Lars von Trier's Last Cannes Q & A: "Stupid" Statements, Melancholia, "I Am Not a Nazi," Dunst, Cruz

Features
by Anne Thompson
May 26, 2011 2:24 AM
8 Comments
  • |

This year at Cannes, fest veteran Lars von Trier picked a hell of a way to became a household name. In the days following the notorious Cannes Film Festival Melancholia press conference during which the Danish writer-director offended just about everybody (except the Iranian culture minister) by calling himself a Nazi, he apologized repeatedly for his "stupid, idiotic" comments that led to his banishment from the festival and insisted, "I am not a Nazi."

He held court with the media in the quiet haven of the lovely hotel Le Mas Candille in Mougins, outside of Cannes, far from the madding crowd. I was literally his last interview before he went off to have dinner with Kirsten Dunst to try and repair the damage he had done to their relationship. The next day, she accepted the best actress Palme d'Or, thanking the festival for allowing Melancholia to stay in competition, and afterwards said that she should not have been punished for von Trier's "inappropriate" comments (video below, with trailer).

The complete transcript of my flip cam interview with von Trier, which covers the movie--originally developed for Penelope Cruz-- as well as his comments and the Trier family scandal that led to them and his problems with Danish filmmakers Susanne Bier and Nicolas Winding Refn, plus two video clips, is also below. Von Trier starts things off, not atypically, by insulting Harvey Weinstein. The film opens in Denmark May 26; von Trier doesn't fly, so any U.S. press he'll do to accompany the film's fall release by Magnolia will be via satellite, phone or Skype.

Thompson on Hollywood
Thompson on Hollywood
Thompson on Hollywood

Melancholia starts off with a stunning prologue introducing the soaring strains of Wagner's Tristan and Isolde that will punctuate the movie, which shows a lavish castle wedding destroyed by a bride's plunge into depression, followed by how she and her family deal with a planet hurtling toward a possible collision with Earth. Melancholia might have had a shot at the Palme d'Or won by The Tree of Life had it not been overshadowed by von Trier's misbehavior. (More details on the film and a sampling of reviews are here.)

AT: Here in Mougins it is very quiet.
LVT: Yes, I used to stay at the Du Cap in Cap d'Antibes, which also has a beautiful park, but this is peaceful, I don't have to be stared at by what's his name, the big guy, Harvey Weinstein. I met him, and he said, "We represented your film once," and I said, "You mean destroyed."

AT: Which film?
LVT: Europa. That was never taken off the shelf. Then he was a little mad. Since then, every time we stayed out there, we would be sitting next to each other eating breakfast without a word. For some strange reason I don't think the last days' incidents would have made this much better.

AT: With all the media coverage of your disastrous Cannes press conference, your movie Melancholia has been completely overshadowed.
LVT: I have almost forgotten the movie.

AT: Your last film Antichrist had an extraordinary opening slow-motion sequence, and you went much farther with this one. How did it come into being?
LVT: My first idea was to have some images during the film that were fixed in monumental slow motion that could kind of mirror a scene, or be there as another element through the story, so they were originally thought as something that would be in the film in the right place. Then I slid into Wagner.

AT: Why Wagner?
LVT: It's an old love. I read about it, and it seems that it's a major work in German Romanticism, especially since it's about being purified through death. Yes, that's how the Germans are, and the Danes for that matter! Then the film suddenly became very romantic and it had to have an overture. So there we used the prelude from Tristan and Isolde. This is one-third of the prelude.

AT: Then we have all the references: the paintings, the Lady of Shallot (pictured). You were shooting in slow-motion, what did you do with the digital photography?
LVT: All these shots are made from many many layers, what you do now very easily in the computer. One shot where she's in the background and the boy is doing something with a knife, was made from 30 different plates. It sounds complicated but it's not, you take each tree, and you put one lamp or two, to light that tree, and do the next one, and when you put it together, it gets this larger-than-life feeling because you don't know where the lights come from because that is taken away in the computer, and you can really play with the picture that way.

