Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Errol Morris Stands Up for Unapologetic Donald Rumsfeld Doc 'The Unknown Known'

Interviews
by John Anderson
March 26, 2014 11:53 AM
5 Comments
  • |
Nubar Alexianan

Errol Morris makes documentaries. He also plays the cello. So a recent conversation in Manhattan turned from film to a performance the previous night of Mahler’s Ninth Symphony, and its eloquent silences. “You could go as far as to say silence is what the Ninth is all about,” Morris said. And you might say the same about the director’s latest movie.

“The Unknown Known,” which arrives in theaters April 4, takes its title from a pseudo-cryptic quote by its subject, Donald Rumsfeld, but also describes the subject himself. The former secretary of defense, a chief architect of the inexplicable Iraq War, doesn’t provide explanations in Morris’ documentary portrait. He doesn’t offer apologies. He doesn’t grasp the need for either -- or why anyone would question a man who seems incapable of questioning himself.

But it is that absence of introspection, or expression of same, that has left some viewers flummoxed, largely because they come to “The Unknown Known” expecting “The Fog of War.” That 2004 Oscar winner (subtitled “Eleven Lessons from the Life of Robert S. McNamara”) seems enveloped in a fog of its own: McNamara was less remorseful and more slippery that a lot of people seem to recall, even if Rumsfeld takes both of those qualities to an Olympian level. But because “Unknown Known” is an interview-based film, Morris had to expect comparisons.

“Well, of course,” he said over lunch in Soho. “I’d even expected there’d be invidious comparisons, because why make comparisons if they’re not going to be invidious? I used to say that Genesis got it wrong and it needed to be amended, because it assumes that the Heavens are better than the Earth. So if God created the Heavens and the Earth knowing one was better that the other, he must have first created the invidious comparison. “So I would like Genesis to read ‘and God created the invidious comparison, and saw it was good. And on that basis did everything else.’”

The director said that he made a list of things he expected people to say about the film even before he finished it. Among them: that there was nothing new in the film, and that he didn’t nail Rumsfeld to the wall. He rejects both.

“It’s not underlined in red,” he said of the new material in the film. “Rumsfeld was shown four different cuts as we gradually put the film together over a year – the understanding as that he would have no final cut, no right of approval, but that I would be respectful. And he would send me notes. I would often refer to him as ‘Donald Rumsfeld, D Girl’ (development girl) they were snowflakes in essence,” Morris said, referring to the name given the blizzard of memoranda Rumsfeld generated during his time with the Bush administration, and portrayed visually in the film as flaky precipitation.

“He’d say ‘This is wrong, I like this, I don’t like that, you should change such and such’ and I would write notes back to him. An example: He felt I should make it clear that the policies of the Bush administration in 2001 were no different than the Clinton administration. And that’s OK -- fair enough: You can request that I do that. But I’m not going to do that, because the policies were not the same.”

5 Comments

  • george | April 23, 2014 10:09 AMReply

    My view:
    Rummy is devious dishonest and unable to face what is was involved in. A master of sophistry.

    Morris reminds me of someone who has just set a bear trap and is now hiding in the woods to see what happens. Way to many tricks (music, superimposed graphics) to dramatize and manipulate the viewers emotions.

    Still worth seeing to fill in the gaps in my historical knowledge.

  • rumsfeldisapsychopath | April 7, 2014 3:49 PMReply

    rumsfeld is a psychopath. google "by, for and of psykopaths".

  • dale | December 16, 2013 8:52 PMReply

    I'm pretty sure Sec Rumsfeld understands irony. I'm equally sure that the word doesn't mean what progressives think it means.

  • Patrick | November 21, 2013 11:23 AMReply

    Having met Mr. Morris briefly he is a prickly sort but not excessively so. He has strong opinions, a healthy ego and he is keenly aware of criticism. But having seen this film he does what a documentarian does, or should do, which is accurately depict the subject, filling in documentable details that may be forgotten or conviently avoided by others involved.

    Rumsfeld has a particular ability to find the maximum amount of flexiblity and obfuscation in any statement he makes redefining things as he sees fit, something Morris details in last exchange with Rumsfeld in the film in which the term used for the title, "unknown known" is given a revised definition. The fact that Rumsfeld has no real contrition for his actions may be frustrating for viewers hoping to see more, but if it's not there in the subject that in itself is very informative as to just how effed up he was/is. And to his credit, Morris shows that characteristic of Rumsfeld in spades.

    The fact that Rumsfeld doesn't come to grip with just how disasterous his leadership was doesn't mean that history won't. Morris' film goes a long way to framing history's judgement.

  • Hey Harry | November 19, 2013 10:55 PMReply

    Quote "I used to say that Genesis got it wrong and it needed to be amended, because it assumes that the Heavens are better than the Earth. So if God created the Heavens and the Earth knowing one was better that the other, he must have first created the invidious comparison. “So I would like Genesis to read ‘and God created the invidious comparison, and saw it was good. And on that basis did everything else.’”

    Really?!

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

Email Updates

Most "Liked"

  • Sony Counters Bad Press with 'Spider-Man' ...
  • PBS Preview: Six New 'Makers' Documentaries ...
  • Toronto Film Festival Global Summit ...
  • Distribution Maestro Jeff Blake Exits ...
  • Trailers From Hell Opens 'The Doors ...
  • Trailers From Hell Loves 'All That ...
  • FIRST LOOK: Toronto Best Actress Candidate ...
  • Five Takeaways as 'Sex Tape' Flops, ...
  • Which World Premieres Did Venice La ...
  • Parker Posey and Jamie Blackley Will ...