By Oliver Lyttelton | www.oliverlyttelton.com June 9, 2012 at 3:01PM
"Donnie Brasco" (1997)
For all the freaks and weirdos that Depp has played over the years, from "Edward Scissorhands" to Barnabas Collins, it can be deeply refreshing to see him play an ordinary human being. And he's perhaps never done that better than in 1997's "Donnie Brasco," in which Depp returned to the undercover law-enforcement roots of his TV breakout "21 Jump Street." Penned by "Quiz Show" writer Paul Attanasio, and directed by Mike Newell, in an unlikely follow-up to "Four Weddings And A Funeral," Depp plays the title character, who's brought into the NYC mob by Lefty Ruggiero (Al Pacino), a troubled, low-level hitman, after befriending him. Except Donnie Brasco is actually Joseph D. Pistone, an FBI agent charged with infiltrating the family, and as soon as he's found out, both he and Lefty will get bullets in the head. The film occasionally dips into undercover cop cliches, but for the most part it's admirably truthful and low-key, and the central performances are a marvel. It's arguably Pacino's last great turn, and complimented beautifully by Depp; he's got real tough guy swagger as Brasco, cheekboned like a young Christopher Walken, and simultaneously excited by his new profession of violence, and horrified at what he's becoming. And there's legitimate anguish when he's 'out of character' as it were, as Pistone frets about the fate of Lefty. What's most impressive of all is the extent to which Depp underplays the part (it's the forerunner of his best recent performance, as John Dillinger in "Public Enemies," although this one's the keeper). It's a reminder of the depth of his skills, and one that we perhaps wish Depp himself would take another look at these days.
"Fear & Loathing In Las Vegas" (1998)
Of course, sometimes the freaks are more fun. Decades in the works (with Jack Nicholson, Dan Aykroyd, John Malkovich and John Cusack all having been linked with the lead at some point), the film version of Hunter S. Thompson's seminal "Fear And Loathing In Las Vegas" finally made it to screens under the eye of Terry Gilliam. And once Thompson himself met with Depp, they became fast friends, and he insisted that the actor was the only possible choice to play Raoul Duke, his very-thinly-veiled surrogate in the tale (the two remained inseperable; Depp paid for Thompson's funeral, and reprised the role last year in "The Rum Diary"). And really, it's almost impossible to imagine anyone else in the part. Depp is almost unrecognizable under a (lack of) hairpiece, hat and glasses, often filmed in extreme close-up with wide lenses by Gilliam, and he lends a furious comic verve to the part that's almost reminiscent of a lost, high-as-a-kite Marx Brother. His manic energy is countered neatly by the deadpan narration, and if you've ever seen footage of Thompson, you know Depp isn't exaggerating in the slightest. And again, his chemistry with Benicio Del Toro, as attorney Dr. Gonzo, is outstanding -- a reminder of how generous he can be, when he wants. The film around the duo is, it should be said, something of a mess, but it's worth sitting through just for the performances.
"Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl" (2003)
It is only with a significant effort of will that we can cast our minds back to 2003-era Johnny Depp without them snagging on some of the more egregious clunkers the actor would subsequently be involved in. And it’s especially hard in the case of “Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl,” which spawned three of the aforementioned clunkers in its sequels. But we must not visit the sins of the sons upon the father, and instead we need to remember just how bloody good Depp was in this role, in this film. A swaggering, ludicrous, slurring rockstar rogue, his Captain Jack Sparrow proved the seasoning that spiced up proceedings into a heady, fun-packed brew: it was an interpretation so gonzo and exaggerated that it’s hard to believe it made it into a Disney franchise, let alone pretty much made a Disney franchise into a global success. Because there’s the rub -- Depp’s performance in ‘Black Pearl’ proved both the film’s chief blessing and its, er, biggest curse, in that it was so universally adored (even garnering Depp the first of his three Best Actor Oscar nominations), that sequel scripts were pushed forward immediately on which clearly the only note the execs ever gave was “More Sparrow!” But of course part of the reason Depp is so great in the first ‘Pirates’ is that there isn’t that much of him -- again, he serves as the seasoning, not the main dish. But the logic went that since he was the most fun part of the original, he should be the focus going ahead so that by the time of “Dead Man’s Chest” we were being asked to suffer through dream sequences in which multiple Sparrows appear (presumably the only way they could think of to cram in even more Depp). Dammit, we’re talking about the sequels again, sorry. Let’s get back to 2003. Back then Depp was an actor universally admired but without a major franchise or even that many true box-office home runs to his name, and he was looking to make a more family-oriented film. Disney just happened to have a not-especially-promising sounding movie in the works, based on one of their theme park rides. To go from that to a recording-breaking blast featuring a performance so OTT and original that it’s kind of hard to remember that the Keith Richards/pirate association was not, simply, always there, merits praise. What makes it an essential of Depp’s, though, is the giggly fun and “can you believe I’m getting away with this?” feel to the portrayal and also the fact that we cannot account for his subsequent career without it; occasionally for better but mostly, sadly, for worse.
-- Oliver Lyttelton, Jessica Kiang