Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...
Cary Fukunaga and Tom McCarthy Shake Venice with 'Beasts of No Nation' and 'Spotlight' Cary Fukunaga and Tom McCarthy Shake Venice with 'Beasts of No Nation' and 'Spotlight' Oscars Contenders and Cannes Breakouts Go to Miami Oscars Contenders and Cannes Breakouts Go to Miami How Well Do You Know the Golden Age of Animation? How Well Do You Know the Golden Age of Animation? The Dramatic Story Behind Satyajit Ray's 50s Masterpiece 'The Apu Trilogy' The Dramatic Story Behind Satyajit Ray's 50s Masterpiece 'The Apu Trilogy' Top 10 Takeaways: Two African-American Movies Draw Crowds as 'We Are Your Friends' Plays in Empty Theaters Top 10 Takeaways: Two African-American Movies Draw Crowds as 'We Are Your Friends' Plays in Empty Theaters Welles Whiz Peter Bogdanovich Says 'Other Side of the Wind' Will Start Editing This Fall Welles Whiz Peter Bogdanovich Says 'Other Side of the Wind' Will Start Editing This Fall With 'A Sinner in Mecca,' Parvez Sharma Puts His Soul and More on the Line (Exclusive Clips and Poster) With 'A Sinner in Mecca,' Parvez Sharma Puts His Soul and More on the Line (Exclusive Clips and Poster) Christopher Nolan to Address Film Preservation at London Film Fest Christopher Nolan to Address Film Preservation at London Film Fest Stream the Nightmarish 'Queen of Earth' Score Composed by Keegan DeWitt (Exclusive) Stream the Nightmarish 'Queen of Earth' Score Composed by Keegan DeWitt (Exclusive) Germany Submits 'Labyrinth of Lies' as More Foreign Oscar Picks Emerge (Exclusive Trailer) Germany Submits 'Labyrinth of Lies' as More Foreign Oscar Picks Emerge (Exclusive Trailer) TIFF First Look: David Oyelowo and Dianne Wiest Lead 'Five Nights in Maine' TIFF First Look: David Oyelowo and Dianne Wiest Lead 'Five Nights in Maine' Tarantino Opens Up about 'Hateful Eight,' Disses Cate Blanchett and 'True Detective,' and More Tarantino Opens Up about 'Hateful Eight,' Disses Cate Blanchett and 'True Detective,' and More Lynch, Fincher, 'True Detective' and the Unknowable Future of Auteur TV Lynch, Fincher, 'True Detective' and the Unknowable Future of Auteur TV 10 Things You Might Not Know About Pixar's 'Inside Out' 10 Things You Might Not Know About Pixar's 'Inside Out' Nicolas Cage and Mike Figgis Reunite for First Time Since 'Leaving Las Vegas' Nicolas Cage and Mike Figgis Reunite for First Time Since 'Leaving Las Vegas' 'The Tribe,' 'Wolfpack' Among 19 Films in 2015 SF Film Fest Competition 'The Tribe,' 'Wolfpack' Among 19 Films in 2015 SF Film Fest Competition 5 Films That Influence 'The Witch,' Sundance's Scariest Horror Movie 5 Films That Influence 'The Witch,' Sundance's Scariest Horror Movie Ten Hot Movie Pairings to Look Forward to in 2015 (Trailers) Ten Hot Movie Pairings to Look Forward to in 2015 (Trailers) Career Watch: Can Eva Green Rise Above Femme Fatale Typecasting? Career Watch: Can Eva Green Rise Above Femme Fatale Typecasting? Why Ten Years Later, Jonathan Glazer's 'Birth' Is Still a Masterpiece Why Ten Years Later, Jonathan Glazer's 'Birth' Is Still a Masterpiece

Is Emily the New Pauline?

Thompson on Hollywood By David Chute | Thompson on Hollywood July 25, 2013 at 2:56PM

The great TV critic Emily Nussbaum, in "The New Yorker," talks back to Brett Martin, author of the widely reviewed and excellent new book "Difficult Men: Behind the Scenes of a Creative Revolution: From ‘The Sopranos’ and ‘The Wire’ to ‘Mad Men’ and ‘Breaking Bad.'"
0
Lena Dunham and TV critic Emily Nussbaum
Lena Dunham and TV critic Emily Nussbaum

The TV critic Emily Nussbaum, in this week's "New Yorker," talks back to Brett Martin, author of the widely reviewed and excellent new book "Difficult Men: Behind the Scenes of a Creative Revolution: From ‘The Sopranos’ and ‘The Wire’ to ‘Mad Men’ and ‘Breaking Bad.'"

Her argument, in effect, is that Martin re-writes history in order to minimize the role played by one of her favorite shows, "Sex and the City" in jump-starting what Martin calls the Third Golden Age of Television. Along the way she issues a manifesto for the swarms of unembarrassed TV critics the TGA calls for:

"Why is (SatC) so often portrayed as a set of empty, static cartoons, an embarrassment to womankind? It’s a classic misunderstanding, I think, stemming from an unexamined hierarchy: the assumption that anything stylized (or formulaic, or pleasurable, or funny, or feminine, or explicit about sex rather than about violence, or made collaboratively) must be inferior."

There's a ring to this that's instantly recognizable: Nussbaum's sensibility as well as her Philosophy of Criticism, seems distinctly Pauline Kael-esque. In a stand-out column earlier this year ("Shark Week," 02/25/13), Nussbaum defended her preference for for the wild, shameless, campy "Scandal" over David Fincher's often grim and serious "House of Cards."

"…honestly, the more I watched (HoC), the more my mind kept wandering to Shonda Rhimes’s 'Scandal'— an ABC series that’s soapy rather than noirish but much more fun, and that, in its lunatic way, may have more to say about Washington ambition. … Popping with colorful villains, vote-rigging conspiracies, waterboarding, assassinations, montages set to R. & B. songs, and the best gay couple on television (the President's chief of staff, Cyrus, and his husband, James, an investigative reporter), the series has become a giddy, paranoid fever dream, like '24' crossed with 'The West Wing,' lit up in neon pink."

Although, she says, Nussbaum became devoted to the medium under the influence of "My So-Called Life," a canceled early classic of "quality TV," it's her populist streak, her unabashed love of mainstream television that strikes the ideal note for a TV reviewer, even in a Golden Age. The last time I felt an immediate buzz of kinship like that for the work of critic was (at the risk of dating myself) when Kael began writing about movies for (fittingly) the same publication.

This article is related to: TV Reviews, TV, Critics, Sex and the City, Scandal


E-Mail Updates








Thompson on Hollywood

Born and raised in Manhattan, Anne Thompson grew up going to the Thalia and The New Yorker and wound up at grad Cinema Studies at NYU. She worked at United Artists and Film Comment before heading west as that magazine's west coast editor. She wrote for the LA Weekly, Sight and Sound, Empire, The New York Times and Entertainment Weekly before serving as West Coast Editor of Premiere. She wrote for The Washington Post, The London Observer, Wired, More, and Vanity Fair, and did staff stints at The Hollywood Reporter and Variety. She eventually took her blog Thompson on Hollywood to Indiewire. She taught film criticism at USC Critical Studies, and continues to host the fall semester of “Sneak Previews” for UCLA Extension.