Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Radius/TWC Takes 'It Follows' Wide in Theaters Friday, Pushing Back VOD Date Radius/TWC Takes 'It Follows' Wide in Theaters Friday, Pushing Back VOD Date Academy Governors: Let's Go Back to Five Best Picture Nominees Academy Governors: Let's Go Back to Five Best Picture Nominees Tom Ford Finally Unveils First Film Since 'A Single Man' with Producer George Clooney Tom Ford Finally Unveils First Film Since 'A Single Man' with Producer George Clooney Why It's Time for the Emmys to Adopt a Single 'Best Series' Category Why It's Time for the Emmys to Adopt a Single 'Best Series' Category The 10 Best Films I Saw at SXSW The 10 Best Films I Saw at SXSW The Breakout Star of Sundance's 2015 Grand Prize Winner Lands Her Next Plum Role The Breakout Star of Sundance's 2015 Grand Prize Winner Lands Her Next Plum Role Cannes 2015 Poster Sends a Love Letter to Ingrid Bergman Cannes 2015 Poster Sends a Love Letter to Ingrid Bergman Top Ten Box Office Takeaways: Why Women Like 'Insurgent' and No One Wants Sean Penn as 'The Gunman'  Top Ten Box Office Takeaways: Why Women Like 'Insurgent' and No One Wants Sean Penn as 'The Gunman' Why Hollywood is Discovering Colombia: from Medellín and Bogotá to Cartagena Why Hollywood is Discovering Colombia: from Medellín and Bogotá to Cartagena Arthouse Audit:  'It Follows' Expands as 'Danny Collins' Leads Openers and Unshelved David O. Russell Film Arthouse Audit: 'It Follows' Expands as 'Danny Collins' Leads Openers and Unshelved David O. Russell Film SXSW: Why Adrien Brody Bought a Run-Down Castle in Upstate New York to Save His Life SXSW: Why Adrien Brody Bought a Run-Down Castle in Upstate New York to Save His Life Hitchcock's 'Rear Window' Returns to Theaters Hitchcock's 'Rear Window' Returns to Theaters Watch: Lena Dunham Gets Abrasive in Seth Meyers' Writers Room as Hannah Horvath Watch: Lena Dunham Gets Abrasive in Seth Meyers' Writers Room as Hannah Horvath SXSW: How the Safdies Made Verité Drug Drama 'Heaven Knows What' with a Real-Life Ex-Junkie SXSW: How the Safdies Made Verité Drug Drama 'Heaven Knows What' with a Real-Life Ex-Junkie SXSW Wrap and Winners: Distributors, Pay Attention to These Films SXSW Wrap and Winners: Distributors, Pay Attention to These Films EXCLUSIVE: Horror Hit 'It Follows' Reveals Challenges of Theatrical vs. VOD EXCLUSIVE: Horror Hit 'It Follows' Reveals Challenges of Theatrical vs. VOD 'Two Lovers and a Bear,' Starring DeHaan and Maslany, Heads for Great White North 'Two Lovers and a Bear,' Starring DeHaan and Maslany, Heads for Great White North SXSW: ‘Trainwreck’ Star Amy Schumer Says “If You’re Against Feminism, You’re a Crazy Person” SXSW: ‘Trainwreck’ Star Amy Schumer Says “If You’re Against Feminism, You’re a Crazy Person” Will the 4th Book in the Millennium 'The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo' Series Recharge Sony Sequels? Will the 4th Book in the Millennium 'The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo' Series Recharge Sony Sequels? 9 Surprising Facts about Disney’s 'Cinderella' and One about 'Frozen Fever' 9 Surprising Facts about Disney’s 'Cinderella' and One about 'Frozen Fever'

Indie Release Mojo: Margaret, Dream House, Machine Gun Preacher, Drive

Photo of Anne Thompson By Anne Thompson | Thompson on Hollywood October 3, 2011 at 5:33AM

The box office wreckage this weekend reminds that it's usually NOT a good idea to take a movie away from a director, and how hazardous it is for indie films in this over-crowded marketplace.
3
Thompson on Hollywood

The box office wreckage this weekend reminds that it's usually NOT a good idea to take a movie away from a director, and how hazardous it is for indie films in this over-crowded marketplace.

