The Assessment: Luc Besson's Directorial Career In 7 Films

Features
by The Playlist Staff
September 18, 2013 2:34 PM
9 Comments
  • |
"I always follow my instinct," writer/producer/director Luc Besson told us in interview last week in regards to his choice of directorial projects. But just where has that instinct led him? He's a fascinating filmmaker, not exclusively for the films he makes but also for the career decisions he's made along the way, puzzling many onlookers. He started out as an indie darling, making stylistic, often visceral and even arty action films that were infused with his love of American genre films, comic books, and music videos. Intelligent, left of center and shot through with a distinctly European sensibility for all their U.S. influence, these early works were a rare breed of critically respectable action film. Soon the Frenchman was essentially known as a modern auteur, and one with a hip, young edge. 

But that period of his career didn't last. At some point Besson ditched his authorial badge and began trying his hand elsewhere, first embracing a populist streak and enjoying a period of mainstream Hollywood success, then moving on to a string of French animated "Arthur and the Invisibles" films for children (only the first of which got released in the U.S.). More recently, Besson has returned to his stylish action roots and, like Roger Corman in a beret, has transformed himself into the CEO of a cottage industry of Euro-trashy action films (most of which he conceives of, writes and produces, but does not direct). Last week, in a bid to recapture something more in the vein of say, “Léon,” than “The Transporter 3,” he returned as the co-writer and director of “The Family,” starring Robert De Niro and Michelle Pfeiffer, a mob comedy that liberally mixes extreme violence, melodrama and awkward situational laughs. Like Besson in his heyday, it’s an uneven balance of elements, but here that doesn't necessarily pay off (read our review). 

Still, it was enough to get us thinking about the rest of Besson’s career — how he parlayed his directorial success into the mini-empire he has since created, how he made the move from "savior of entertaining European fare" (even being listed as one of a few French filmmakers spearheading a movement in the '80s called cinema du look) to "exclusive purveyor of above-average B-movie cheese" and how likely it is that he'll ever be able to go back again. Maybe, after being heralded as important, the director shied away from the label, intent on forging a more lucrative path for himself (as the man behind the incredibly successful “Taken” series, it’s paid off well). But after all this time, it's debatable as to whether he can regain that early level of respect -- even when he makes a bid for importance, as with recent Aung San Suu Kyi biopic, "The Lady," the critical response has been less than rapturous, and audiences have stayed away. 

His has been a rollercoaster journey, and so rather than just do a "Best of" we’ve created The Assessment -- in which we take a sampling of representative projects from the better- and lesser-known portions of a career, and use them to tell the story of a filmmaker. In a career with as many highs and lows, peaks and valleys as this one, it wasn't an easy task, but here we go with a whistle-stop tour through Luc Besson's directorial career.

"Subway" (1985)
Just two years after his feature debut, "Le Dernier Combat," a nearly dialogue-free black-and-white post-apocalyptic tale that brought Besson quite some success on the international festival circuit, he made "Subway," which, while it nodding to the spartan minimalist narrative of his first movie, is stylistically a much clearer signpost of where he'd be going in the future. Imbued with a punkish, kinetic aesthetic, from the hairdos to the synthy score (by frequent Besson collaborator Eric Serra, who also takes a small role), it's true that the things that made it feel so hip and edgy at the time are the very elements that date the film now. But there is undeniable filmmaking bravado at play here including Besson's ability to find a garish sort of glamor in the lives of his disenfranchised, largely subterranean heroes, and injecting a kind of manic energy into even this most illogical and incoherent of stories, something that endures through his movies to this day. 

Christopher Lambert plays Fred, a handsome, bleached-blonde drifter type who, on the run from the henchmen of a gangster from whom he stole some documents, and from the police, takes refuge in the cavernous and mazelike Paris Metro, moving with ease and familiarity between its public and its forbidden spaces. Tracked down by the gangster's moll Helena (Isabelle Adjani, whose gorgeousness overcomes even the ruffliest of 80s frou-frou concoctions) whom Fred has already fallen for, the film then devolves into a series of chases and interludes as Fred's accomplices -- notably Jean-Hughes Anglade as a rollerskating pickpocket and Jean Reno as a drummer who refuses to be named -- themselves have run ins with the various pursuers, all while Fred is trying to marshal together a rock band out of the disparate collection of buskers who work the tunnels. Nodding directly to Godard's "Breathless," we can also certainly detect a kinship with the following year's "Mauvais Sang" from Leos Carax (not to mention his 1991 film "The Lovers on the Bridge") in the portrayal of a marginalised society driven literally underground and in the idea of star-crossed lovers rejecting a bourgeois life in favor of something freer and less encumbered. But let's not overstate Besson's impulses as a social commentator, whatever the political content, there is a certain irony present, a kind of winkiness that indicates Besson is not taking it all too seriously, and nor should we -- an element that foreshadows his later career in pure popcorn. Nonetheless, while hardly a classic, "Subway" was a calling card for something very exciting at the time: a fusing of the nihilist French tradition with a poppy, punky, trashy vibe. If every generation needs a new expression of rebellion, it felt, for a few years at least, like the young people of Mitterand's '80s France might have found it with "Subway," Besson and his ilk.

