside the final five come January (Maria Bello and/or Viola Davis are also potentials, but we believe their roles are too small to ultimately get through, though as Jacki Weaver will tell you from last year, that's not always a roadblock to a nod). There's a lingering feeling from some that the film may just be too dark and, yes, pulp-y to go the distance—the similar "Mystic River" wasn't quite as brutal, and of course had the more obviously prestige-y Clint Eastwood factor. But healthy box office when it opens in a few weeks will help.

Rush, Daniel Bruhl

We actually saw "Rush" six weeks or so back, and while this writer liked it a fair bit less than the official review, the crowd we were with ate it up, and it felt fairly clear that it could attract some attention. Still, we were surprised by how warm most of the reactions from Telluride and TIFF have been, so it's very much in the conversation, as is co-lead Daniel Bruhl (who'll be campaigning in supporting, and aided by the relatively little traction that he's getting for "The Fifth Estate"). We still wonder about the appeal of the film in the U.S, given the general apathy towards Formula 1, and it never really transcends the sports movie genre, so there's potential weakness that could see it drop out of the top slots if those still to come deliver. But if "Frost/Nixon" could make it in in a five-film year, one shouldn't doubt the potential of Ron Howard's film too much here.

Not actually on the festival circuit yet is "Captain Philips" (it's opening the New York, London and Tokyo Film Festivals in the next month or so), but the trades breaking embargo on the film led to early word getting out sooner-than-expected, and it's pretty strong. Few are losing their shit over it completely, but Paul Greengrass seems to have delivered a docudrama that stands alongside his earlier "Bloody Sunday" and "United 93," and one centered on a performance—by most accounts, his best in years—from award-friendly megastar Tom Hanks (who'll also be in contention for Supporting Actor for "Saving Mr. Banks"). There are already rumblings in terms of the film's treatment of the pirates from some quarters, and we wonder if its impact will be dulled for those who saw this year's superb "A Hijacking" (likely very few of the Academy membership, admittedly), but Scott Rudin and Sony are following the template that worked beautifully for them for "The Social Network" a few years ago, and there's no reason to think it won't pay off again.

Also shoring up a strong position is Alexander Payne's "Nebraska," which if anything, got better notices out of Telluride than it did at Cannes. The film doesn't have the star wattage of Alexander Payne's previous film "The Descendants," but the film, and star Bruce Dern, are very much in the top tier of potential contenders right now, though, again, we wonder if its relative intimacy makes it vulnerable to bigger hitters like "American Hustle" and "Monuments Men" down the line.

August: Osage County

The Less Well Received Contenders That'll Probably Get In Anyway
With many films delivering and then some on their promise at the festivals, it was inevitable that something wouldn't quite take off in the way many expected, and it seems that the biggest film to do so was "August: Osage County." Our review was one of the more negative ones, but reaction in general has been fairly cool, with quite a few detractors, and the film's fans generally acknowledge that it's a flawed piece of work. But we suspect that, if any awards-targeting film is essentially review-proof, it's this one due to source material already swimming in Tonys and Pulitzers, a much-lauded cast along with  George Clooney and Harvey Weinstein in the producers' chairs. Maybe most importantly, unless "Grace Of Monaco" proves to be a real surprise, it's the most obvious contender from The Weinstein Company, certainly over "The Butler" and "Fruitvale Station." The films' huge ensemble is likely to make it a favorite among the actors' branch (it already feels like a good bet for the SAG ensemble prize), so reviews be damned, we'd be very surprised if it didn't make the Best Picture cut, with Meryl Streep and Julia Roberts looking likely for their own nods.

Dallas Buyers Club
"Dallas Buyers Club"

Looking Set For Acting Nods, Could Make Best Picture Too
Most had figured that "Dallas Buyers Club" was looking good for Matthew McConaughey, given his dramatic weight loss, and the film's status as the culmination of an extraordinary couple of years for the star. And indeed, the performance, by almost all accounts, really delivers—not just a physical transformation, but an honest-to-good great piece of acting, and at this stage, he's a lock for Best Actor, and looks likely to be pitted against Chiwetel Ejiofor in the months to come. But what was more surprising is that the film itself was as warmly received as it was, and that co-star Jared Leto, who hadn't acted in nearly four years, would become a serious possibility for his supporting turn as McConaughey's characters' trans business partner. Bar a brace of surprises still to come in the category, Leto looks like he'll be a nominee, and the film certainly has a shot as well being Focus' sole real priority this year (though we vainly hope that they might launch a Best Actor push for Simon Pegg in "The World's End"—seriously, he's totally deserving...). Assuming the good reviews continue on release, it's very much in the race.

Equally surprising was the quality of "Philomena," which we were somewhat dreading in Venice, and turned out to be far, far better than it had any right to be. We're unlikely to personally include it among our favorites of the year, to be sure, but it's sharper and funnier than you might expect, and should go down a storm with the Academy membership. Even given the weighty competition, Judi Dench is a very strong Best Actress contender, and Steve Coogan could well see a Screenplay nod (he won, with co-writer Jeff Pope in Venice) and possibly even a Supporting Actor nomination, though the latter is less likely. As for Best Picture? The film is enough of an issues-driven crowd-pleaser that it's sure to be in the conversation, though again, it may be pushed out by films seen, fairly or unfairly, as being less dominated by a single turn. That being said, if it walks away with Audience Award in Toronto—where the movie played very well—expect the Weinsteins to hustle this one in a hurry.

