Best Actress Race Is Wide Open: Oscar Perennials vs. Newbies

News
by Anne Thompson
November 9, 2012 1:09 PM
7 Comments
  • |

'Amour'
As soon as an actor wins an Oscar, they enter the Academy fluke zone. It means that going forward, they have earned an advantage: they will be taken seriously as a possible nominee.

This means that the ever-growing media covering the Oscars tend to assume that because an Oscar-perennial is in a movie, they will be nominated.

Jacques Audiard’s “Rust & Bone”

This year's Best Actress race reveals this trend. As soon as a publicist revealed that current it-girl Jessica Chastain--who was nominated in her first year starring in some six movies for her supporting role for "The Help"--was the lead in Oscar-winner Kathryn Bigelow's "Zero Dark Thirty," she lept onto the best actress charts. This was before anyone had seen the film, which was kept under wraps until after the presidential election. (The final cut is due to be submitted November 19; press screenings begin Thanksgiving week.)

As usual, the actress field is weak and wide open. And Chastain is a highly regarded performer who so far can do no wrong. And this is Bigelow's follow-up to "The Hurt Locker" (which Sony has deemed not commercially robust enough to go against the holiday big guns; the wide release of "Zero Dark Thirty" has been pushed back to January). Word is that Chastain has a juicier role (as a CIA analyst obsessed for 12 years with tracking Osama bin Laden) than Ben Affleck's stoic agent in "Argo." (As popular as he is, and as many nominations as "Argo" will get, Affleck will not be nominated for that role.) We still don't know if Chastain has that key dramatic scene that earns Oscars.

Jessica Chastain in "Zero Dark Thirty."

There's also an assumption that Marion Cotillard is a lock for her extraordinary performance in Jacques Audiard's "Rust and Bone." I'm the only Oscar-watcher who did not vote for her at Gurus 'O Gold. Why not? Because I worry that there isn't room for two great French actresses in the best actress top five. Sony Pictures Classics is pushing both Cotillard and "Amour" star Emanuelle Riva as Best Actress. While it was overlooked at Cannes, "Rust and Bone" is admired by many who've seen it. (It will be on my ten best list partly due to Cotillard's amazing performance.) But it's a challenging film with an ick factor that may put off some viewers: at the start, Cotillard's whale trainer suffers an horrific limb-severing accident. The film is about her recovery, and how she changes as a result of this dramatic change in her life. If the New York or L.A. critics go with Cotillard, it's a whole new ball game.

Quvenzhané Wallis

And I may change my vote. The Hollywood Foreign Press Association likes "Rust and Bone," and Cotillard learned fluent English and wooed over many voters and critics the year she won best actress for "La Vie en Rose."  The list of actress suspects is all over the place, and anything can happen. But for now I'm betting that "Amour" will wow Academy voters, and that 85-year-old Riva, who starred in "Hiroshima Mon Amour," a movie that many Academy seniors remember, will get the nod (which would make her the oldest best actress or actor nominee ever; "Cocoon"'s Jessica Tandy was 80).

What will year-end critics and awards groups and guilds do, and what will Academy voters embrace? "Silver Linings Playbook" star and "Winter's Bone" nominee Jennifer Lawrence is a slam dunk; everyone falls for her in this romantic drama from David O. Russell. And newcomer Quvenzhané Wallis, eight, has the best shot at an Oscar slot for the superb indie, "Beasts of the Southern Wild." She could be the youngest Best Actress ever nominated (she will be nine in January). Keisha Castle-Hughes was 12 when she was nominated for Best Actress for 2002's "Whale Rider." Tatum O'Neal won the Best Supporting Actress Oscar for "Paper Moon" at age 10 in 1973. Adrien Brody is the youngest Best Actor winner at age 29 for "The Pianist" in 2002. Mary Badham was nominated for supporting actress for "To Kill a Mockingbird" at age 10 in 1962. And Justin Henry was eight when he was nominated for supporting actor for "Kramer vs. Kramer" in 1979. (More Oscar age details here.)

Naomi Watts is extraordinary in the true story "The Impossible," as a mother fighting for survival for the sake of her son. If I'm right that another Gurus fave, Helen Mirren, will not wow Oscar voters in "Hitchcock," that leaves open another slot. We have yet to see what "Anna Karenina" will do for Keira Knightley, who unlike Chastain, has not been earning rave reviews of late, and could be due for a major comeback as Tolstoy's tragic heroine.

