Critics raved over her "Monster" performance: Andrew Sarris declared, "Ms. Theron has ventured far beyond mere surface impersonation -- although that is startling enough -- to an insightful penetration of her subject's psyche." Peter Travers called her "a force of nature," and Michael O'Sullivan gushed over "the bravura, mercilessly watchable performance of Charlize Theron."
That performance was tough to top, but "North Country" (2005) earned Theron her second Oscar nomination (Reese Witherspoon won for "Walk the Line"). "In the Valley of Elah" (2007) and "The Burning Plain" (2008) also featured strong performances by Theron but lured limited audiences. 2011's hard-R comedy "Young Adult" was a perfect use of Theron's "I-don't-give-a-fuck" attitude (which few A-listers are brave enough to reveal) but Jason Reitman/Diablo Cody's tone is an acquired taste. Oscar-buzz for the role disappeared as reviews were mixed and the Best Actress category became more crowded.
This summer Theron makes a bid to boost her global bankability with two big-budget studio films. As the evil Queen Ravenna in Universal's "Snow White and the Huntsman" (46% Rotten) she goes as far as she can with the character. Some critics accepted her over-the-top display and others balked -- part of the problem was a weak script.
In Ridley Scott's higher-quality "Prometheus," Theron is again trapped by a poorly developed supporting character in a script that doesn't give her much to do. In other words, Rapace has the Ripley role.
CAREER ADVICE: Because she looks the way she does, it's all too easy to use her in roles that require a minor amount of ability and depth -- and because those roles come from the films that have the easiest time getting made, it's an uphill battle to find material that will capitalize on Theron's muscular combo of supermodel looks and talent. It's no coincidence that it took "Monster" -- and Theron's complete physical transformation into Aileen Wuornos -- for audiences see just how good she is. But how often do films like "Monster" come around? In "Young Adult" she played a beautiful bitch instead of an ugly serial killer and it's clear which one was easier for audiences to swallow.
While men are allowed to grow into grizzled authority, women have to figure out a way to find character roles as they age. Theron is adding producing to her skill set as she becomes more proactive going forward. She realizes, as Sandra Bullock did, that she can't rely on the studios to look out for her best interests. She has to do it herself.