Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Harvey Weinstein Says Quentin Tarantino Has Changed The Last Chapter Of 'The Hateful Eight' Harvey Weinstein Says Quentin Tarantino Has Changed The Last Chapter Of 'The Hateful Eight' Sundance Review: ‘Slow West’ Starring Michael Fassbender, Kodi Smit-McPhee & Ben Mendelsohn Sundance Review: ‘Slow West’ Starring Michael Fassbender, Kodi Smit-McPhee & Ben Mendelsohn Sundance: Keanu Reeves Opens The Door To Trouble In Teaser Trailer For Eli Roth's 'Knock Knock' Sundance: Keanu Reeves Opens The Door To Trouble In Teaser Trailer For Eli Roth's 'Knock Knock' Watch: 8-Minute Video Essay Argues Steve McQueen's 'Shame' Is Actually A Critique Of The Modern Metropolis Watch: 8-Minute Video Essay Argues Steve McQueen's 'Shame' Is Actually A Critique Of The Modern Metropolis Watch: The Tampon Scene From 'Fifty Shades Of Grey' You Won't See In The Movie Recreated With 'The Sims' Watch: The Tampon Scene From 'Fifty Shades Of Grey' You Won't See In The Movie Recreated With 'The Sims' 'Death Proof' Star Zoe Bell Leads Latest Additions To Quentin Tarantino's 'Hateful Eight' As Filming Begins 'Death Proof' Star Zoe Bell Leads Latest Additions To Quentin Tarantino's 'Hateful Eight' As Filming Begins Ranked From Best To Worst: Every Sundance Dramatic Grand Jury Prize Winner Ranked From Best To Worst: Every Sundance Dramatic Grand Jury Prize Winner Watch: 'Saturday Night Live' Sketch 'Fanatic' Written & Directed By Paul Thomas Anderson And Starring Ben Affleck Watch: 'Saturday Night Live' Sketch 'Fanatic' Written & Directed By Paul Thomas Anderson And Starring Ben Affleck The 10 Best Films Of 2003 The 10 Best Films Of 2003 The 10 Best Films Of 2002 The 10 Best Films Of 2002 Check Out These Minimalist, Old School Paperback-Style Posters For The Films Of Wes Anderson Check Out These Minimalist, Old School Paperback-Style Posters For The Films Of Wes Anderson First Look: Leonardo DiCaprio Gets Grimy In Alejandro González Iñárritu's 'The Revenant' First Look: Leonardo DiCaprio Gets Grimy In Alejandro González Iñárritu's 'The Revenant' The 30 Most Anticipated Movies Of The 2015 Sundance Film Festival The 30 Most Anticipated Movies Of The 2015 Sundance Film Festival 2015 Oscar Nominees Get The Honest Poster Treatment 2015 Oscar Nominees Get The Honest Poster Treatment "Carry Bolt Cutters Everywhere": Werner Herzog Has 24 Amazing Pieces Of Advice "Carry Bolt Cutters Everywhere": Werner Herzog Has 24 Amazing Pieces Of Advice The 25 Best Horror Films Of The 21st Century So Far The 25 Best Horror Films Of The 21st Century So Far Watch: 3 Graphic, Very NSFW Clips From Lars von Trier's 'Nymphomaniac Vol II — Director's Cut' Watch: 3 Graphic, Very NSFW Clips From Lars von Trier's 'Nymphomaniac Vol II — Director's Cut' The 20 Best TV Shows Of The 2013/2014 Season The 20 Best TV Shows Of The 2013/2014 Season From Worst To Best: Ranking The Films Of Hayao Miyazaki From Worst To Best: Ranking The Films Of Hayao Miyazaki Christopher Nolan Says His Howard Hughes Film Is Dead, But He'd Still Like To Do A Bond Film At Some Point Christopher Nolan Says His Howard Hughes Film Is Dead, But He'd Still Like To Do A Bond Film At Some Point

Review: 'When We Leave' An "Issues" Drama With All The Subtlety Of A PSA

Photo of Christopher Bell By Christopher Bell | The Playlist January 26, 2011 at 7:30AM

There's no question that the Academy Awards have gotten much stronger in the past few years. Big awards have been handed out to pictures that went against the norm -- at least in comparison to what else was nominated -- and while this writer wasn't a huge fan of all of them, there's no question about them being much different than what the Academy used to go for ("Slumdog Millionaire" was, at least in its style -- we won't instigate an argument about the overly moving fairytale narrative right now). Unfortunately that kind of forward thinking mentality has yet to hit the Foreign Oscars category, and even though some really good flicks have made the short list (this year included), the powerful few tend to pick the most manipulative, Hollywood-ish picture possible. Sometimes they click and sometimes they don't. Many, including some of the staff, loved last year's sentimental "The Secret In Their Eyes," whereas most could barely stomach the previous winner "Departures." Then there are ones that don't make it at all, ones so manipulative and forced it almost seems like they were manufactured solely to demand recognition by the awards committee. Germany's "When We Leave" is that kind of movie, one that has its heart in the right place but is hampered by juvenile direction.
3