All Is Lost, Robert Redford

Robert Redford continues to be considered an obvious choice for a Best Actor slot thanks to "All Is Lost," and if the momentum behind the J.C Chandor directed film can keep up, it's certainly a possibility for Picture, Director and more. Redford's legendary status gives it an advantage, but as a less obvious technical showcase than fellow survival tale "Gravity," it's going to have to breakthrough to reach other major categories.

Finally, we floated before the festival season kicked off the idea that "Enough Said" might be worth keeping an eye on, at least for James Gandolfini's performance, his penultimate one (and likely a much more significant one than his final film, next year's "Animal Rescue"). Reviews have been kind to a point—it's ultimately a Nicole Holofcener film, so fairly intimate and small scale, so it doesn't seem to have Best Picture legs, though in a year thin with comedy, a Golden Globe nomination might well be a good bet. But the notices are united on Gandolfini's turn, so a nomination in Supporting is certainly viable if Fox Searchlight push for it.

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

15 Comments

  • Child of God | September 29, 2013 11:55 PMReply

    Scott Haze 4 Child of God with nomination 4 James Franco as Director.

    Also, hope the Oscars don't forget Franco's performance 4 Spring Breakers as in Best Supporting Actor.

  • Bill G | September 14, 2013 3:51 PMReply

    How about Brie Larson in "Short Term 12", and the film in general? Is it lacking in star power? Is Cinedigm too small to give it an Oscar push? It's definitely the best film I've seen all year, though I admit that I haven't seen most of the heavy hitters yet.

  • CrombyMouse | September 13, 2013 3:19 AMReply

    And what about Ain't Them Body Saints?

  • catherin | September 13, 2013 3:11 AMReply

    I expected to see some improvements in my love life after I contacted Ekaka and asked him to send out a spell to the Universe for me, but I didn’t expect a life-changing experience, that’s for sure! Still, though, that’s what I got! I’m not only in love, I’m going to be moving to my soon-to-be-fiance’s state next month! We probably would never even have met if it weren’t for ekakaspelltemple@ yahoocom and his wonderful powers of peace and love. I wish you all the peace and love you sent me, DR Ekaka.

  • cirkusfolk | September 12, 2013 8:13 PMReply

    I saw the trailer for Prisoners and was immediately struck by how gorgeous it looked. So I looked up who shot it, and of course it was none other than Roger Deakins. I'll expect another nom for him this year, but not the win :(

  • Mohammed | September 12, 2013 5:47 PMReply

    If there is one film I like to see excluded it's August: Osage County. It looks terrible, has had mixed to bad reviews, and it's director is telling the press that the ending wasn't made by him or for creative choice, but 1) because test-audiences liked the current one, and 2) because Harvey demanded it. Send a message that the creative choice should be the directors and shut out August entirely.

    Also shut out American Hustle. Russel's Silver was a sh** movie that somehow went all the way entirely on the basis of Harvey. And anyone who thinks Jennifer Lawrence delivered a better performance than Riva is crazy.

  • Oh Dear | September 12, 2013 8:37 PM

    Silver Linings Playbook is pure brilliance. Riva and Lawrence were equally great.

  • Tyler | September 12, 2013 6:21 PM

    American Hustle has alot of things going for it and will certainly not be shut out. It will most likely be up for Best Picture. But you must have been watching a completely different movie than the rest of the world if you though Silver Linings sucked

  • cass | September 12, 2013 5:41 PMReply

    what are you talking about when you say the evil nature of his character will go against Fassbender? Hello Bardem in No Country, Waltz in Basterds, Ledger in Dark Knight. Tucci, Renner and Brolin were nominated; this category LOVES evil guys.

  • Daniel O'Raw | September 13, 2013 3:54 PM

    The mere thought that the evil nature of a character could stop someone winning for a great performance is ridiculous. If the Oscars think like that, then they truly are retarded, but I guess they are considering Ralph Fiennes Nazi performance not winning and them giving it to bloody Tommy Lee Jones' silly cop chasing Harrison Ford in the Fugitive.

  • Fred | September 13, 2013 12:06 PM

    I would say that at the time, Bardem was not fun evil. Perhaps taken as the kickoff of his colorful, crazy-haired villain string and of a piece with them, but the strange do still didn't make his killer much fun. Ditto Waltz: witty banter doesn't negate the horrific deeds of a Nazi or a sociopathic killing machine.

  • Oliver Lyttelton | September 12, 2013 7:02 PM

    But there's fun evil -- Bardem, Waltz, Ledger -- and brutal, irredeemable, inhuman evil. I feel like Fassbender's more in the latter category in Slave, and that's less popular when it comes to that category. Then again, Ralph Fiennes was nominated for Schindler's List, so it wouldn't be unprecedented.

  • joe | September 12, 2013 5:34 PMReply

    you will first hear it in this commnet:

    altough james gandolfini has a bigger role in enough said he absolutelly kills it in animal rescue

    his performance is hands down the second best in his carrer (number one will always be tony ) but the best in his film career and you'll hear his name among the supporting actor nominees in 2015 at the oscars

  • BOO | September 12, 2013 5:32 PMReply

    Fruitvale Station I think is still a contender for a Picture nomination. It's kind of like Beasts of the Southern Wild and the Academy gave that a lot.

  • Tyler | September 12, 2013 6:17 PM

    If Fruitvale Station gets anything I think it will only be a nod for Michael B. Jordan. And with so many potentials for best actor I believe he will be pushed out of the running. The same way Shailene Woodley was two years ago.

Email Updates