Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Sacha Baron Cohen Reportedly Returning To Write, Produce, Star In & Direct The Freddie Mercury Biopic Sacha Baron Cohen Reportedly Returning To Write, Produce, Star In & Direct The Freddie Mercury Biopic Watch: James Bond Is Back In First Trailer For 'Spectre' Starring Daniel Craig, Lea Seydoux, Dave Bautista, & More Watch: James Bond Is Back In First Trailer For 'Spectre' Starring Daniel Craig, Lea Seydoux, Dave Bautista, & More Terrence Malick's Next Film With Ryan Gosling, Rooney Mara & Michael Fassbender Reportedly Gets Titled Terrence Malick's Next Film With Ryan Gosling, Rooney Mara & Michael Fassbender Reportedly Gets Titled Watch: Jake Gyllenhaal Gets Bloody And Bruised In First Trailer For Boxing Drama 'Southpaw' Watch: Jake Gyllenhaal Gets Bloody And Bruised In First Trailer For Boxing Drama 'Southpaw' New Infographic Lays Out Canonical 'Star Wars' Timeline With Films, TV And Books New Infographic Lays Out Canonical 'Star Wars' Timeline With Films, TV And Books First Official Image: Jesse Eisenberg As Lex Luthor In 'Batman v Superman: Dawn Of Justice' First Official Image: Jesse Eisenberg As Lex Luthor In 'Batman v Superman: Dawn Of Justice' Watch: First Trailer For Arnold Schwarzenegger's Zombie Pic 'Maggie' With Abigail Breslin Watch: First Trailer For Arnold Schwarzenegger's Zombie Pic 'Maggie' With Abigail Breslin Idris Elba Replaces Jamie Foxx In Harmony Korine's 'The Trap,' Al Pacino, Robert Pattinson, James Franco Also Join Idris Elba Replaces Jamie Foxx In Harmony Korine's 'The Trap,' Al Pacino, Robert Pattinson, James Franco Also Join Watch: Explore The Loneliness Of Sofia Coppola's Films With This Supercut Watch: Explore The Loneliness Of Sofia Coppola's Films With This Supercut 10 Terrible Films Starring Great Actors 10 Terrible Films Starring Great Actors Watch: Tom Hanks Acts Out His Filmography In 7-Minutes On 'The Late Late Show' Watch: Tom Hanks Acts Out His Filmography In 7-Minutes On 'The Late Late Show' Watch: Trailer For 'Fifty Shades Of Grey' Unrated Blu-Ray Edition, Will Also Feature An Alternate Ending Watch: Trailer For 'Fifty Shades Of Grey' Unrated Blu-Ray Edition, Will Also Feature An Alternate Ending New Directors/New Films Review: Jia Zhang-ke Produced 'K' Is A New Take On Franz Kafka's 'The Castle' New Directors/New Films Review: Jia Zhang-ke Produced 'K' Is A New Take On Franz Kafka's 'The Castle' The 25 Best Animated Films Of The 21st Century So Far The 25 Best Animated Films Of The 21st Century So Far The 25 Best Films Of 2015 We've Already Seen The 25 Best Films Of 2015 We've Already Seen Best Of 2014: The 15 Best Movie Soundtracks Of 2014 Best Of 2014: The 15 Best Movie Soundtracks Of 2014 The 25 Best Horror Films Of The 21st Century So Far The 25 Best Horror Films Of The 21st Century So Far The 20 Best TV Shows Of The 2013/2014 Season The 20 Best TV Shows Of The 2013/2014 Season From Worst To Best: Ranking The Films Of Hayao Miyazaki From Worst To Best: Ranking The Films Of Hayao Miyazaki All The Songs In 'Pitch Perfect' Including La Roux, David Guetta, Azealia Banks, Nicki Minaj & More All The Songs In 'Pitch Perfect' Including La Roux, David Guetta, Azealia Banks, Nicki Minaj & More

Review: 'Black Butterflies' Showcases A Life Of Art Overshadowed By A Life Of Sensuality

