Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Ryan Gosling To Star In 'Blade Runner 2' Ryan Gosling To Star In 'Blade Runner 2' Watch: New Trailer For 'Star Wars: The Force Awakens' Flies Into The Galaxy Watch: New Trailer For 'Star Wars: The Force Awakens' Flies Into The Galaxy Watch: First Teaser Trailer For Quentin Tarantino's 'The Hateful Eight' Watch: First Teaser Trailer For Quentin Tarantino's 'The Hateful Eight' 'Macbeth,' Todd Haynes' 'Carol,' Pixar's 'Inside Out' Lead 2015 Cannes Film Festival Line-Up 'Macbeth,' Todd Haynes' 'Carol,' Pixar's 'Inside Out' Lead 2015 Cannes Film Festival Line-Up Watch: Zack Snyder Teases The Full Trailer For ‘Batman V. Superman: Dawn Of Justice' & Upcoming IMAX Event Watch: Zack Snyder Teases The Full Trailer For ‘Batman V. Superman: Dawn Of Justice' & Upcoming IMAX Event Ryan Gosling & Edgar Wright Talk 'Lost River,' Shooting In Detroit, And Advice For First Time Filmmakers Ryan Gosling & Edgar Wright Talk 'Lost River,' Shooting In Detroit, And Advice For First Time Filmmakers Netflix & Marvel's 'Daredevil': The Pros, The Cons, The Verdict Netflix & Marvel's 'Daredevil': The Pros, The Cons, The Verdict Netflix's 'Daredevil' Is An Awesome Achievement And Marvel's Most Graphic & Grounded Effort To Date Netflix's 'Daredevil' Is An Awesome Achievement And Marvel's Most Graphic & Grounded Effort To Date Watch: Action-Packed Footage In 2 New “Avengers: Age of Ultron’ TV Spots, Plus Watch Interviews With The Entire Cast Watch: Action-Packed Footage In 2 New “Avengers: Age of Ultron’ TV Spots, Plus Watch Interviews With The Entire Cast Watch: Trailer For 'The Great Beauty' Director Paolo Sorrentino's 'Youth' Starring Michael Caine & Rachel Weisz Watch: Trailer For 'The Great Beauty' Director Paolo Sorrentino's 'Youth' Starring Michael Caine & Rachel Weisz Joss Whedon Says He's Not Making 'Avengers: Infinity War' Because It's "A Young Man’s Game" Joss Whedon Says He's Not Making 'Avengers: Infinity War' Because It's "A Young Man’s Game" Watch: Take 7 Minutes And Learn The History Of Film Editing Watch: Take 7 Minutes And Learn The History Of Film Editing 'Avengers: Age Of Ultron' Called "Amazing" And "More Emotional" With "Insane Action" After First Screening 'Avengers: Age Of Ultron' Called "Amazing" And "More Emotional" With "Insane Action" After First Screening Joss Whedon Calls 'Jurassic World' Clip "70s Era Sexist" Joss Whedon Calls 'Jurassic World' Clip "70s Era Sexist" The 20 Most Anticipated Films Of The 2015 Tribeca Film Festival The 20 Most Anticipated Films Of The 2015 Tribeca Film Festival The 25 Best Films Of 2015 We've Already Seen The 25 Best Films Of 2015 We've Already Seen Best Of 2014: The 15 Best Movie Soundtracks Of 2014 Best Of 2014: The 15 Best Movie Soundtracks Of 2014 The 25 Best Horror Films Of The 21st Century So Far The 25 Best Horror Films Of The 21st Century So Far The 20 Best TV Shows Of The 2013/2014 Season The 20 Best TV Shows Of The 2013/2014 Season From Worst To Best: Ranking The Films Of Hayao Miyazaki From Worst To Best: Ranking The Films Of Hayao Miyazaki

Review: 'If A Tree Falls: A Story Of The Earth Liberation Front' Is A Compelling Eco-Terrorism Doc