AT: In one shot you see the electricity going up and coming out of Dunst's hands?
LVT: All these things are from the research. If a planet of this size would come there would be a lot of electric storms and this could happen.

AT: It seems there are all these films with apocalyptic feelings in the air, that you are capturing, in the zeitgeist.
LVT: But it's a little bit by chance because my motive was the melancholia. And then somewhere in the story of this melancholic person, she seems to call the planet Melancholia to come and swallow her up.

AT: The wedding goes to hell --Festen on steroids--and when Stellan Skarsgard and Charlotte Rampling as her parents behave badly, she goes down very fast.
LVT: She's had this melancholia before, as we hear, and she's clinging to the idea that if she forces normality on herself that would save her--by getting married, by having a child. So she can fall a long way, we start her quite high. But already from the start they are two hours late; that's not a good sign.

AT: The image of the lengthy stretch limo that can't make the curve, where did that come from?
LVT: That was just something I always thought about because it's something you see in American films all the time, they must have special roads that can allow them to move. I thought it was also a little symbolic of how great she wanted the wedding to be: it should be a very long car, then the circumstances of the reality get in the way.

AT: She runs away in a fabulous wedding gown to this meticulous golf course. The setting is very Marienbad. Did you think of that?
LVT: Yes, but that came mostly from the castle that we found, that it had these Marienbad views. What I thought was interesting was when they did Last Year at Marienbad, they were painting the right shadows on the ground. But here we have two shadows, because of the two planets. Yeah, everything is stolen, that's how it is.

AT: The movie was originally supposed to star Penelope Cruz.
LVT: Exactly. My task was to write a film for her. It's good to have a task, and she asked me if she could be in a film. I said, 'I don't know, I like you very much as an actor, let me think about it, if I can find something.' And we discussed a lot and had a lot of contact, and I came up with, what I could give her was Melancholia. The word Melancholia and Penelope together I thought I could use to create a film.

AT: But she didn't want to do it?
LVT: This is a little unclear. No, I think she wanted, because compared to the film before, Antichrist, she was getting off relatively easy.

AT: There was some nudity.
LVT: But it was not so hard. I think she wanted to do it, but then she was suddenly in this Pirates of the Caribbean. It's happened to me before this, these big actresses think that 'ok he can just wait for me,' which of course I could. But my problem, compared to other directors, is that I can't work on more than one thing at a time. And that means that I should wait three quarters of a year doing nothing. So I chose to try something else.

AT: Kirsten came through.
LVT: I think so.

AT: Is she mad at you now?
LVT: Kirsten? I hope not, I am going to have dinner with her. Because I was naughty at the press conference? Yeah, it was probably harder on her than anyone else.

AT: It was a great performance.
LVT: I was talking about the press conference, that was not such a great performance! No, she's probably a little afraid of situations like that. I can understand that. It was completely stupid, completely stupid, but I am not a Nazi.

AT: What is the real story, what your mother told you?
LVT: The real story, and that's where all the Nazi nonsense came from, was that Trier is a Jewish name, and a very big Jewish family.

AT: You added the von.
LVT: I added the von, maybe to get away from that, but that was first of all because it was forbidden for me to do it in the film school. You know if something is forbidden it's kind of attractive to me. But it was also Von Stroheim and Von Sternberg, they added it also, because they came from Germany, and they said, 'how do we do it in Hollywood?' and of course we put a von in there, and they were suddenly noblemen, which was complete nonsense, they were not at all. And I like crooks somehow. I like the idea of that, so I put that in. But I took it very seriously that I was from a Jewish family.

AT: Because your father, you thought, was Jewish.
LVT: I know that the thing is it should come from the mother's side, which is a very clever idea, of course, as we know, but I still took it very seriously, and I went to the concentration camps, blah blah, I was very Jewish.