Margaret. Filmmakers battling with studios over too-long edits of their movies are many over Hollywood's long history, from Eric von Stroheim and Orson Welles to Ridley Scott's Kingdom of Heaven. But it's depressing indeed to look at the fate of Kenneth Lonergan's sophomore outing Margaret, shot in 2005 with a strong ensemble--Anna Paquin, Mark Ruffalo, Matt Damon, and Matthew Broderick-- which was on the shelf so long that it became tainted goods and a reviewers' target by the time it opened to a woeful $7,496 gross and $3,748 average in two theaters (Searchlight had planned limited runs in 12 cities).

Thompson on Hollywood

The struggle involved two powerful producers--the late Sydney Pollock and Scott Rudin--insisting that financing producer Gary Gilbert not take the movie away from an auteur final-cut director, whose two-hour-50 minute cut (which Ruffalo calls a “masterpiece") didn’t meet Fox Searchlight’s contractual demands. Lonergan mentor Martin Scorsese and his editor Thelma Schoonmaker delivered a shorter edit, but no entity was willing to pay the fees to make it happen.

Nobody came out ahead here: not the fractious producers, the filmmaker, or the distributor. What could have prevented this debacle? Fox Searchlight had contractual length constraints, but in the end, wouldn't the longer and timely film have been better than damaged goods nobody wanted to see? (More details and review round-up here.)

Dream House. Irish auteur Jim Sheridan (My Left Foot, In the Name of the Father, In America) would seem an odd choice for a commercial thriller, but Morgan Creek wouldn't have landed class acts Daniel Craig and Rachel Weisz without him. Finally, after creative clashes between Sheridan and Morgan Creek yielded an edit no one liked, the stars withdrew from promoting the film and Dream House skipped critics screenings and grossed a meager $8.2 million. Again, nobody won. Except maybe Craig and Weisz, who fell in love on the set and got married.

Drive vs. Machine Gun Preacher: wide or platform release? Anthony D'Alessandro asked that question in his analysis of Warrior and Drive's box office performance. There was once a time when you could count on a good movie liked by critics building strong word-of-mouth in limited release. The guys at Sony Pictures Classics still believe in playing out their movies over time. They also have the earned clout to do so with exhibitors. They know their audience, and can calibrate just who will show up to what.

It may seem counterintuitive, but sometimes these days a movie is better off starting fast out of the box in order to reach a benchmark number. Why: The ancillaries. All advertising fuels future Blu-ray, Netflix, DVD and VOD. Thus Film District's Bob Berney argues that his "Reverse Platform" strategy for Drive is working like a charm. You spend as much opening on fewer screens, he points out. "We're cheating it a bit to get the mainstream audience in," he admits. "We wouldn't have gotten that audience the other way. This is a success, I'm proud of it, it's a radical violent film."

Drive opened to $11 million on 2900 screens, to awesome reviews but a C- Cinemascore--which tends to measure mainstream moviegoers reaction. Focus used this strategy with stylish smart Euro-thrillers Hanna (C+ Cinemascore) and The American (D-), which arguably pulled bigger crowds than they would have earned the old-fashioned way. Drive played best--shocker--in core film markets like NY and LA, where it competed with the likes of Contagion; it dropped 49% in its second weekend and 43% in its third (with a healthy 44% jump from Friday to Saturday) on 1794 screens. Even as the film organically pulls back to its strongest runs (thus the "reverse platform" concept), and lures younger crowds via its hit soundtrack, Drive is on track to gross about $32 million, which will get it into the black, even with a $24 million spend on P & A, and marks a solid 2.8 multiple of the first weekend.

When the marketplace is crowded with fall movies chasing the same smart audience demo, platforming can be a risky and expensive. Look at Relativity Media's Machine Gun Preacher, a heart-felt true story about a missionary in Africa directed by Marc Forster and starring Gerard Butler. While Lionsgate was reluctant to platform Warrior with an 84% Tomatometer score, Machine Gun Preacher did well considering it was at 23%. This weekend the film broadened from four to 33 screens and grossed $82,000 for a modest $2,485 per-theater-average and a ten-day total of $140,200. But did it play well enough to hold screens and keep going? It already lost its main house in San Francisco.

The hazards of platforming are real. "In the fall, if you platform and miss," says Berney, "you're dead." Like Margaret.

This article is related to: Box Office, Fall


E-Mail Updates






Festivals on TOH