Photo of Drew Taylor By Drew Taylor | The Playlist June 21, 2011 at 3:26AM

Of all the "issue" documentaries that have come out in the past few years about our environment, one that hasn't been broached, in any kind of thorough way, has been eco-terrorism. Part of this undoubtedly has to do with the propagation of the image of environmentalists as peace-loving, hippy dippy folks who would rather hold up signs and play hacky sack (while on break from Hampshire College) than burn out a building or engage in Palahniuk-ian fits of mischief and violent rebellion. But an even bigger reason why the subject hasn't been tackled in any kind of in-depth way must surely be the thorny, morally complicated issue of eco-terrorism; at times their aims are understandable and their tactics not much different than those they're rallying against, but there's an intensity to their methods that leaves some feeling uncomfortable, and anything involving the word "terrorist" is a tough sell.
0


Of all the "issue" documentaries that have come out in the past few years about our environment, one that hasn't been broached, in any kind of thorough way, has been eco-terrorism. Part of this undoubtedly has to do with the propagation of the image of environmentalists as peace-loving, hippy dippy folks who would rather hold up signs and play hacky sack (while on break from Hampshire College) than burn out a building or engage in Palahniuk-ian fits of mischief and violent rebellion. But an even bigger reason why the subject hasn't been tackled in any kind of in-depth way must surely be the thorny, morally complicated issue of eco-terrorism; at times their aims are understandable and their tactics not much different than those they're rallying against, but there's an intensity to their methods that leaves some feeling uncomfortable, and anything involving the word "terrorist" is a tough sell.

What Marshall Curry's uneven but ultimately rewarding "If A Tree Falls" tries to do, admirably, is attack the issue from all sides while chronicling the very personal ordeal of Daniel McGowan, by all accounts a cherubically mild-mannered citizen who was seized by the F.B.I. and charged with eco-terrorism acts committed a half-decade before. (Curry explains, in an unnecessary voice over, that McGowan worked in the same office as Curry's wife and that she saw him getting hauled off by the feds.)

From there the movie follows a more biographical path, as McGowan, under house arrest at his sister's Manhattan apartment while awaiting trial, explains how he was exposed to various environmental concerns in the 1990s, indoctrinated with cult-like zeal into the Earth Liberation Front, a militarized, highly secretive group that began in the Pacific Northwest and had cells all over the country, ultimately claiming responsibility for hundreds of incidents of arson and property damage.

It's a fascinating subject matter, for sure, and the roly-poly McGowan is the greatest audience surrogate you could have wanted for this kind of thing, as you watch his idealism curdle into something more violent and ultimately into a kind of somber regret, as he faces decades in federal prison if he is convicted. (With even harsher restrictions because his crimes were grouped as terrorist attacks.) You go along with his story, and his reasons for first being part of peaceful protests and then transitioning to more serious acts, partially because what he was rebelling against is so heinous (acres of wild forest, gone) and partially because there was both an intellectualized seriousness and an impish sense of joy that accompanied the attacks, both of which seem intoxicating in their own rights. Occasionally McGowan's causes seem silly and border on zealotry (a family member recounts a recycling frenzy that led McGowan to remove all of the labels on all of the cans in her cupboard, leaving them unidentifiable and useless), but it helps with the overall tone of the movie, which is even-keeled and never overtly incendiary.

Curry, an accomplished but inelegant filmmaker, does a good job of talking to as many people as he possibly can, including giving a fairly even-handed portrait to some of the victims of the attacks (mostly logging companies and a site that was supposedly introducing genetically modified trees into the environment but in actuality wasn't). Sometimes the, for lack of a better word, coolness of environmental terrorism, including the specifics of a number of the operations, is glazed over or rendered too dry and academically procedural (probably because, as admirable as the participants come off, the documentary is quick to remind viewers that burning down buildings is a very bad thing indeed), but the strength of McGowan as a character is undeniable and the punishment for the crimes ultimately comes across as unjust and lopsided. You'll be thinking about it for a long time after it ends, even if you're unsure of the validity of both the eco-terror actions and the stringency that the F.B.I. dealt with the crimes. The documentary, at the very least, answers the lingering question of what the Bush administration was up to instead of finding Bin Laden or regulating anything – they were coming after people who were wrapped up in activism and got in over their heads a decade before. Way to go, guys. [A-]

This article is related to: Review


The Playlist

The obsessives' guide to contemporary cinema via film discussion, news, reviews, features, nostalgia, movie music, soundtracks, DVDs and more.


E-Mail Updates