AT: Did you celebrate Shabbat?
LVT: No, because my family was, as I found out later, not considered to be a fine Jewish family because they didn't go to the synogogue, they were very much atheistic, and my father was very much against Israel, but he was very Jewish. But people can be anti-Zionist without being anti-Semitic, of course. This was very important to me. Then my mother died and on her deathbed she told me that my father was not my biological father, which is very common I believe, and probably has happened in royal houses anywhere where the name is important. And then I said this is in a stupid way because I was feeling good and relaxed.

AT: You were cheerful because you knew they liked your movie, the press actually applauded.
LVT: No, I didn't know that. OK, that's good. No, I just felt relaxed, then I have this stupid unprofessional thing that I need to entertain a little.

AT: We actually expect you to, it's a tradition.
LVT: This is the last one of these I'll do at Cannes. Because I get carried away. Then I say that I found out I was not a Jew but a Nazi, which meant I was on the other side of the fence. It was not nice to say, especially to the Germans. That's ridiculous and stupid. It was kind of the Danish way of being idiotic. And I regret that. I don't think I was really anti-Semitic, because that would be extremely stupid. All my four children have Jewish names, I take it very seriously.

AT: And aren't your children friends with Susanne Bier's?
LVT: Yes. But that's quite another story. I have problems with Susanne Bier and she has problems with me, we went to school together, and we always had these problems.

AT: This all seems to be blowing up inside your Danish film community.
LVT: She's Danish. Yeah, OK. We have these differences. Maybe it has to do with, some people think she is very important to our company that I am co-owner of, Zentropa, that has given her privileges. Fuck that.

AT: You said that to the son of your editor, Nicolas Winding Refn.
LVT: I am very fond of Nicolas. He's a nice guy.

AT: His film Drive did well last night.
LVT: Good. No, I like him very much. I'm sure what he said about me was what he meant but I can't stop loving him. I worked with his father on almost all my films and I'm very good friends of his mother's and I don't know what he meant that I've been harmful to his family, that was a little strange, but I would kiss him any day.

AT: With Anti-Christ, you were pulling yourself out of depression, as you made it, and this film feels as if you were out of it, had come to another place.
LVT: That is what I'm not so proud of, that it was too easy to do.

AT: It feels like it was easy, like it was like butter. Why is that bad?
LVT: That's a very good question! I think it has to do with the Protestantism of my country even though I'm not religious. It's like you have a great view, if you crawl there with your nails and see the view, or you go there in your car, stop the car, and get out, see the view. That's something different, even though it's the same thing.

AT: Any word from Martin Scorsese on The Five Obstructions?
LVT: No, I haven't heard anything from him. I'm a little worried that he should be frightened by all this nonsense that I don't want to say any more that I regret. The only thing that I have decided is that I don't want to do these press conferences. Because if I had said 'I'm a Nazi,' while we were talking, you would say to me, "what the fuck do you say? What do you mean by that?' Then we would discuss it and there might come some sense. That doesn't happen.

AT: What did you feel at that moment as you were doing it, you said 'how do I get out of this sentence?' Was your heart beating? Did you know that you were in trouble?
LVT: No, I didn't know that I was in that serious trouble that I later came to be. It seems it has very much to do with where we are. Of course, in America there would be trouble also.

AT: France has certain rules?
LVT: They have rules and certain historical issues with Jews that are not so good. Which yeah, so but then again it can't be forbidden to mention Hitler, for Chrissake, especially not at a festival. That's called freedom of speech.

AT: You said that Thierry Fremaux and Gilles Jacob were on your side. You still feel that?
LVT: I expect them to be, they are very dear to me. I haven't talked to them about it, I just said, 'do whatever you think is necessary for the festival.' I haven't talked to them about it, haven't talk to them directly, I said to them through my people, 'do what is necessary, throw the film out, it's fine.'

AT: They were talking about cutting the film off. Fremaux told me he and Jacob fought against it.
LVT: That was a good idea, because that would have given them an artistic problem, because let's talk about some other film that was politically incorrect, but was a brilliant film. Should that go in competition, should it not, should you choose the films by the chance that this idiot would say something stupid at a press conference? It's an interesting question, if you have a film festival.

