Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

Obit: New York Film Critic Judith Crist

by Aljean Harmetz
August 7, 2012 9:06 PM
1 Comment
  • |
Judith Crist
Judith Crist

Judith Crist, the tough, witty, and often caustic film critic who combined a passionate love for movies with an equally passionate distaste for movie rubbish, died Tuesday, August 7 at the age of 90.  According to her son, Steven Crist, she died at her Manhattan home after a long illness.

Director Billy Wilder once remarked that inviting Crist to review one of your films was “like asking the Boston Strangler for a neck massage.” And Wilder was one of her favorites. She was arguably the most powerful film critic of her era because of her two-prong status as main reviewer at both the New York Herald Tribune and NBC’s “Today” show.

Never afraid to take on the movie establishment, she famously described “Cleopatra,” 20th Century Fox’s mega-million-dollar 1963 catastrophe, as “At best, a major disappointment, at worst an extravagant exercise in tedium.  The mountain of notoriety has produced a mouse.” 

She called “The Sound of Music” (1965) “Icky-sticky” and dared to complain that “The Greatest Story Ever Told” (1965) was “a kind of dime-store holy picture.”  And of Otto Preminger’s “Hurry Sundown” (1967), she wrote, “To say that ‘Hurry Sundown’ is the worst film of the still-young year is to belittle it.  It stands with the worst films of any number of years.”  When that review won a prize, Preminger sent a telegram to be read at the awards dinner, “Congratulations on your night of triumph from the man without whom all this would not be possible.”

Yet, in reviewing Robert Altman’s version of Raymond Chandler’s novel “The Long Goodbye” (1973), Crist was sweeping in the opposite direction.  “The buccaneers have been making the Hollywood headlines recently what with the dismantling, absorbing and swapping of studios,” she wrote, “but it’s the adventurers, the creative risk-takers and myth-breakers, who provide the life’s blood of our movie experience.”

She praised Altman as one of those risk-takers and was an early partisan of directors Sydney Pollack and Woody Allen and of Steven Spielberg from the time of his first movie, “The Sugarland Express.”

Crist was the first female full-time  film critic at any major newspaper, and it took her nearly 20 years to go from a woman’s page reporter at the  Herald Tribune in 1945 to film critic in 1963.  Six weeks later she demolished “Spencer’s Mountain,” starring Henry Fonda and Maureen O’Hara with: “A film that for sheer prurience and perverted morality disguised as piety makes the nudie shows at the Rialto look like Walt Disney productions.”  Radio City Music Hall pulled its advertising from the paper.  The paper stood behind its critic.

  • |

More: Critics, Obit

1 Comment

  • Brian | August 8, 2012 1:06 PMReply

    I don't know how many of you have seen SPENCER'S MOUNTAIN (based on the same source material that provided the basis for "The Waltons"), but Crist was certainly right about it. It's all about teenage sex. IIRC, coquettish little Mimsy Farmer spent much of the film trying to give lucky James MacArthur (in the JohnBoy part) a roll in the hay. (Delmer Daves, the film's director, was obsessed with that subject. See also: A SUMMER PLACE, PARRISH and SUSAN SLADE.)

    When I was 12, I went with my father to an advance screening of BATTLE OF THE BULGE (1965). It was also a critics' screening (at the old Cinerama on Broadway). Outside, we discussed the film and I was all excited about it because of the action and spectacle while my father, a WWII veteran, insisted it had no relation to the facts of the actual battle. He later insisted that Ms. Crist was standing nearby because in her review the next day in the Herald Tribune she wrote something about how 12-year-old boys would find it exciting but old soldiers would protest.

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

Email Updates

Most "Liked"

  • Why Weinstein Is Re-Releasing Summer ...
  • First Gurus 'O Gold Pre-Festival Top ...
  • Emmy Watch: As TV Enters the Future, ...
  • Emmy Awards: Lena Dunham Wins the Red ...
  • The Radical World of Avant-Garde Master ...
  • Participant Joins DreamWorks' Spielberg ...
  • How David Byrne Collaborated with Jonathan ...
  • WATCH: Live Stream Emmys Red Carpet ...
  • Participant Media, Changing Its Stripes, ...
  • Remembering Actor-Director Richard Attenborough ...