Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
2015 Tribeca Film Festival Line-Up Announced: James Franco’s ‘Adderall Diaries,’ Olivia Wilde In ‘Meadowland’ & More 2015 Tribeca Film Festival Line-Up Announced: James Franco’s ‘Adderall Diaries,’ Olivia Wilde In ‘Meadowland’ & More First Look: Joseph Gordon-Levitt As Edward Snowden In Oliver Stone's 'Snowden' First Look: Joseph Gordon-Levitt As Edward Snowden In Oliver Stone's 'Snowden' Drew Goddard To Write And Direct Sony & Marvel's 'The Spectacular Spider-Man'; 'Sinister Six' Scrapped Drew Goddard To Write And Direct Sony & Marvel's 'The Spectacular Spider-Man'; 'Sinister Six' Scrapped Premature Oscar Predictions: The 2016 Best Picture Contenders Premature Oscar Predictions: The 2016 Best Picture Contenders Watch: Original Short Film Version Of 'Whiplash' Starring Oscar Winner J.K. Simmons Watch: Original Short Film Version Of 'Whiplash' Starring Oscar Winner J.K. Simmons Watch: Nifty Video Examines David Fincher’s Subtle Repetition Of Framing And Blocking In 'Gone Girl' Watch: Nifty Video Examines David Fincher’s Subtle Repetition Of Framing And Blocking In 'Gone Girl' Sigourney Weaver Says She'll Be Playing A New Character In The 'Avatar' Sequels Sigourney Weaver Says She'll Be Playing A New Character In The 'Avatar' Sequels Margot Robbie Says 'Suicide Squad' Is More 'The Dark Knight' Than 'Avengers'; David Ayer Says Joker Is "Majestic" Margot Robbie Says 'Suicide Squad' Is More 'The Dark Knight' Than 'Avengers'; David Ayer Says Joker Is "Majestic" Kristen Stewart Joins Kelly Reichardt’s Untitled Montana Drama With Michelle Williams & More Kristen Stewart Joins Kelly Reichardt’s Untitled Montana Drama With Michelle Williams & More Watch: Paul Thomas Anderson's Sophomore Short 'Cigarettes & Coffee' Watch: Paul Thomas Anderson's Sophomore Short 'Cigarettes & Coffee' Another Oscar? First Look At Eddie Redmayne In Tom Hooper's 'The Danish Girl' Another Oscar? First Look At Eddie Redmayne In Tom Hooper's 'The Danish Girl' 'Prisoners' & 'Enemy' Director Denis Villeneuve To Helm 'Blade Runner' Sequel, Harrison Ford Confirmed To Return 'Prisoners' & 'Enemy' Director Denis Villeneuve To Helm 'Blade Runner' Sequel, Harrison Ford Confirmed To Return The 50 Best Films Of The Decade So Far The 50 Best Films Of The Decade So Far "I F*cked It Up": Neill Blomkamp Says He Wants To Go Back To 'Elysium' And "Do It Correctly" "I F*cked It Up": Neill Blomkamp Says He Wants To Go Back To 'Elysium' And "Do It Correctly" New Looks At Daniel Craig, Dave Bautista, And Lea Seydoux In 'Spectre' New Looks At Daniel Craig, Dave Bautista, And Lea Seydoux In 'Spectre' The 25 Best Films Of 2015 We've Already Seen The 25 Best Films Of 2015 We've Already Seen Best Of 2014: The 15 Best Movie Soundtracks Of 2014 Best Of 2014: The 15 Best Movie Soundtracks Of 2014 The 25 Best Horror Films Of The 21st Century So Far The 25 Best Horror Films Of The 21st Century So Far The 20 Best TV Shows Of The 2013/2014 Season The 20 Best TV Shows Of The 2013/2014 Season From Worst To Best: Ranking The Films Of Hayao Miyazaki From Worst To Best: Ranking The Films Of Hayao Miyazaki

Rome Review: '1942' Is A Long, Old-Fashioned But Absorbing Epic Of Chinese Historical Cinema

The Playlist By Jessica Kiang | The Playlist November 17, 2012 at 7:02PM

If the appropriate length of a film were calculated in proportion to the scope of its subject, all 144 minutes of Feng Xiaogang's "1942" (also known as "Back to 1942"), which played In Competition at the Rome Film Festival, would be wholly justified. While the Henan Famine of the early 1940s is not a well-known tragedy outside China, the scale of the suffering, death and displacement it caused simply boggles the mind, the numbers are so colossal. And for the most part, Feng does an impressive job of memorializing the 3 million dead; "1942" is not an unqualified success, but it did retain our interest and engagement across its multiple story lines and over its expansive running time.
5

Back to 1942
Back to 1942
If the appropriate length of a film were calculated in proportion to the scope of its subject, all 144 minutes of Feng Xiaogang's "1942" (also known as "Back to 1942"), which played In Competition at the Rome Film Festival, would be wholly justified. While the Henan Famine of the early 1940s is not a well-known tragedy outside China, the scale of the suffering, death and displacement it caused simply boggles the mind, the numbers are so colossal. And for the most part, Feng does an impressive job of memorializing the 3 million dead; "1942" is not an unqualified success, but it did retain our interest and engagement across its multiple story lines and over its expansive running time.

