Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Fantastic Fest Review: Hitman Thriller 'John Wick' Starring Keanu Reeves, Willem Dafoe & Adrianne Palicki Fantastic Fest Review: Hitman Thriller 'John Wick' Starring Keanu Reeves, Willem Dafoe & Adrianne Palicki Watch: First Trailer For Tim Burton's 'Big  Eyes' Starring Amy Adams And Christoph Waltz Watch: First Trailer For Tim Burton's 'Big Eyes' Starring Amy Adams And Christoph Waltz 'Deadpool’ Spin-Off With Ryan Reynolds Is Finally Green Lit, Set For A Winter 2016 Release Date 'Deadpool’ Spin-Off With Ryan Reynolds Is Finally Green Lit, Set For A Winter 2016 Release Date First Look: Cobie Smulders & Guy Pearce In Andrew Bujalski's 'Results' First Look: Cobie Smulders & Guy Pearce In Andrew Bujalski's 'Results' 10 Films We Haven’t Yet Seen That May Be Serious Oscar Contenders 10 Films We Haven’t Yet Seen That May Be Serious Oscar Contenders Review: 'The Maze Runner' Starring Dylan O'Brien, Kaya Scodelario, Patricia Clarkson, Will Poulter And More Review: 'The Maze Runner' Starring Dylan O'Brien, Kaya Scodelario, Patricia Clarkson, Will Poulter And More Exclusive: Matthew McConaughey Won’t Be Back For ‘Magic Mike XXL,’ Director Says Sequel Will Be “Very Different” Exclusive: Matthew McConaughey Won’t Be Back For ‘Magic Mike XXL,’ Director Says Sequel Will Be “Very Different” David Fincher Says He Shouldn't Have Directed 'The Game,' Dislikes Superhero Movies & Talks "Crazy" '20,000 Leagues' David Fincher Says He Shouldn't Have Directed 'The Game,' Dislikes Superhero Movies & Talks "Crazy" '20,000 Leagues' Matt Damon & Paul Greengrass Are Returning To The 'Bourne' Series Matt Damon & Paul Greengrass Are Returning To The 'Bourne' Series First Look: Angelina Jolie And Brad Pitt In 'By The Sea' First Look: Angelina Jolie And Brad Pitt In 'By The Sea' The Best, Worst And Most Disappointing Films Of The 2014 Toronto International Film Festival The Best, Worst And Most Disappointing Films Of The 2014 Toronto International Film Festival David Fincher Says Differences Over Casting And Disney's Corporate Culture Stalled '20,000 Leagues Under The Sea' David Fincher Says Differences Over Casting And Disney's Corporate Culture Stalled '20,000 Leagues Under The Sea' Recap: 'Boardwalk Empire' Season 5, Episode 2 ‘The Good Listener’ Recap: 'Boardwalk Empire' Season 5, Episode 2 ‘The Good Listener’ Review: 'No Good Deed' Starring Idris Elba and Taraji P. Henson Review: 'No Good Deed' Starring Idris Elba and Taraji P. Henson Tom Hardy Says He'll Never Do Another Romantic Comedy Again Thanks To 'This Means War' Tom Hardy Says He'll Never Do Another Romantic Comedy Again Thanks To 'This Means War' The Best Documentaries Of 2014 So Far The Best Documentaries Of 2014 So Far The 20 Best TV Shows Of The 2013/2014 Season The 20 Best TV Shows Of The 2013/2014 Season The Best Films Of 2014 So Far... The Best Films Of 2014 So Far... The 10 Best & Worst Movie Sex Scenes The 10 Best & Worst Movie Sex Scenes All The Songs In 'Pitch Perfect' Including La Roux, David Guetta, Azealia Banks, Nicki Minaj & More All The Songs In 'Pitch Perfect' Including La Roux, David Guetta, Azealia Banks, Nicki Minaj & More

Review: 'Mann V. Ford' A One-Dimensional Tale Of Bittersweet Justice Served

The Playlist By Kevin Jagernauth | The Playlist July 18, 2011 at 1:59AM

What kind of price tag do you put on justice after decades of being harassed, abused, ignored and victimized by big business and government alike, whose actions have devastated a community and a way of life that will never be the same again? Can justice ever truly be served and what shape will it take? Those are the central questions that co-directors Maro Chermayeff and Micah Fink endeavor to answer with "Mann v. Ford" a well-intentioned, but fundamentally flawed film that takes us elbow-deep into the shocking and heartbreaking titular case, which results when the Ramapough Mountain Indians -- longtime residents of Ringwood, N.J. -- find their people ravaged with cancer and other illnesses after it's discovered that Ford used their land as dumping ground for toxic waste in the late '60s and early '70s.
16