Here's what the field looks like at Gurus 'O Gold:

  1. Jennifer Lawrence "Silver Linings Playbook" 82
  2. Marion Cotillard "Rust and Bone" 54
  3. Quvenzhané Wallis "Beasts of the Southern Wild" 39
  4. Helen Mirren "Hitchcock"  29
  5. Jessica Chastain "Zero Dark Thirty" 26
  6. Naomi Watts "The Impossible" 21
  7. Emmanuelle Riva "Amour"   20
  8. Keira Knightley "Anna Karenina" 20
News
  • |

More: Oscars, Awards, Awards, Academy Awards

You might also like:

7 Comments

  • Kil | November 11, 2012 4:11 AMReply

    Anne, I really like you but I can't believe you support a five or six years old performance. Don't you think that it's wrong? An academy award nomination is not for a child (IMO). Why not using it to help an adult career? What if someone give the highest critic honor to a 6 year old girl over you? How would you react? Would it be fair?

    I believe Cotillard is a sure thing by now, she is one of the only two academy members of the list (With Mirren) and she accomplished what only a few actresses have done, she imposed herself as a very respected actress with perfects post-Oscars roles. She in not stranger to the academy starring in Inception (Won 4 Oscars), Midnight in Paris (Won 1) or Nine (nominated for 4, Her song "Take it all" among them). And I bet they are already anticipating "Nightingale" and "Blood Ties" so they know very well she's gonna be here for a very long time and they've certainly remarked the fact that a lot of directors wants to direct her and when they do, they never stop praising her (Nolan, Allen, Marshall, Mann...). Michael Mann which saw a preview of "Rust & Bone" praised her again, James Gray even said she was the best actor he's ever worked with (Somewhere on THE PLAYLIST).
    I don't like to say the word "campaign" but let say she makes a lot of promotion which never hurts.

  • Genadijus | November 9, 2012 5:54 PMReply

    I'll see "Amour" this weekend, but for now on Marion looks for friendly for the Academy. My nominations prediction for Best Actress category:
    Jennifer Lawrence
    Jessica Chaistain
    Naomi Watts
    Marion Cotillard
    Helen Mirren

  • M. | November 9, 2012 3:46 PMReply

    I agree that Jennifer Lawrence is a slam dunk...she is perfection in Silver Linings Playbook.

  • Jamie | November 9, 2012 3:33 PMReply

    Early buzz on the ladies of "Quartet" as well. This field is getting crowded. Currently I think Marion Cotillard is the best option.

  • Ad | November 9, 2012 1:47 PMReply

    The Jessica Chastain badwagon is really annoying, she is a good actress but she has been very overesposed and, as the other person pointed out, she good pretty bad reviews for her stage debut.
    Knightley has had great reviews from lots of critics for her AK role ( nd you Anne really liked it) and is one of the only true leading role of the season. I hope Riva get is over Cotillard. I like the latter a lot but Riva deserves this spot over her. As per Mirren, the movie wasn't like by everybody and even though she is Mirren, it isn't a guarantee.

  • just saying | November 9, 2012 1:20 PMReply

    Jessica Chastain can do wrong. She just received bad reviews for her Broadway stage debut, " The Heiress. "

  • SCH | December 6, 2012 4:57 AM

    Good to know there's still some objectivity left in the world of stage vs. the world of film.
    Then again, ScarJo is apparently considered Broadway's second coming.

    Chastain needs to play the game carefully lest she gets the wind taken out of her sails too soon. I've liked what I've seen her do on screen so far (which hasn't been much) but am not yet prepared to believe that her poo perpetually smells like roses.

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

Email Updates

Most "Liked"

  • Pick Hit: Raunchy R-Rated Comedy 'Neighbors,' ...
  • Trailers from Hell on 'Pink Flamingos,' ...
  • WATCH: Trailer for 'Scandal' Star Tony ...
  • Friday Box Office: Sequels Beat New ...
  • HBO Renews 'Veep' and 'Silicon Vall ...
  • WATCH: Director Alexander Payne's Bizarre ...
  • Meron and Zadan Return for Third Round ...
  • Read an Excerpt from Andy Warhol's Delightfully ...
  • Want to Know How Many Characters Died ...
  • David Fincher Photographs Rosamund Pike's ...