There's no question that the Academy Awards have gotten much stronger in the past few years. Big awards have been handed out to pictures that went against the norm -- at least in comparison to what else was nominated -- and while this writer wasn't a huge fan of all of them, there's no question about them being much different than what the Academy used to go for ("Slumdog Millionaire" was, at least in its style -- we won't instigate an argument about the overly moving fairytale narrative right now). Unfortunately that kind of forward thinking mentality has yet to hit the Foreign Oscars category, and even though some really good flicks have made the short list (this year included), the powerful few tend to pick the most manipulative, Hollywood-ish picture possible. Sometimes they click and sometimes they don't. Many, including some of the staff, loved last year's sentimental "The Secret In Their Eyes," whereas most could barely stomach the previous winner "Departures." Then there are ones that don't make it at all, ones so manipulative and forced it almost seems like they were manufactured solely to demand recognition by the awards committee. Germany's "When We Leave" is that kind of movie, one that has its heart in the right place but is hampered by juvenile direction.

Umay (Sibel Kekilli) has found herself stuck in an impossible marriage with an unrelenting, cold man. It all started at one fateful supper where Umay's son, Cem, got a little too big for his britches and said some rather fresh things. Kemal, father and husband, rushes after the boy for a proper spanking, one that sends the mother after him and leads to her crying on the floor. Night time only brings dispassionate sex, with her husband completely unaware of her feelings (clue: she's lying stiff and avoiding eye contact during intercourse) and their child sleeping in the corner much too soundly. If actor-director Feo Aladag is to be given credit for anything, it's that she made it very clear from the start that she was making a broad melodrama with about as much substance and subtlety in her content as a PSA.

With son in tow, the battered woman escapes to her parents' house. It slowly trickles out that not only will her husband not being joining her, but that she has left him for good. Her traditionally minded folks are appalled by her decision; her siblings are just happy to have her. In the meantime, she nestles into her old bed and reconnects with an old friend, but mom and dad make things plenty tense with their intent on mending their daughter's marriage. They're mostly worried about the dishonor she's bringing their family due to her actions, which lead to some yelling and slapping (an unfortunate, pathetic reoccurring action) and the departure of Umay and Cem from the house. Now living in a closed-off facility, this newfound safety and freedom allow her to take classes and get a job at a local restaurant. Things are going great until family and husband attempt multiple kidnappings, and as Umay's supporters drop like flies (for instance, her sister's fiance breaks off the engagement for a brief spell because of her family's shame), she slowly descends into a frustrated, stress-induced insanity.

It's regrettable that this movie is such an over-the-top failure because it tackles some serious issues. How can anyone not get behind a film that advocates women's rights and critiques the absurd, inhuman act of honor killing? Now if only Aladag could make a statement that wasn't so ham-fisted and dour, one that properly examined the issue instead of creating an offensive and blatant Oscar bait of a movie. Almost every character in the picture merely exist to further her cause, so instead of complex insight into why Umay's opposition think the way they do, they are portrayed as selfish and villainous (when she tells her father that she is beaten by her husband, he replies "He's your husband."). When they do show reasons for their actions, it's glazey and quick -- she doesn't want to give the opposing side any screen time unless they're being atrocious human beings.

Of course, she's probably in the right. How can you humanize any person who would contemplate killing their flesh and blood to save the honor in their name? Then again, we've seen directors defy assumptions and conventions constantly, Todd Solondz concocted a layered pedophile in "Happiness" and Cristi Puiu refused to give digestible, concrete reasonings to his murderous character in "Aurora." Sure, not every filmmaker is going to start taking cues from a "perverted" American director and a minimalist Romanian, and no one should obscure their artistic messages simply for the sake of being subtle, but when the film is executed as poorly as it is here, the subject hardly becomes a worthwhile topic of conversation or a push towards activism.

But if only it were as simple as hating the presentation of an idea. There's plenty of other cinematic crimes here -- lifeless cinematography, a contrived romantic subplot, overbearing music -- which makes it even more difficult to give the film a pass for "fighting the good fight." This miserablist chore is all too imperious with its message, sacrificing absolutely everything in order to expose an all-too-terrible thing. What we have here isn't art, it's a soapbox, and just as bad and ineffective as those "very special episodes" that would clog up our half-hour sitcom excursions back in the day. [D-]

This article is related to: Foreign Films, Review, Foreign Directors, When We Leave, Feo Aladag


The Playlist

The obsessives' guide to contemporary cinema via film discussion, news, reviews, features, nostalgia, movie music, soundtracks, DVDs and more.


E-Mail Updates