AT: I agree. It's about art.
LVY: It is. That's why I said to them 'do whatever you need to do that gives you the less trouble.'

AT: The ban may be just for this year. Would you submit your films again?
LVT: I don't know if I'm allowed to. So far I am persona non grata, I've been told. The words are funny, and something a rebel like me can treasure. I'm not proud of the circumstances of how it happened, not at all. I said a thousand times that I would not hurt anybody, that was not the idea. I like provocation, this is not a good provocation, it was not something I wanted to do. Sometimes I provoke because there's meaning behind it. This time there was no meaning. It was a mistake.

AT: Did you know who your real father was?
LVT: The real father, he was a German. That's why I said I was a Nazi. He was not a Nazi, he was a freedom fighter. Yes, I met him, he was an asshole. It was ridiculous, my mother said to me, 'you will like him so much, he is such a fantastic person.' Then I met a feminine man, he said, 'I was sure that your mother would protect herself.' He said to me, 'If you want to discuss more, it should be through my lawyer.' And he was 78.

And I had imagined this kind of slow-motion thing. And he said, 'I have never accepted that child.' And he said that to me. It was completely awful, but that did not make him a Nazi, not at all, he was a freedom fighter, and very respectable in every way. I just didn't like him. But then I got some siblings, who I see. That's fine. The only thing that was funny in the story was that I was not Jewish, I was half-German. From there it went wrong.

AT: So Thierry Fremaux indicated to me, my sense was that he'd like to see this not be more than just this year. There's hope for the future. You could come back.
LVT: If I come back to Cannes, or to any other festival, I won't make press conferences. That's what I learned. It's so much better to talk to directly to someone. It becomes very formal, like I'm making a statement. I don't want to make a statement, my film is my statement.

AT: You and Terry Malick. He didn't do it either.
LVT: I was told early on that I had to make this press conference. But I could show up and talk one at a time. It doesn't necessarily have to be. The same people that can communicate with the world in a good way with the right films, it's two different talents. One is to talk to the world in the right way, which you do when you talk at a press conference. I'm not good at that. So I'd rather talk through my films.

Von Trier interview, part one:

Part two:

Dunst reacts to winning her Palme d'Or for Melancholia, saying that she should not have been punished for what von Trier did, which was "inappropriate and idiotic," adding, "he paid for it":

Melancholia trailer:

Melancholia from Zentropa on Vimeo.

[Photo of Lars von Trier and Kirsten Dunst by Brian Brooks, indieWIRE.]

You might also like:

8 Comments

  • oliver | June 6, 2011 1:43 AMReply

    Just want to add: Great interview :)

  • oliver | June 6, 2011 1:09 AMReply

    Sorry... just gotta add to Mr/Miss/Mrs Frances comment about the "The First Film in 15 years"...

    Well, a little film history lesson here, Frances:

    After "Breaking the Waves", Trier put together something light, easy entertainment, only for the Danish audiences, called "Dancer In The Dark", nothing much, but an insignificant little singer from some country called Island named Bjork, won some award at some... oh wait! She won at Cannes for best Female actress... oh well, nothing to brag about.

    Then he went even more obscure and made some silly little ditty with some nobody called Nicole Kidman or something - there were also some other nobodies (Check IMDB for full cast list). Anyways, the film was called "Dogville" or something... was in competition at some small festival called Cannes... not much to brag about.

    Oh, he also made a sequel to that one,called "Mandalay", guess he was cashing in on the "Matrix" franchise at the time...

    Oh, if you haven't heard of the above, he made a film called "Direktøren for det hele" featuring a lot famous danish actors... It was big in France.

    But then he hit rock bottom... He did some insignificant film once more... something called "AntiChrist" - not much to write about there... It won some tiny award (not an Oscar - now that would have meant something).

    Seriously! I agree with Dr. Hulbeck. If you are gonna rant AND get your facts wrong?! Grow up.

