Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Review: Supernatural Thriller '+1' Is Not A Party You'll Want To Be Invited To

by Gabe Toro
September 22, 2013 11:04 AM
  • |

It’s the end of the world and the kids can’t stop partying in “+1,” the new horror whatzit from director Dennis Iliadis. Not that you’d know it from the reactions of the characters involved in this slightly off-center genre picture's young partygoers who may or may not be emblematic of the youth of today. When it’s emphasized that there is danger afoot, their drunken cries to keep the music playing bellow in unison. God help us if Iliadis actually does have his finger on the pulse of Generation iPod, or whatever they’re ironically (post-ironically?) calling themselves. And get them off our lawn.

Rhys Wakefield, last seen terrorizing the suburbs in “The Purge,” brings his rictus grin to the lead of this film, a semi-flat loverboy whom, we’re told later, can’t seem to find that extra motivation in life to exist beyond being a successful student who is really, terribly good looking. Wakefield is matched with Ashley Hinshaw, and the two look like they might as well be from different, but still good looking, universes: she is limber and model-pretty, and he has a positively Satanic grin that serves him better as an antagonist than as a likable lead character. It’s the kind of film that doesn’t pause for character-building until maybe thirty minutes in, and you have to spend the first third of the film wondering if Wakefield’s David is the villain.

After a hypnotic moment of infidelity that can’t be explained by simple logic, David finds himself on the outs with Hinshaw’s Jill, following her to a massive house party highlighted by an obscene amount of excess. There are the strippers on a giant outdoor stage! There is the nude Asian woman allowing everyone to eat food off her body! Let’s light a tennis ball on fire and bat it around! Either Iliadis is subtly critiquing American youth culture, or, more likely, he’s never actually experienced it. It’s unclear as to whether the film is operating on bizarre dream logic (that approaching asteroid can’t possibly be real, no?), or events are already subtly spiraling out of control.

Once that asteroid lands, David’s wooing strategy is interrupted by an unlikely threat: the partygoers are beginning to multiply, and doppelgängers have infiltrated the house, replaying events that occurred moments earlier. While these doubles appear to have murderous intentions, their main interest is mimicry, and they pull it off quite well. There’s a point to be made about the interchangeability of people at these massive college-age keggers (even before the doubling, there are about three separate chubby, fratty jerks clip-clopping through scenes like broken jalopies), but this film doesn’t have a single skilled comedic performer, nor does it have a particularly trenchant point of view or deeper observation.

The moments in between the sequences of violence and dread attempt to top every movie house party you’ve ever seen, a highlight being a particularly graphic sadomasochistic sex scene edited for maximum back-row titters. But the film is so po-faced that you wonder what the point of all this is, let alone what we should be hoping is the outcome. Struggling to bring gravity to the proceedings are Wakefield and Hinshaw, who give off the heat of two slabs of baloney slapped together. Even with a film loaded with unconvincing green-screen brawls where actors have to beat themselves up, it’s unusual that the most artificial element are the two people at the center of the film. By the time they are multiplied, it’s as if Iliadis is doubling down on the film’s weakest elements. [D]

  • |

More: Reviews, Review, Dennis Iliadis

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    


  • aaron | July 28, 2014 7:25 PMReply

    Honestly who is this jackwagon Gabe so and so, to have such a negative review in which he spells bologna wrong. Really classy chump.

  • Steam Team Carpet Cleaners NEPA | September 25, 2013 3:07 PMReply

    After a party like that is best to assume they'll need a good Carpet cleaning!

  • Bsupple601 | September 24, 2013 9:43 PMReply

    Any chance there are more then one Natalie Hall's aka Melanie sluttin it up at a party is a party that I want to be at!

    That kid was a tool runnin out on 2 identical Natalie Halls 1 wearing nothing the other wearing a towel..

  • Lana | September 22, 2013 12:56 PMReply

    Alison is not played by Lauren Ambrose. She is played by two actresses who are twins. Their names are Colleen and Suzanne Dengel. You should do your research more thoroughly next time.
    The two actresses we're great in the film.

Email Updates