Click to Skip Ad
Closing in...

TOH! Ranks the Best 'Pride and Prejudice' Screen Adaptations UPDATE (Clips)

Features
by Anne Thompson and Beth Hanna
August 15, 2013 2:10 PM
11 Comments
  • |
Jennifer Ehle and Colin Firth in "Pride and Prejudice"

With Jerusha Hess' "Austenland," starring Keri Russell as a Jane Austen obsessive, hitting theaters August 16, and the 200th anniversary of Austen's "Pride and Prejudice" celebrated earlier this year, we rank the best screen versions of the romantic classic which sees the uniting of bright, stubborn Elizabeth Bennet with the breathlessly handsome yet slow-to-warm Mr. Darcy. Video below.

For the P&P anniversary, Entertainment Weekly compiled a list of the many ways in which the novel has influenced pop culture over the years. While the classic has launched or cemented the careers of a number of A-list stars (hello, Colin Firth!), its effects also run deeper. EW posits that the now tried-and-true TV convention of romantic couples who love/hate each other comes straight from "P&P," and the novel has ultimately even renewed passionate U.S. interest in British culture (hello, "Downton Abbey"!).

Meanwhile, Colin Firth's Mr. Darcy is so ingrained in pop culture adoration that the character got his own 12-foot statue in London's Serpentine Lake.

1. "Pride and Prejudice" (1995, TV Miniseries) The BBC found the perfect Elizabeth Bennet-Mr. Darcy casting in Jennifer Ehle and Colin Firth. The series, expanded over six 50-minute episodes, manages to be faithful to Jane Austen's mischeivous sense of humor and swoon-worthy sense of romance without the trappings of a stuffy adaptation. A positively glowing Ehle is at once observant and sharp, stubborn yet insecure about her true feelings for the men around her. Firth is the definition of "dashing," and communicates smoldering yearning with his eyes while maintaining the stiff-upper-lip countenance that has become a signature for the actor as a romantic hero. (Since then, Firth has revisited a more contemporary Darcy opposite Renee Zellweger in the Richard Curtis adaptations of the "Bridget Jones's Diary" series.)

2. "Pride and Prejudice" (1940) For decades, Robert Z. Leonard's gorgeous black-and-white Greer Garson/Laurence Olivier romance was the Austen standard. Until Firth came along, Olivier defined the arrogant yet elegantly sensitive Darcy, who loves Elizabeth despite himself. Aldous Huxley was one of the screenwriters, and in also adapting Helen Jerome's popular 1936 stage play, many changes were made from the novel, most especially in a more sympathetic Lady Catherine de Bourgh. The movie was beloved by critics and won the Oscar for art direction; it holds an 88% Rotten Tomatoes rating.

3. "Pride & Prejudice" (2005) Joe Wright's wind-tossed version of the Austen classic is the director's best work to date, and the film on which he first collaborated with muse Keira Knightley. The actress gives her own spin to Bennet, making the character's stubbornness a tad spikey. It isn't exactly plausible that statuesque Knightley's Elizabeth would be the second-most attractive sister, but then gorgeous Elizabeth Bennets are the norm for the book's screen versions -- see Ehle and Garson. Donald Sutherland and Brenda Blethyn are magnificent as the night-and-day Bennet parents; Sutherland's performance is reserved and loving, Blethyn's performance is tittering and vapid. The one weaker point is Matthew Macfadyen as Mr. Darcy. He by no means turns in a poor performance, but he's in the unlucky position of having unbeatable acts to follow.

4. Seth Grahame-Smith's "Pride and Prejudice and Zombies" is floundering in development limbo, presumably dead in the water because of the poor reception of the film version of the author's "Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Slayer." For this we can be truly thankful.

11 Comments

  • senuka27 | September 13, 2013 4:34 PMReply

    what Arthur replied I am inspired that a single mom can profit $9451 in 4 weeks on the computer. navigate to these guys............x.vu/ZDQyMg

  • Anonymous | August 19, 2013 7:13 PMReply

    Woah, woah, woah. The 2005 adaptation with Keira Knightley shouldn't be so discredited. Not to say that the other adaptations are bad, because they certainly aren't, but Joe Wright's adaptation was a wonderfully artful film. Don't even get me started on the score... Absolutely sumptuous. And Matthew Macfadyen was a fantastic Mr. Darcy. He played the part with the perfect amount of mystery and vulnerability, so I really wouldn't say he was a "weaker point" in the film.

    Overall, I would say these adaptations really can't be ranked, because they're all different approaches to a beloved story!

  • linsky | January 29, 2014 5:56 PM

    I agree with this 100%..matthew macfadyen wasn't a weaker mr. Darcy..he potrayed it really well.

  • Mike | August 19, 2013 3:59 PMReply

    I would put the Joe Wright version above the 1940s version easily, that one was played up far too much for laughs with many of the performances being somewhat stilted or comedic where it shouldn't be comedic.

  • anonymous | February 10, 2013 2:09 PMReply

    I disagree about Matthew Macfadyen. He was great.

  • rgm | January 30, 2013 12:03 AMReply

    The 1980 BBC miniseries of Pride and Prejudice scripted by Faye Weldon (with a slightly more feminist slant) belongs among the best of the long versions. A personal favorite -- and definitely worth checking.

  • B C Molinare | February 3, 2013 10:15 PM

    Absolutely agree.....The Colin Firth version of Mr. Darcy may be sexy for today's audience.....but that version did not follow very closely the script of Jane Austen's masterpiece. It certainly did not appeal to a Pride and Prejudice devotee.

  • RealDogBoy | January 29, 2013 5:55 PMReply

    I'd put Wright's movie at #1 but I haven't seen the BBC mini-series.

    It's funny but all screen adaptations change one crucial thing about the story: that Elizabeth is (in the book) a physically unattractive young woman who has to compensate for that shortcoming by being very clever. The character is invariably played by a beautiful actress... contradicting a central point of the novel.

  • Katie | January 30, 2013 3:36 PM

    Thats actually not true. In the book Elizabeth's beauty is described only second to her sister Jane's in Herefordshire.

  • Bridget | January 29, 2013 3:28 PMReply

    'Lost in Austen' should have made the list. It's a really good series released a few years ago about a woman who finds herself stuck in the plot of Pride & Prejudice (while Elizabeth Bennett transfers to her modern world). Her presence sets the P&P plot on its head and the more she tries to get things back on track, the worse the tangle becomes. Fantastic series!

  • Julia B. | January 29, 2013 2:53 PMReply

    thanks for editing that massive mistake.

Free Indie Movies and Documentaries    

Email Updates

Most "Liked"

  • Ron Howard Rocks Beatles Concert Tour ...
  • Trailers from Hell Spends 'A Night at ...
  • WATCH: Knightley, Rockwell and Moretz ...
  • WATCH: Academy Videos of 'Originals’ ...
  • Read an Interview Between Richard Linklater ...
  • First Reviews of Woody Allen's 'Magic ...
  • Best of the Week: Peter Biskind's New ...
  • Summer Box Office Freefall Continues ...
  • Academy Elects New Board of Governors: ...
  • Will Mark Romanek Follow Kubrick Into ...