    Yeah, it's stupid behavior, I'll agree with you there. But Emir Kusturica (Black Cat, White Cat - Oscar and Cannes winner) was actively supporting the Muslim genocide from the Serbs during the Croatian war in the 90's and NO ONE battered an eyelid - hell, they just gave him awards!

    Now how sick is that?!

  • Monica Laursen | May 30, 2011 10:19 AMReply

    At first I was choked and speechless over Von Trier remarkes. Now it has passed over to a concern. Please let Von Trier back in. May he not have learned from this experience?? Hopefully.

  • Paul Kelly | May 28, 2011 6:12 AMReply

    I think I'd have more respect for the reaction at Cannes if they hadn't appointed a convicted child rapist to their jury in 1991

  • Dr. Hulbeck | May 27, 2011 11:27 AMReply

    Lars Von Trier is one of the few really interesting moviemakers on the planet right now, and for Cannes to turn up their collective nose at him because of a silly joke indicates quite clearly that they are foolish and irrelevant.

    For Chrissake, the man said, "I'm joking" as he spoke, and apologized afterward. Considering that some of the same people who voted this man unwelcome also signed the petition to free Roman Polanski, and gave Mel Gibson's latest performance a standing ovation, this ban is an obvious, hypocritical, and frankly bewildering overreaction to a very minor incident.

    Frances Willington, who posted above? May I say to you that just about any artist worth a damn is just about guaranteed to be "full of himself, vain and immodest." That would apply to Picasso, Tolstoy, Mozart, Balzac, Dickens, Wilde, Proust, Lennon, Bergman, and... just a sec here... oh yes, all the rest. What in God's name do you think artists get paid for? I'll answer the question for you: TO HAVE DIFFERENT PRIORITIES THAN THE REST OF US. To be crazy, irrational, arrogant, and to act and speak carelessly and wildly. Because if they didn't, they wouldn't be very interesting to listen to, and their art wouldn't be very interesting to experience. To pretend otherwise is simple moral dishonesty.

    In short, this whole "incident" is a great bagful of hot air. Von Trier's no Nazi, he's a fine, original director who has just been swallowed by the vulture press.

  • Frances Willington | May 27, 2011 7:58 AMReply

    Lars Von Trier is a vile ape in more ways than one. he is rude and ignorant, to insult Harvey Weinstein, who has produced and released more GREAT FILMS than Von trier and had hot dinners, is outrageous and to call him a Big, Fat Guy is just bad manners. OK Melancholia is an interesting, arresting film, but it's the first one Von Trier has made in 15 year, since "Breaking the Waves". He is so obviously 'full of hmself", vain and immodest, sans courage, that I do not believe he will ever be able to capture the wonderful magic and emotion of "Waves'. he also placed the reputation of Gilles Jacob, president of Cannes, FIF open to insults from other Countries, this was also outrageous and stupid behavior.

  • rgm | May 26, 2011 5:29 AMReply

    Excellent interview. Clarifies von Triers sad lack acumen that caused Cannes understandable rush to judgment.

  • Jill Kennedy | May 26, 2011 3:48 AMReply

    Here's a good review of Melancholia from a Finnish reviewer attempting to write in English. He addresses the controversy as well.

    http://mankabros.com/blogs/btp/

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

Email Updates

Most "Liked"

  • Academy Reveals Key Dates for the O ...
  • WATCH: It's All Hitting the Fan in New ...
  • This Weekend in Theaters, Johnny Depp ...
  • Pick Hit: Raunchy R-Rated Comedy 'Neighbors,' ...
  • Trailers from Hell on 'Pink Flamingos,' ...
  • WATCH: Trailer for 'Scandal' Star Tony ...
  • Friday Box Office: Sequels Beat New ...
  • HBO Renews 'Veep' and 'Silicon Vall ...
  • WATCH: Director Alexander Payne's Bizarre ...
  • Meron and Zadan Return for Third Round ...