"Nikita" (1990)
With a black-and-white, mostly silent post-apocalyptic war movie, a subterranean punk-rock odyssey and a languid, heavily fictionalized based-on-a-true-story diving movie ("The Big Blue") under his belt, Besson had become a director to watch: he was stylish, energetic and seemingly totally unafraid to change it up completely from one film to the next. He was happy to cross boundaries and mix genres, with his films fluctuating wildly between earnest melodrama and a kind of arch expressiveness. But it was "Nikita" in 1990 that really put Besson on the map: and it's probably still the film that best exemplifies a "Luc Besson movie" if there really is such a thing, foreshadowing all his guns'n'gals Hollywood films, and also the quasi-exploitational phase of his later producing career, while still retaining an independent's eye for character. In the first fifteen minutes of "Nikita," we see an economy of narrative that Besson has yet to recapture in any of his later films, as a young junkie (Anne Parillaud) murders a policeman in the botched robbery of a pharmacy, is sentenced to life in prison, "dies" while detained, and wakes up in a secret spy organization known as The Centre. Here she's reborn as an assassin, under the tutelage of Bob (Tcheky Karyo).

"Nikita" was Besson's first real taste of U.S. success and though it met with mixed reviews both at home in France and elsewhere, it did well at the box office internationally, in direct contrast to his last film, "The Big Blue" which, rescored and recut, with a "happier" ending for the U.S., tanked just a couple of years prior despite its massive success at home. "Nikita," however, was a wonderfully sellable mix of foreign, subtitled prestige pic and down-and-dirty genre action film; it was hyperstylized, in an almost Tony Scott way (you can understand why it was a favorite of Quentin Tarantino's), but it did have a little more on its mind for those who wanted to look for it. Besson was clearly invested and interested in the emotional journey of the main character, and in the way that violence and femininity can coexist side by side (a thematic obsession that recurs regularly throughout his work). Perhaps more tellingly for Besson's future career, it has since shown its franchise-ability in inspiring an American remake (John Badham's decent "Point of No Return") and two popular television series, none of which, Besson claims, he received a red cent for. But more importantly, more than any of his films, it cemented Besson's particular talent as a writer/director who could mix popcorn entertainment with thornier thematic concerns and a singular point of view. How much he followed through on that promise, however, is a matter for debate.

"Léon" (1994)
If "Nikita" was the promise, then "Léon" was the delivery. Essentially, Besson took the Jean Reno character from "Nikita," a ruthless hitman who refers to himself as a "cleaner," and built an entire movie around him, giving an indelible role to his lucky charm actor as well as to the impossibly winsome Natalie Portman in the process. This cleaner lives and works in New York City, next door to a young girl, Mathilde (Natalie Portman) whom he reluctantly takes in after a corrupt DEA agent (Gary Oldman) guns down her entire family. He then teaches her the only thing he knows: how to kill and how to exact retribution for her murdered family. Since the film was English-language and highly accessible, it served as Besson's breakthrough for those who hadn't bothered with the artier, or at least more subtitled “Nikita.” Despite some of Besson's signature quirks shining through, and the borderline inappropriate relationship between the assassin and the young girl (while there are a couple of moments in the movie that give you pause, their connection seems to be emotional more than romantic) in a lot of ways “Léon” (released as the more anonymous “The Professional” in the U.S.) represents the peak of Besson’s abilities as a filmmaker – it’s cleanly told, boldly stylized, violent, emotional and, at its core, features a powerful young woman coming to terms with that power. It epitomizes his love of foreign art films and Hollywood action movies, all in one beautifully concise package, and it might be the best Gary Oldman bad guy role ever (which is really saying something). Even if you don’t appreciate Besson’s larger body of work, it’s hard not to love “Léon,” and it is certainly his most complete and most satisfying film to date. The mooted Portman-starring sequel never got off the ground, with Besson protege Olivier Megaton directing the similarly themed Zoe Saldana-starring, Besson-co-scripted "Colombiana" in 2011 instead, to vastly diminished returns. 

Features
  • |

More: Luc Besson, The Family, Features, Feature

You might also like:
Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

9 Comments

  • Brian Milne | September 21, 2013 9:11 PMReply

    Then I found this: http://blogs.smithsonianmag.com/paleofuture/2012/07/1927-magazine-looks-at-metropolis-a-movie-based-on-science/
    You might have to copy and paste the text into a word document to get around the infuriating add.

  • Brian Milne | September 21, 2013 8:43 PMReply

    When watching the 'The Fifth Element' take note or keep in mind that this film either references or copies scenes from ‘Metropolis’. Depending on your point of view on interrupting film. Which might make you re-think your interruption of the 'The Fifth Element'.

  • Liam | September 19, 2013 7:08 AMReply

    I love this guy ! Some of his movies are really unforgettable (Nikita, Leon & The Lady for me, love'em!) To be honest, I do find the fifth element's plot a little "childish" but I love that movie too, it's so freaking funny ! Oldman & Jovovich both give a great performance and the visuals are really nice & originals.

  • Timothy | September 18, 2013 11:26 PMReply

    La Femme Nikita is still Luc Besson's only good film in his filmography . Whatever happened to Anne Parillaud ? She had more sex appeal , acting talent , and charisma than Marion Cotillard .

  • HARVEY DENT | September 20, 2013 9:33 AM

    Anne Parillaud was in the dicaprio version of 'Man in The Iron Mask'

  • Northern Star | September 18, 2013 11:23 PMReply

    I have rarely been as depressed and as crushingly disappointed as coming out of the cinema having watched Besson's 'Joan of Arc' film... the thought of the director behind 'Leon' and 'The Fifth Element' handling a full-on historical epic was a mouth-watering prospect! Instead we got a slanderous and smer-filled hatchet job of a film with a shrieking and indescribably shrill Jovovich stinking up the joint with one of the worst performances of recent years... after that, Besson just lost me...

  • EDDIE COYLE | September 20, 2013 9:34 AM

    'ANGEL A' was a sexy funny b/w piece of cinema

  • alex | September 18, 2013 3:03 PMReply

    just as my fried Angela said, his career went south.

  • robyo | September 18, 2013 2:47 PMReply

    WEINSTEIN CO HAS TO ....[yeah they did, stop already ed]

Email Updates