The Playlist By Gabe Toro | The Playlist February 29, 2012 at 12:00PM

Cinema has endured through the years not because it's a good time, or because it's a concise, closed method of storytelling. The format endures because of its innate flexibility, utilizing sound and visuals with the natural storytelling techniques of writers and directors that allows for interpretations and re-interpretations of the very same ideas that shape our other art forms. Not to say it is hierarchically "better" or worse than literature, prose, poetry or illustrated artwork, but it is no less durable. This partly serves as the reason why filmmakers and audiences remain drawn to the dramatized lives of artists, such as Ingrid Jonker, the poet at the heart of "Black Butterflies," as the subject matter allows the medium to penetrate both creator and creation.
0
Black Butterflies

Cinema has endured through the years not because it's a good time, or because it's a concise, closed method of storytelling. The format endures because of its innate flexibility, utilizing sound and visuals with the natural storytelling techniques of writers and directors that allows for interpretations and re-interpretations of the very same ideas that shape our other art forms. Not to say it is hierarchically "better" or worse than literature, prose, poetry or illustrated artwork, but it is no less durable. This partly serves as the reason why filmmakers and audiences remain drawn to the dramatized lives of artists, such as Ingrid Jonker, the poet at the heart of "Black Butterflies," as the subject matter allows the medium to penetrate both creator and creation.

Jonker, a white Afrikaner, grew into an unprecedented upbringing underneath her father Abraham, a staunch apartheid ally and member of Parliament in the late '50s and early '60s. While Abraham extolled the virtues of a separatist lifestyle, Ingrid embraced a more liberal view towards her surroundings. The delicate nature of her own contradiction was living a life of privilege while remaining an outsider to both her father and the suffering masses. This was reflected through her work, poetry that served as a pinprick to the accusatory finger of Abraham and his administration. The issue with such direct insubordination, however, is that Abraham is also chairman of the committee of censorship for the arts.

Black Butterflies

The most vivid way to understand cinematic antagonists is to realize they're merely trying to keep their house in order, and Abraham, prejudices or none, has a responsibility to keep his job and his country moving smoothly. "Black Butterflies" never shifts organically from a story about drama into a story with drama, and director Pamela van der Oest refuses the ample opportunities to place the audience in this man's shoes. His opposition against his daughter isn't self-preservation, nor is it a struggle of ideals, but rather the function of a cruel man with noted disdain for his daughter's interest. Emotionally it works; it won't be hard to find an audience member who has felt slighted in their life's work by a family member. But with such rich stakes, it represents an emotional shortcut, particularly with Abraham played by the fiery, volatile Rutger Hauer.

Jonker is also brought to life by a powerful actor, in this case the exceptional Carice Van Houten of "Black Book." Steely and beautiful, Van Houten has the interrupted edge of a chipped pearl, brittle but with a sense of danger. Consistently defeated by her surroundings, the film's Ingrid is placed through the emotional wringer, trapped in relationships that test her emotions and her allegiance to her art. She is haunted, her search for paternal acceptance leading her into the arms of more forceful, wizened men.

Black Butterflies

The film is sadly never matched to the level of Van Houten's intensity, nor does it do much for Jonker's poetry. The pleasure of film capturing the intensity of the prose written by "the South African Sylvia Plath" is lost as the picture never engages in languid prose over didactic biopic moviemaking. Films about artists persist, but filmmakers lack the ego to sublimate and heavily incorporate the idea of a differing artform. At the opportunity to use Jonker's words to paint a mosiac, van der Oest attempts to draw a perfect straight line from the art to the artist, as if all artistic inspiration comes from a succession of saying "Eureka."

"Black Butterflies" is very naturally drawn to the beauty of Van Houten's face and figure, but also to the lust inspired by her struggles and her partners. The movie's Ingrid mixes her torrid affairs with a breakdown and a stay at a psychiatric institute, spiking her sexual encounters with a sense of danger that keeps the film uncomfortably (and sometimes comfortably) heated. The picture stakes its tone in the words of Miss Jonker, but seems far more at ease with ripping open shirts as bodies, like waves, collapse into each other on the beach. It's an intense, mostly effective approach, but the film simply can't decide whether it's the passion for the pen, or the hunger for the flesh that properly motivates Jonker, trapping the film in an endless loop of melodrama. [C+]

This article is related to: Review, Carice van Houten, Rutger Hauer


The Playlist

The obsessives' guide to contemporary cinema via film discussion, news, reviews, features, nostalgia, movie music, soundtracks, DVDs and more.


Check out Indiewire on LockerDome on LockerDome

E-Mail Updates