The title “The Accidental Feminist” was used by M.G. Lord for her recent biography of Elizabeth Taylor, and I liked it a lot, and think it’s apropos to this situation too.
I’ve been thinking about this for awhile, and reading with great interest the tsunami of over-excited journalism that “Girls” in particular has generated. That’s one thing that HBO has got to be happy about -- if there’s no bad publicity, then “Girls” is doing great! And lately, the public has been talking about the characters on the show as if they were real people, criticizing the behavior of Hannah and her “sisters” as though they were disappointed in them, on occasion, like friends who let them down. “Girls” has also stirred a passionate sometimes divisive debate among its critics, with as many people hating these women as loving them, sometimes throwing stones without even having seen the target (a lot of posts start out, “I haven’t actually watched the show, because I don’t want to waste my time…”).
One of my favorite Hannah-watchers is the wonderful “New Yorker” writer and TV critic Emily Nussbaum, whose defense of Lena Dunham has so far been unflagging, and whose reminder to us of “Girls’s” literary and cinematic forebears -- Mary McCarthy and Rona Jaffe, etc -- was entirely on the money. Ms. Nussbaum came up with a new moniker for the type of character which I am obsessing over; she has named these women characters “Hummingbirds,” and announced them as a new television archetype. At first I thought she had simply preempted what I wanted to say, but as I have thought about the “Hummingbird” theory….I’m not sure we’re on the same page exactly. (Click here to read Nussbaum’s piece)
I feel like a Hummingbird is meant to be an agent of change. They are characters who ARE leading ladies -- or important secondary characters -- who are NOT necessarily likable. For me, that is the key here. But Nussbaum loses me in widening her theory so much that I am no longer sure what she’s identifying. In particular when she says there can be male Hummingbirds….I’m lost.
Read the rest of this article as originally published here.