What kind of price tag do you put on justice after decades of being harassed, abused, ignored and victimized by big business and government alike, whose actions have devastated a community and a way of life that will never be the same again? Can justice ever truly be served and what shape will it take? Those are the central questions that co-directors Maro Chermayeff and Micah Fink endeavor to answer with "Mann v. Ford" a well-intentioned, but fundamentally flawed film that takes us elbow-deep into the shocking and heartbreaking titular case, which results when the Ramapough Mountain Indians -- longtime residents of Ringwood, N.J. -- find their people ravaged with cancer and other illnesses after it's discovered that Ford used their land as dumping ground for toxic waste in the late '60s and early '70s.

With a history stretching back well over a hundred years, the Ramapough are a close-knit and insular group that drew tighter as the world around them cast them in the roles of inbreeders, thieves and generally a northern version of the worst Ozarks-type people served up since "Deliverance." And thus, as the community children began to develop strange symptoms from playing with the dumped paint sludge -- often using it slide down hills or make colorful mud pies as kids are wont to do -- the village elders, out of fear of the reaction they might get if they brought it to the authorities and a little wilful ignorance too, turned a blind eye to what they were seeing. But those symptoms soon became deadly diseases and the damage being done to both to the environment and to the the Ramapough was worse than anyone could have imagined.


Enter Vicki Gilliam, lawyer at the The Cochran Firm in Memphis, Tennessee who is hired by Wayne Mann to represent his people in a class action lawsuit against the car manufacturer. Pairing up with a few other firms to share the workload and expense, Gilliam begins pulling together the details of the case that will include over 600 plaintiffs and a web of malfeasance that seems to get worse each day the case moves forward. While Ford's complicity is pretty much confirmed by their own damning internal memos, which not only reveal their full knowledge about the dumping that occurred at the time, they also demonstrate overt racism against the very people they were affecting. In short, they didn't care and they were pretty sure no one else would either. But the failings didn't stop there. Perhaps even more galling, the Environmental Protection Agency declared the area a Superfund site -- one in desperate need of cleanup -- only to literally pour a bunch of rocks over the problem and announce it was "safe." In fact, it was still so badly polluted that the community rallied and succeeded in having their neighborhood relisted as a Superfund site (something that is rarely done) but the damage was done and the hope that their own government would step in to help quickly gave way to easy cynicism.

In case it isn't already apparent, "Mann V. Ford" will make your stomach churn in outrage and your heart ache in sympathy. However, the filmmakers are hampered by an approach that almost never steps outside the viewpoint of the Ramapough and their supporters. This isn't to impugn the accuracy of their evaluation of the devastating toll Ford's actions have taken, but from a cinematic perspective, without the participation of anybody from the carmaker (they declined to be interviewed for the film) or even the EPA (they appear in a few brief scenes), "Mann V. Ford" quickly becomes one-note and at times drifts into being strident. With repeated mini-screeds against Evil Big Business and their attention on the bottom line versus human rights, the film takes on an amateurishly political bend at times that's better suited to idealists in dorm rooms than a measured, level-headed film. And as an indication of perhaps how starved the directors were for material, the middle of the film takes a detour and creates a mini-documentary about Gilliam's journey to becoming a lawyer. It's a fascinating story but it has little to no bearing on the tremendous legal action that is being put forth.

As the doc moves into its second half, it simply begins notching timestamps in the decades-spanning case, with more and more details emerging not only painting a better picture of just how nearly everyone in the Ramapough has suffered sickness but also how much of this mess came from the decision-makers at Ford. A suggestion is floated that the EPA is actually run/lobbied by Ford and other industry folk who influence their findings but it never goes beyond suspicion. Likewise, a thread involving Lisa Jackson -- a supposed champion of the Ramapough and President Obama's choice to head up the EPA is his administration following the election -- ends up unresolved with no followup after she is sworn in.

Justice does eventually arrive, but it's a bittersweet moment because it ultimately does nothing to bring back those lost or to replace the void they left behind. Overlong, repetitive and not as investigative as it could have or should have been, "Mann V. Ford" can be admired for giving a voice to the Ramapough, but in doing so, Chermayeff and Fink make sure it's the only voice you hear, to the detriment of the film. [C]

"Mann v. Ford" premieres on HBO tonight at 9 PM.

This article is related to: Review


The Playlist

The obsessives' guide to contemporary cinema via film discussion, news, reviews, features, nostalgia, movie music, soundtracks, DVDs and more.


E-Mail Updates