Back to 1942, Adrien Brody

The main narrative concerns Fan (Zhang Guoli), a wealthy landlord in Henan Province, which is already in the throes of poverty and famine, with crop failures, locust infestations and the ever-hungry machine of war all contributing to a terrible scarcity of food. Early on, we are thrown into an alien world; Chinese society in the 1940s seems to operate on such a medieval level of feudalism that the appearance of a bicycle came as a shock and seemed momentarily an anachronism. Fan may be the lord of this tiny fiefdom, but when a group of bandits, grown desperate by hunger, lay siege demanding food, events quickly spiral until the village is torched and the meagre stores raided. The inhabitants, including Fan and his family, set out on a long and merciless journey whose destination changes as city after town turns out not to be a place of refuge, but the site of more suffering. The long column of carts and wagons and stumbling, ragged pedestrians becomes shorter and sparser as hunger and cold claim lives, and soon, whole families. Landlord Fan himself is gradually brought low, stripped first of the trappings of relative wealth not by jealous citizens but by the Chinese army who are sweeping through the region on their way to the Japanese front and who commandeer everything they can get their hands on in the name of the war effort. But worldly good are not all Fan loses, one by one his family and friends are taken, some selling themselves into presumed prostitution if it means they'll be fed, but most dying of sickness, lack of food, or in the terrifying Japanese bombing raids. 

In fact the drawn-out agony of Fan's personal tragedy might seem overblown or exaggerated, were it not again for the fact that the sheer numbers involved here have to mean that stories like his were all too common. But we do look away from him, once in a while. Against the backdrop of the immensity of the crisis, other stories are told. Adrien Brody's Time reporter visits the front lines and then plays a vital role in getting official China to finally recognize the need for aid to the affected area. Less narratively necessary, Tim Robbins also shows up for a few scenes as a Catholic priest in the region whose accent is almost as nomadic as the refugees. And the set pieces, when they come, are impressive and immense. Feng did not get to be China's most commercially successful director without knowing how to shoot spectacular action, and the scenes of the bombing of the refugee column by the Japanese are visceral, shocking and bloody.

Back to 1942

Some have complained of the film's lack of emotional connection, and while there is a certain reserve, we felt it worked in its favor to restrain what could otherwise become histrionic. To us, a more serious issue has to do with our own lack of knowledge in this area: how much of the political side of the film should we take as propaganda, and how much fact? With the two U.S. stars clearly included to help sell the film overseas (Brody's character is quite meta in that regard; his dedicated reporter is also trying to get the West to take notice of China) we can see the hand of manipulation in how positively these Westerners are portrayed. And of course, Japan is portrayed as the evil empire, but no more so than we have seen in American films before now. But was the story around Chiang Kai Shek (Chen Daoming) deliberatley designed to show the (not inhuman but certainly politically pragmatic) Generalissimo as the head of a corrupt system of bickering toadies who valued their positions and their status in the eyes of their superiors over the welfare of those they were supposed to represent? Because, of course, the more unjust and unfeeling a political system, the more heroic and justified the one that replaces it… We'd love to know what subtle messages, if any, the home audience read into the film.

But we're getting off the point. Politics aside, there can be no doubt about the preventable deaths of millions of ordinary people during that ruinous famine. And "1942" while perhaps never packing the emotive gut punch of "Schindler's List" or "Bridge on the River Kwai" nonetheless kept us engaged in an old-fashioned epic style, in a story of a monumental tragedy they we're ashamed to say we knew little of beforehand. It is not perfect, but we're glad it's there to even partially redress our ignorance. [B]

This article is related to: Back to 1942, Feng Xiaogang, Rome Film Festival, Adrien Brody, Review


The Playlist

The obsessives' guide to contemporary cinema via film discussion, news, reviews, features, nostalgia, movie music, soundtracks, DVDs and more.


Check out Indiewire on LockerDome on LockerDome

E-Mail Updates