5. Jackie Earle Haley in "Dark Shadows"
Everyone's favorite Tiger Beat heartthrob, Jackie Earle Haley, graced not one, but two one-sheets for "Dark Shadows," each as pointless as the other. Presumably this came out of contractual obligation or something?

Dark Shadows Jackie Earle Haley character poster 1
Dark Shadows Jackie Earle Haley poster 2 skip crop