Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

The Essentials: The 5 Best John Frankenheimer Films

by The Playlist Staff
July 6, 2012 1:57 PM
  • |

Few filmmakers these days name John Frankenheimer as an influence. He was never particularly trendy, never embraced by the auteurists or overtly paid homage by those who came after. In part, it's because of some of his later projects; the commercial failure of thriller "Black Sunday" in 1977 drove him to alcoholism that lasted for several years (it was only when he was reduced to drinking on the set of martial arts actioner "The Challenge" in 1981 that he checked himself into rehab), and some of his later projects, including his final film, "Reindeer Games," and the famous disaster "The Island Of Doctor Moreau" (on which the helmer replaced Richard Stanley several weeks into production) meant his critical reputation took a hit.

But Frankenheimer was also a master of the American thriller, with an extraordinary run in the 1960s, and many underrated subsequent highlights, from "French Connection II," multiple HBO and TNT movies, and 1998's gripping "Ronin," which includes one of the great screen car chases. He was never a showy filmmaker, but one with a clean, clear, unfussy style, and a serious attention to detail, that helped him produce his fair share of classics. A decade ago today, on July 6th, 2002, only a month after dropping out of the director's chair on the ultimately ill-fated "Exorcist: The Beginning" for health reasons, Frankenheimer passed away from a stroke, at the age of 72. To mark the anniversary, we've picked out our five favorites from the Frankenheimer filmography, and you can find them below. Did we neglect your favorite in our selections? Weigh in in the comments section below.   

“Birdman of Alcatraz” (1962)
For an all-too brief four-year period, Burt Lancaster and John Frankenheimer collaborations were looking as if they were going to be continuous and fruitful ala Robert De Niro & Martin Scorsese. After their inaugural team-up on 1961’s morality crime drama “The Young Savages,”  the duo hit certifiable pay dirt on their second time out with the “Birdman of Alcatraz.” Nominated for four Oscar baubles, including Best Actor for Lancaster (he would lose to Gregory Peck for “To Kill a Mockingbird,” but had already won in 1960 for “Elmer Gantry"), ‘Birdman’  centers on the true-life story of Robert Stroud, a federal prison inmate known for his affection with birds on the inside. A convicted murderer and intractably rebellious young inmate, Lancaster butts heads with the overbearing warden (Karl Malden) and then kills a guard in anger when his mother is denied a visit.  Eventually sentenced to solitary confinement for the rest of his life ‘Birdman’ then chronicles Lancaster's redemptive transformation from recalcitrant prisoner to withdrawn internee who becomes an ornithologist inside, all the while hounded by the autocratic warden who eventually transfers him to Alcatraz; a prison that will not permit him to keep his beloved birds. Co-starring Telly Savalas and Thelma Ritter, who both were nominated for their supporting turns as fellow prisoner and mother respectively, Frankenheimer’s simple yet effective and empathetic craftsmanship creates a quietly moving story that placed the film on The AFI's “100 Years...100 Cheers” list. All the more impressive as Frankenheimer was forced to take over the film from filmmaker Charles Crichton and compelled to shoot (by Lancaster, also the producer), the long version of the screenplay that resulted in an initial four-and-a-half-hour movie when it was first cut. Two-time Oscar winner Burnett Guffey was also nominated for Best Cinematography, making it five nominations in total.

"The Manchurian Candidate" (1962)
What better way to tap into the nation's Cold War anxiety than with a political thriller about communists brainwashing American soldiers? Frankenheimer's 1962 film follows Frank Sinatra as Major Bennett Marco, a man plagued by constant nightmares involving men of his platoon being killed by their Staff Sergeant Raymond Shaw (Laurence Harvey). After pursuing an investigation, it's revealed that the troops were brainwashed by communists, with Shaw poised to follow any orders so long as he is shown a Queen of Diamonds. The forever-old Angela Lansbury plays his mother (despite being only three years older than Harvey), a secret commie who hopes to execute a plan allowing her to influence the U.S. President with her ideology. It's a solid puzzle of a story chugging along with powerful forward momentum; incredibly absorbing even if both Soviet-paranoia and Sinatra-lead films usually find modern audiences uninterested. The 2004 Jonathan Demme-helmed update with Denzel Washington wasn't badly received, but the original stands head and shoulders above, thanks to its weirder passages: Marco and love interest Eugenie (Janet Leigh) have such an odd conversation about states, railroad lines and old Chinese men that many concocted a "brainwashing theory" over the scene. There's also the nightmare sequence, in which the soldiers are drugged to think that a presentation by Communists showing off new assassin Shaw is actually an informational meeting about hydrangeas, attended only by older housewives. The reality and dream images are cut together disturbingly, going back and forth in a dissonant, maniacal fashion. It's pretty ingenious, expertly handled stuff, and you can't really remake that.

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    


  • Jinky | July 19, 2012 3:21 PMReply

    The Train is woefully under-seen and under-appreciated. Thanks for including.

  • SJHoneywell | July 14, 2012 4:08 PMReply

    I was going to be very upset if Seconds wasn't on this list. I watched that recently and was completely knocked sideways. A great film, and my current favorite Rock Hudson performance.

  • Leonardo | July 10, 2012 4:53 AMReply

    An Underrated director he is a fucking master.

  • Stevo the Magnificent | July 6, 2012 11:53 PMReply

    You should have included 'French Connection II' as an honorary mention, it was (unfortunate jazzy score notwithstanding) one of the best cop thrillers of the 1970's, had it been a stand-alone 'fish-out-of-water' story and not a sequel, it would be regarded as a classic now, Gene Hackman absolutely should have gotten a Best Actor nomination for it...

    One more thing, Frankenheimer's final film, the 2002 television movie 'Path to War' was just extraordinary; the study of an idealistic President - LBJ - increasingly crushed by circumstances and bad decisions in wartime, Michael Gambon's performance of a defeated and demoralized LBJ was simply magnetic, not to mention heartbreaking (and I'm a conservative), with Frankenheimer's direction pitch-perfect throughout, showing the young turks why he was such a master of his craft...

  • Real | July 6, 2012 6:07 PMReply

    Thanks for this list. Always wondered why John Frankenheimer doesn't get much of a mention when talking about film history. He directed some great films. And I'm always happy to see Burt Lancaster get some recognition-another great actor that tends to be rather underrated.

  • James | July 6, 2012 5:04 PMReply

    Dang! I was hoping to see BLACK SUNDAY on the list. It's one of my top 5 favorite films ever - the kind of studio film that could only have been made in the 70s. It's both a gripping thriller with the most thrilling third act in cinema history, and the most intelligent, nuanced look at global terrorism ever made. Not many films would dare to make the Israeli Mossad agent, the Palestinian Black September member, and the deranged Vietnam vet she teams up with ALL into the protagonists. The film treats nobody as stock villains, but looks on dispassionately as the terrorists pursue their horrifying goal. The female terrorist in particular is fascinating and multi-layered - Thomas Harris has said she was the model for Clarice Starling in his later books. And Bruce Dern's frenzied monologue about WHY he wants to attack the Super Bowl is one of the screen's great mad scenes, so brilliantly written that it takes you inside his thought process. By the end of it, you half root FOR him. It also has a glorious John Williams score written within months of his breakthrough STAR WARS score. And never again will it be possible to get permission to film an ACTUAL Goodyear blimp attacking an ACTUAL Super Bowl - no CGI garbage, it's all real. All in all an unrecognized masterpiece to my mind.

Email Updates